First Fatty temp advice

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

thelinx004

Fire Starter
Original poster
Mar 12, 2014
35
13
Hellow fellow smokers,

I've been doing some reading on here before doing my first fattie and was hoping to get some confirmation before giving it a shot tomorrow night. I was already planning on doing some Scarbelly wings and thought I would put a fatty on with them just for good measure and I am now feedings a few more mouths. I know I've read to cook the fattie anywhere from 225-240, but if I'm doing wings I was hoping to run a tempurature closer to 275-300.

Would the fattie dry out to quick you think?

And at that temp my assumptions would be they would both get done around 1.5 hours?

Thanks for all your help guys, this site is the best!
 
The sausage for the fatty is full of fat so you shouldnt have an issue with it drying out. I cooked mine at 250. Took about 2.5 hrs. I dont see why you couldnt cook it at a higher temp, just wont get all the smoke that it would at a lower temp.
 
If you put cheese inside your fatty - at that temp, it is likely to burst out and leak.  I tend to cook at the lower temps with cheese filled fatties to get less leakage.  Other than that - no problems cooking it hotter - just less smoke flavor as Smoke Jenson said.
 
Thanks for the reply guys, confirmed my suspicion.  Although I never thought of the cheese spewing out at a higher temperature, that's a good point.  I will have to make extra effort when rolling it to tighten up the ends.  I'll be sure to update tomorrow with qviews.
 
Decided work wasn't as important and left a little early to give myself more time. Was able to get the fattie on for about 45 minutes 225-235 before getting the wings on. Just put them on and cranked her up to finish it all off
zybave8a.jpg
 
Farmer - fattie has a layer of smoked ham, provolone, pepperoni, mozz., and sauteed onions
y8uvaguq.jpg

Learned the hard way about putting all the toppings to the edge, made it difficult to roll up. Made a wrap in bacon for good measure
dy5u8ade.jpg
 
Luckily nailed having the fattie in for an hour and then finishing on high with the wings for an hour, both came out perfect! The sauce inside of the wings is like the second coming of Christ, I can't believe restaurants don't do this technique. You can see the sauce pouring out the inside on the picks below. Thanks everyone for all the help and taking a look. Enjoy the qviews

The cheese dripping on the wings, gorgeous.
yqa3e9y5.jpg


sa2a8uve.jpg


yzuguqu5.jpg
 
I feel horrible with all these pics I didn't get one, but when I break the leftovers our tomorrow I'll snap another pic. The oozing cheese just won't have the same effect ha ha

Sent from my DROID RAZR HD using Tapatalk
 
looks good.  I agree with the comment on the wings - I just love them this way.

One trick I use on the Fatty.  I put it lengthwise on a 2-foot piece of plastic wrap, then roll it in the wrap, then grab the two ends and twirl it around and around and around.  The plastic wrap compresses the fatty together and really helps to seal up the ends.

Happy rsmoking!
 
looks good.  I agree with the comment on the wings - I just love them this way.



One trick I use on the Fatty.  I put it lengthwise on a 2-foot piece of plastic wrap, then roll it in the wrap, then grab the two ends and twirl it around and around and around.  The plastic wrap compresses the fatty together and really helps to seal up the ends.



Happy rsmoking!

Used this technique thanks to the info here and the great step by step in the sticky

Innerds picture as promised
aqyby3a6.jpg
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky