• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

First Smoked Turkey…Results: Tasty but not picture perfect…

SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Compulsive Smoker

Master of the Pit
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Joined
Jul 17, 2026
Messages
1,128
Reaction score
1,134
Location
Mohnton PA
Most of you probably saw the post where I asked for anyone who had advice to share with tips for my young friend who is just getting into smoking.

Well there is nothing like first hand experience to enable you to help someone else, so I bought an 11 pound turkey and brined it for 36 hours in Meat Church’s Bird Baptism.

This morning I pulled it out and injected it with Meat Church’s Chicken Injections, then let it sit uncovered in the fridge for about 3 hours…

I tried using a stand, but my OKJ offset was not high enough so it went straight on the rack…
IMG_2275.jpeg

Had a charcoal base to get things started, but then ran with cherry splits the rest of the way tried to keep it mostly between 350* and 400* I struggled a little, because I’m not used to running this hot on this smoker so it was a bit of a learning curve, but it never went above 400*
IMG_2276.jpeg

1/2 hour in I foiled the wingtips to keep from burning too bad…
IMG_2278.jpeg

1 hour in …
IMG_2281.jpeg

Flip over to get color on the back…
IMG_2282.jpeg

Soon after this shot i sprayed it with olive oil thinking it would help crisp the skin
At about 2hours the skin started splitting…could this be from the oil???
IMG_2284.jpeg

Took about another 1/2 hour to get to 180* and the skin was very badly split by that time…I’d like to know why that happened? Running too hot?
IMG_2285.jpeg

IMG_2286.jpeg

2.5 hours…pulled and sliced the skin was crispy and very tasty, but plenty dark…
IMG_2288.jpeg

Plated with mashed potatoes and homemade gravy (from boiling the neck, gizzard, and section of the backbone that I cut out) corn with browned butter and store bought cranberry sauce…
IMG_2291.jpeg

Very tasty meal! The juiciest turkey I think I ever had!

But, id like some feedback on why the skin split so badly!

Thanks for looking!
 
Most of you probably saw the post where I asked for anyone who had advice to share with tips for my young friend who is just getting into smoking.

Well there is nothing like first hand experience to enable you to help someone else, so I bought an 11 pound turkey and brined it for 36 hours in Meat Church’s Bird Baptism.

This morning I pulled it out and injected it with Meat Church’s Chicken Injections, then let it sit uncovered in the fridge for about 3 hours…

I tried using a stand, but my OKJ offset was not high enough so it went straight on the rack…
View attachment 743531
Had a charcoal base to get things started, but then ran with cherry splits the rest of the way tried to keep it mostly between 350* and 400* I struggled a little, because I’m not used to running this hot on this smoker so it was a bit of a learning curve, but it never went above 400*
View attachment 743532
1/2 hour in I foiled the wingtips to keep from burning too bad…
View attachment 743533
1 hour in …
View attachment 743534
Flip over to get color on the back…
View attachment 743535
Soon after this shot i sprayed it with olive oil thinking it would help crisp the skin
At about 2hours the skin started splitting…could this be from the oil???
View attachment 743536
Took about another 1/2 hour to get to 180* and the skin was very badly split by that time…I’d like to know why that happened? Running too hot?
View attachment 743537
View attachment 743538
2.5 hours…pulled and sliced the skin was crispy and very tasty, but plenty dark…
View attachment 743539
Plated with mashed potatoes and homemade gravy (from boiling the neck, gizzard, and section of the backbone that I cut out) corn with browned butter and store bought cranberry sauce…
View attachment 743540
Very tasty meal! The juiciest turkey I think I ever had!

But, id like some feedback on why the skin split so badly!

Thanks for looking!
HI!
Glad the bird was GOOD! , That,s all that matters!.
Advice:
Temp was way too high !
EX: If you took a balloon and squeezed it, it will push out : Yur bird did that !
I w would start @ 300 Temp to below 350, 325 be idea.
Rack the bird in a pan if you can ?
If not lay a layer of Vegs in the pan : similar to campfire wood : elevate the bird.
try using a pan under the bird, even under the rack ?
Adding apple juice : 1/2 in to the pan, Its very important! Keeps it moist, breaks down protein , adds flavor !
If needed add water to the pan to prevent burning dry pan. no more Apple juice, too much Acid !
Turkey : Tuck the wings under the body. Have to swing the wing to make it work,
Foil the drums .
@ hour and a half/ 2 hours ?
Rotate the bird and Baste away !
Adding water if needed .
Foil the bird loosely if browning too fast ?
Dripping can be used for gravy , after separating the fat grease.
 
Another thing you can try if you're not going for the typical Norman Rockwell looking turkey is separate all the pieces of the bird and cook it that way. Turns out wonderful and you can remove the pieces as they get to their correct doneness. I'd show you pics if I could find mine. Not exactly sure who I learned it from... @thirdeye maybe??
 
Looks good from here. Never had skin split so not sure about that, skin to dry before going on though three hours in the fridge isn't really all that long.

It's a bummer the stand didn't allow for the bird to fit. It's the only way I do whole birds now.
 
If you cooked the breast to 180 it is way overcooked and is probably why split. Breast is done at 157. Legs thighs are good at 180 ish.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Back
Top
Clicky