First brisket a success - but a little dry.

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

dixiedog11

Newbie
Original poster
Jan 12, 2013
15
10
Apex, NC
I attempted my first brisket the other night.  It turned out pretty good, but not without some stress during the cooking.  

I was using a Masterbuilt propane vertical smoker and was smoking a 5.25 lb brisket. I put the soaked wood chips in a small cast iron skillet in the bottom instead of putting the chips directly on the burner.  It did not produce as much smoke as I was expecting. 

After reading many posts, I decided I would smoke it in a pan until it got to 170,then put it on the rack until 200, and then put it in a cooler for about an hour.  Well, after it got to 170 I took it out of the pan and put it on the rack.  But the temp proceeded to drop to about 145.  I thought my thermometer might be wrong but I used another one it was the same.  After cooking it for about an hour that way the temp did not rise very much.  So I was starting to panic.  I put it back in the pan and covered it with foil to see it that helped.  It starting rising again and I ended up taking it out at 195 deg and let it rest on the counter for about 30 min.  

I told my wife that there was about a 25% chance that it would be good and to be prepared to order a pizza.  But I cut into it and it turned out great.  Although a little on the dry side but not too dry.

Any tips on it not being so dry next time.

Thanks to all the threads already out there, they helped a lot.

Here are a few pics.


 
That looks pretty good from here. I am curious to where you read to Pan to 170*F and then go on the Rack? If you can find the Thread, please post the info or link. Most info I have read is the opposite. Smoke on a Rack to 160-170*F then go in a Pan with some Au Jus of other liquid, Foil and take to 195*F, rest and serve...JJ
 
That looks pretty good from here. I am curious to where you read to Pan to 170*F and then go on the Rack? If you can find the Thread, please post the info or link. Most info I have read is the opposite. Smoke on a Rack to 160-170*F then go in a Pan with some Au Jus of other liquid, Foil and take to 195*F, rest and serve...JJ

Back last summer when I was learning how to smoke and trying to hammer out my procedure, my dad was stedfast on telling me to keep it foiled all the way up til the last hour of the cook, which made ZERO sense to me. Gladly I didnt listen to him, because I think otherwise I wouldnt have had any smoke in the meat, and it would have been just baked pork, which I can do inside with a lot less headache.
 
You're asking how to get it so that it's not so dry--I recommend injecting and marinating with beef broth.  I'm still not a fan of brisket but Friday, I smoked an 11lb one and injected it with beef broth and then marinated it for ab out 7 hours.  I rubbed it with a cherry rub and smoked it.  Below is the final result.

 
You're asking how to get it so that it's not so dry--I recommend injecting and marinating with beef broth.  I'm still not a fan of brisket but Friday, I smoked an 11lb one and injected it with beef broth and then marinated it for ab out 7 hours.  I rubbed it with a cherry rub and smoked it.  Below is the final result.
How long did you wait to put it in the smoker after you put the rub on it?
 
Pics look great.  Looks like you got a smoke ring!

I do the opposite of what you described.  No secret, it is the same as the beef sticky http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/forum/newestpost/50979

I cook at 225-240 until brisket IT is 170.  Then I foil and put back on until 195 IT.  Then leave in foil and wrap in my wife's fancy monogrammed wedding towels and place in cooler for about at least an hour.

I know guys who smoke, foil, and unwrap for bark, but if it is too dry, you need to foil it longer.  IMHO.

I've cooked several brisket.  It takes a few times to get it just right.  Try and try again!

However, your picks look great!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky