Disappointed with amount of smoke; bought a master built electric 40" added updated part sent by mas

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Oh BTW... 30 degrees is a fine temp to cold smoke. Cheese has a lot of salt in it. Bacon is brined and the burning pellets will add 20-30 degrees.

JD
 
 
My sister actually lives in LLano, LLano Ranch, LLano Texas
That's cool. I think Llano is outside the Staked Plains region but I guess your sister lives on what once were open plains. I've only been through Texas once. I found out about the Llano Estacado from watching and then reading "Lonesome Dove" and in some Elmer Kelton Western novels. Looks like you and your sister live close fairly close (enough) to each other.
 
 
I guess I am one of the minority here. I have tried using my AMNPS for a long time with zero success in keeping it going. I've built the "mailbox" attachment, vented the smoker, followed pretty much everyone's suggestions and after a year of trying, gave up. It now sits idle in my used gear box.

What I did find works perfectly, every time is the MES cold smoke attachment (about $60 on Amazon). Consistent smoke, goes for hours and I can use it for any kind of smoking I want to do from cheese to turkeys.

Originally I used it on my MES30 and just recently upgraded to a new MES40 with the same results.  I know I will be boo'ed for my anti AMNPS comment, but that has been my experience. Wish it were different, but at least I have a really good alternative that works for me.
I hope nobody boos you, jsk53. Your experience is your experience. I've had smokes where the AMNPS worked like a charm and other smokes--both cold and hot--where it snuffed out a bunch of times. However, I chalk that up to what can be poor airflow in my MES 30 Gen 1. The proof of that was that outside my smoker and on the ground the wood pellets in the AMNPS kept burning for 30-40 minutes (if I lit them too early before the meat was ready) with no problem. But on those occasions after placing the maze inside my smoker the pellets would snuff out after 30 minutes or so and multiple times after that. Frequently, the pellets stay lit and smoking after the meat is removed from the smoker so I have to separate the lit from the unlit pellets to allow the smoking pellets to snuff themselves out. I leave the AMNPS in the smoker and close the top vent and make sure the wood chip loader and tray are both closed.

Bottom line is that you use what works best for you.
 
I have been using a gen 1 MES 40, for years!
Just got a Masterbuilt XL 44 gas, but I haven't needed extra smoke yet.

JD
JD, I haven't heard of anyone else posting about this smoker. Did you post a review or did you upload some Qview to illustrate any of the meats you smoked? What are you using for wood smoke, chips, pellets or chunks (someone on Amazon said he was using chunks)? What looks cool about the design--other than the cooking space--is you've got that lower door for loading wood chips or chunks so that you don't have to open the door to the cooking compartment. Looks like you're having fun with it.

Rick
 
Oh BTW... 30 degrees is a fine temp to cold smoke. Cheese has a lot of salt in it. Bacon is brined and the burning pellets will add 20-30 degrees.

JD
Man, I can't do 30 degrees. Poor circulation to my hands and feet in cold weather has always been one of the banes of my existence. My entire spine and the body that surrounds it aren't cold weather fans either. Not too surprising for a guy who grew up in the San Fernando Valley in southern CA. I've acclimated to the winter weather in the Puget Sound region but I've still got my limits.
 
Last edited:
Man, I can't do 30 degrees. Poor circulation to my hands and feet in cold weather has always been one of the banes of my existence. My entire spine and the body that surrounds it aren't cold weather fans either. Not too surprising for a guy who grew up in the San Fernando Valley in southern CA. I've acclimated to the winter weather in the Puget Sound region but I've still got my limits.
I am so sorry to hear. My hands / fingers are like that from being a stupid kid.
Be careful with temps and cheese. If certain kinds get to warm, you can wind up with a gooey mess dripping on everything! A real pain to clean up!!

JD
 
JD, I haven't heard of anyone else posting about this smoker. Did you post a review or did you upload some Qview to illustrate any of the meats you smoked? What are you using for wood smoke, chips, pellets or chunks (someone on Amazon said he was using chunks)? What looks cool about the design--other than the cooking space--is you've got that lower door for loading wood chips or chunks so that you don't have to open the door to the cooking compartment. Looks like you're having fun with it.

Rick
The MES 40 or the Masterbuilt 44" gasser?

JD
 

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/content/type/61/id/504056/width/200/height/400[/IM

[GALLERY="media, 504057"][/GALLERY]

[GALLERY="media, 504058"][/GALLERY]

I just got it(early xmas present). Did two burn ins and one test smoke of 3 slabs of baby backs. Then it got freaking cold!!

JD
 
Last edited:
Hey JD,

It might be cold there, but I'm betting the guy inside your smoker is nice & warm---The guy with the camera!! 
PDT_Armataz_01_12.gif


Bear
 
I am so sorry to hear. My hands / fingers are like that from being a stupid kid.
Be careful with temps and cheese. If certain kinds get to warm, you can wind up with a gooey mess dripping on everything! A real pain to clean up!!

JD
Thanks for the advice, JD. BTW, it was 16 degrees when we woke up. Now it's shot all the way up to 21 degrees and we're now heading out to go shopping.
 
Hey jimmy1957,

Thanks for the pictures. They are giving me lots of ideas. I see you made your smoker four wheel drive. That sounds like a great idea! I have a Lowe's close and I have a credit card. [emoji]128516[/emoji]

JD
 
Hey jimmy1957,


Thanks for the pictures. They are giving me lots of ideas. I see you made your smoker four wheel drive. That sounds like a great idea! I have a Lowe's close and I have a credit card. [emoji]128516[/emoji]


JD
I got the wheels at a auction for $3 and I had the wood so I just made the cart, Makes for moving the smoker real easy.
 
Hey jimmy1957,


Thanks for the pictures. They are giving me lots of ideas. I see you made your smoker four wheel drive. That sounds like a great idea! I have a Lowe's close and I have a credit card. [emoji]128516[/emoji]


JD
I got the wheels at a auction for $3 and I had the wood so I just made the cart, Makes for moving the smoker real easy.

I'll be looking at the local auctions. Great idea!

JD
 
Most electric smokers have a difficult time making decent smoke
Some do a better job than others.....

I came up with my first gadget, because I was just as frustrated as you with my brand new MES 40
3 years later and lots of happy MES owners out there who own one of my gadgets


Todd

I actually own this one. I got it from Sam's for $399. I noticed the other day they are still selling at that price.

Cons: you can't over load it because it won't work properly.
Pro: Never really had any other problems with it. I usually use Hickory chips. I smoked 4- whole Briskets at a time. 7 full spare ribs. Never had problems with not enough smoke flavor.
 
I am one of the minority that doesn’t sing the praises of the AMNPS.  I bought one and no matter what I tried I could never get it to keep burning. I followed the lighting procedures, tried it in the smoker in several different locations without success. I tried the “mailbox” system, added a fish tank air pump for flow and could just not get a long and consistent burn. That’s just my experience and I know others swear by the AMNPS.

Anyway, after looking for alternatives to the chip loader on my MES30, and later MES40, I found that Masterbuilt makes a cold smoke attachment for the MES. As I wanted to smoke some cheese anyway, I order one from Amazon and put it to the test. It worked perfectly as a cold smoker so I tried a batch of summer sausage using it as my smoke source. It worked great. Plenty of wood chips to keep smoke up for hours unattended.

With that said, it might be a good option if the AMNPS doesn’t fit the bill for you.  Here are some photos of my setup.



Lot's of good suggestions here and I'm sure you'll get set up the way you want it. I love my MES 40 and this was the solution for me, plus I can easily smoke cheese.  Best of luck.
 
 
I am one of the minority that doesn’t sing the praises of the AMNPS.  I bought one and no matter what I tried I could never get it to keep burning. I followed the lighting procedures, tried it in the smoker in several different locations without success. I tried the “mailbox” system, added a fish tank air pump for flow and could just not get a long and consistent burn. That’s just my experience and I know others swear by the AMNPS.
 
Lot's of good suggestions here and I'm sure you'll get set up the way you want it. I love my MES 40 and this was the solution for me, plus I can easily smoke cheese.  Best of luck.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The pellet smoker is a bit  finicky.  You really have to make sure it is lit, about a 10 minute burn is what I do.

As they say YRMV. ;)

BTW...  How do you like the MB cart? It does look sharp!!

JD
 
BTW...  How do you like the MB cart? It does look sharp!!

Thanks Smoker21.  I wanted to get the smoker up higher as I'm 6'4" and saw this online. As it's made for the MES40 I figured it would be perfect, and for the most part it is. The smoker locks down to the stand with provided hardware so it's solid and stable. The only shortcoming I saw was no rollers which meant it would have to be stationary wherever you put it.  I had an old set of casters and had a friend weld on plates to the bottom of the each leg, then tack weld the casters on the plate and now I can roll it around anywhere I want it to be. With that update, it's a perfect addition. I did have to build a stand for the cold smoke attachment though, but some scrap wood did the trick.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky