New Toy-Caution PBC Content

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

tbrtt1

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Was itching for a new toy. After all, its been nearly 3 months since my last new toy. I had the itch for charcoal smoker. I have an electric (SmokingIt #2 tricked out) a pellet pooper and now a Pit Barrel Cooker

First things First: Spare me the "dummy, you coulda built a UDS for 13 cents". I appreciate where you UDS guys are coming from but I ain't interested in building one. If I ever get a UDS it will likely be one made and ready to go. I build and mod guitars, I don't have enough time or desire to build other stuff. 

Anyway, I was intrigued and after much research figured this is a good way to get into charcoal smoking. Money is not an issue for me but I wasn't about to drop 4 figure coin on a Backwoods or Stumps, only to find that I may not like charcoal smoking at all. 

It arrived about 4 days after I placed the order. It was very well packed and included a couple of shakers of Noah's rubs. I make my own rubs, but I'll find use for it at some point (more on that later). Nice touch. 

Last night on the way home from the airport I picked up a bag of KBB some SLC ribs and a plump yard bird. I've been interested in trying my hand at some Jamaican jerk style ribs. So I made up a marinade for one of the racks to sleep in last night. 

I had a home office day today so it was a perfect day for me to test this thing out. Early afternoon I prepped the non-jerk rack and threw caution to the wind and put some of Noah's rub in that rack. Hung them up and about 2.5 hours in I hung the bird. 

No question about it, the chicken from this thing is the bomb. That alone will justify the purchase. My wife is not a BBQ fan but she raved about this chicken. Home run for me. My son will try some chicken and ribs later but I am sure he will approve. 

The jerk ribs were so so, but that is entirely due to my mediocre jerk marinade. It just didn't have the jerk flavor I was looking for. Plus, I am not into marinading meat so I may try a dry jerk rub in the future. The marinade does something to the meat that I don't like. The other rack was delicious. Noah's rubs were fine, and it was good to mix in some different flavors today. 

There are some things I will tweak but the learning curve should be short. This thing runs hot by nature so I couldn't be sure of timing. That combined with the curiosity had me peeking in way too much. 

This is a great addition to my arsenal and I will be cooking on it a lot as I get to know it better. 

Here are some pics. 





This is a nice little idea I got from somewhere to light the charcoal in the chimney. 



Cut off a few and ate them before I took pics. We almost devoured the whole chicken before I remembered to take pics of that. 





 
Off to a great start with the new cooker! I looked at them but went WSM as I could smoke that night! That's the best way to light the charcoal if you ask me.
 
Off to a great start with the new cooker! I looked at them but went WSM as I could smoke that night! That's the best way to light the charcoal if you ask me.
I like to smoke at night too and do with the pellet pooper. But I may add a WSM anyway. I like toys and I know they are great smokers.

Question: I added some health chunks of wood, but the predominate taste and smell on the food was charcoal. Not that I mind that, but I was expecting a little discernible wood flavor in the smoke profile. OK that was not a question, but this is; how is your smoke flavor? Do you taste the wood flavor? I guess I can run a batch of food without the wood chunks and see if I can tell the difference. 
 
What kind of wood did you use? Hickory is a good one and my personal favorite. Apple also goes well with pork. I'm not real sure about the UDS smokers, but I had a vertical charcoal smoker until a couple weeks ago, and always got great flavor from the wood.

I'm glad to say I upgraded to a WSM 18.5 last weekend and will be giving it a try this weekend.
 
Congrats on the new PBC! I have had one for about a year and I love it! As far as the wood chunks adding flavor, the PBC or any UDS gives food a taste that is very different from other smokers because of the juices from the meat dripping on the coals and vaporizing. Some people call it a grease fog. It's a somewhat prominent taste which might make it difficult to distinguish one wood from the others when you add chunks. Honestly, I have never tried to cook anything with straight charcoal because I am so used to adding chunks with my other cookers. No matter what wood I have added, I absolutely love everything I've made on it.
 
Off to a great start with the new cooker! I looked at them but went WSM as I could smoke that night! That's the best way to light the charcoal if you ask me.


I like to smoke at night too and do with the pellet pooper. But I may add a WSM anyway. I like toys and I know they are great smokers.

Question: I added some health chunks of wood, but the predominate taste and smell on the food was charcoal. Not that I mind that, but I was expecting a little discernible wood flavor in the smoke profile. OK that was not a question, but this is; how is your smoke flavor? Do you taste the wood flavor? I guess I can run a batch of food without the wood chunks and see if I can tell the difference. 

I get plenty of smoke flavor from the WSM. Maybe a little trial and error with how much wood you need to get the flavor your looking for. Maybe you can adjust your temp a little as well while you learn the new toy. How comfortable are you with that hanging food? That's the other reason I went WSM.
 
What kind of wood did you use? Hickory is a good one and my personal favorite. Apple also goes well with pork. I'm not real sure about the UDS smokers, but I had a vertical charcoal smoker until a couple weeks ago, and always got great flavor from the wood.

I'm glad to say I upgraded to a WSM 18.5 last weekend and will be giving it a try this weekend.
I used hickory. I like that WSM and see myself owning one in the future. 
 
Congrats on the new PBC! I have had one for about a year and I love it! As far as the wood chunks adding flavor, the PBC or any UDS gives food a taste that is very different from other smokers because of the juices from the meat dripping on the coals and vaporizing. Some people call it a grease fog. It's a somewhat prominent taste which might make it difficult to distinguish one wood from the others when you add chunks. Honestly, I have never tried to cook anything with straight charcoal because I am so used to adding chunks with my other cookers. No matter what wood I have added, I absolutely love everything I've made on it.
I think you are absolutely right. I understand and am somewhat familiar with the "grease fog" taste as I once or twice cooked semi-low-n-slow on my Weber Kettle. This is just my first go-round with smoking something for several hours where the juices drip into the coals. As mentioned I have experience with an electric and a pellet smoker. 

And I am not saying this was a bad thing, just different. 
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky