I can't speak for everyone, but the first batch of cheese I ever smoked I used Hickory. Took forever to mellow out. I use apple dust now with far better results.
I used 100% apple dust that I made from Lumberjack pellets the other night. After 2 hrs with my maze it was pretty good but I wanted it smokier tasting, so I Topped off the maze with the Comp dust I made using Lumberjack pellets. And I lit both ends and let it smoke for another 1 1/2 hrs. The smoke flavor was maybe just a touch heavier than I was shooting for but it should mellow a touch before Christmas day. I'll taste it and if it's just a bit strong still I will tell everyone to wait until New Year's Eve before trying it. And if it's still to smokey for them to give it another week or two and it should be fine by then.
I don't understand how some people say that they smoke theirs for 6 hours using hickory dust and it's ready to eat right off the smoker. The only I can think of is that they are using much larger smokers with a lot more air flow. I just used my maze and put it in my
Camp Chef pellet grill that was unplugged it has a 3'' vent. I put the maze under the defuser and 2 plates of salt on the lower racks, one had kosher salt and the other had coarse sea salt on them and the cheese went on the top rack with the vent cap removed for better air flow. I'm going to Costco in the morning for some gouda, horseradish cheddar and some mozzarella to smoke tonight. It's perfect temp for cheese smoking this week with temps in the 30's the smoke box never even got slightly warm to the touch, absolutely no oils formed on the cheese.
If you don't have a smoke maze you need one, they are worth every penny, and they flatout work awesome for cold smoking or adding more smoke to your pellet pooper during low and slow smokes, pick up a 10'' smoke tube while you're at it, you won't be sorry.
Thank you all for your help, I really appreciate all of your knowledge and expert advice.
Dan
P.S. I still don't like it right off the smoker, it needs a few days to mellow in my opinion. (even with dust)