Austin XL 2nd smoke Top Round

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

smokinq13

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
May 21, 2017
427
194
south central Pennsylvania
I probably picked the worst temperature of this winter to try to smoke in( High of 4 last night) BUT there is no wind so it shouldn't be too bad ( I hope).

On the grill is a Top Round roast I picked up at Giant, They were/ might still be buy one get one free of equal or less value
Angus Top Round:
20190122_084532.jpg
20190122_084526.jpg

20190122_084510.jpg

They are right around 4lbs so It shouldn't take long. I FORGOT to take a picture after rubbing it down!! >.< oh well, I imagine everyone knows what it'd look like. I just did a simple rub of SPG, paprika for color and Montreal steak seasoning for more flavor and texture.

** one cool thing I learned is how to refill the store bought grinders that you shouldn't be able to get the lids off of. what you do is get a bowl of hot hot water and flip it upside down into the bowl covering the whole top part of the grinder. the plastic will soften and after 15-30 minutes you should be able to pull them apart. Stupid they make grinders that are one time use.
Non-reusable grinder being reused:
20190122_085154.jpg
20190122_085157.jpg


Just make sure you get the grinder and container part completely dry before refilling it.

This is my second actual smoke on this grill and I'm using my new Therm-Pro TP-20 thermometer to watch both the grill temp and meat. It being so cold out, I dont want to check of it flaming out. Which as soon as I was typing that last sentence my alarm went off about the grill getting below my low alarm setting, this thing is great! Highly recommend one if you dont already have one.

Therm-Pro:
20190122_091101.jpg
20190122_093107.jpg


My process this time is to use the "smoke" setting on the grill for about 2-3 hours first then up to a 225 for the rest. the last time I smoked on this my food didn't have enough smoke flavor which I realize that I wasn't using the smoke setting at all which probably could have been the problem.

This is a lender piece of meat so I'll be wrapping it when it reaches 150. Most pictures to come is I remember
 
Looks great! Let us know how it turns out. I’ve only smoked one once and it turned out like shoe leather. Dogs didn’t even want to eat it.

Now I usually put unseasoned meat tenderizer on mine then marinate in dales and Worcestershire. Quick sear on the grill both sides to medium rare and slice real then against the grain.
 
Looks great! Let us know how it turns out. I’ve only smoked one once and it turned out like shoe leather. Dogs didn’t even want to eat it.

Now I usually put unseasoned meat tenderizer on mine then marinate in dales and Worcestershire. Quick sear on the grill both sides to medium rare and slice real then against the grain.

I never had done one but I'm hoping doing it low and slow and wrapping it will help tenderize it. We'll see
 
Looking good . Where you located in Pa smoking13 we have a Pa gathering in Sept. look under events and get date and info be glad to have you. Its near Port matilda.

Warren
 
IMO you will not be happy with your results the way your cooking it. Top round IMO should be smoked or grilled to 130-140 max then rested. After the rest slice it thin. Top round is used for pit beef back in MD alot. Its great but there isn't much fat or connective tissue in there so if you wrap and take higher than 150 like it sounds you might I fear it will be tough and dry.
 
IMO you will not be happy with your results the way your cooking it. Top round IMO should be smoked or grilled to 130-140 max then rested. After the rest slice it thin. Top round is used for pit beef back in MD alot. Its great but there isn't much fat or connective tissue in there so if you wrap and take higher than 150 like it sounds you might I fear it will be tough and dry.

Yeah after researching a little I realized that the way I wanted to cook it is more intended for chuck rounds... so Pit Beef sandwiches it is. I'll be pulling it when it reaching a internal of roughly 135, I'm going to heat up some beef broth and wrap it in foil with some broth to help keep it moist and hot. Thanks for all the information.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bmudd14474
Yeah after researching a little I realized that the way I wanted to cook it is more intended for chuck rounds... so Pit Beef sandwiches it is. I'll be pulling it when it reaching a internal of roughly 135, I'm going to heat up some beef broth and wrap it in foil with some broth to help keep it moist and hot. Thanks for all the information.


Sounds like Brian steered you right on Temp!!!
The Biggest thing I've found on all the Rounds (Top, Bottom, or Eye) is to slice it as Thin as you're able, after smoking.
Makes Awesome Sammies!!

Bear
 
So pulled it at 135... wrapped in foil with some heated broth, into a cooler with a towel... how long can it rest for in this state? Im looking at another 2 or so hours before supper time
 
Results:
20190122_171622.jpg


Not the traditional way of eating it but still good! Served on a slice of bread with thinly sliced onion and jalapenos for a bite, side of red roasted potatoes in air fryer and green bean casserole.

Smoke ring:
20190122_171149.jpg
20190122_170924.jpg


I put too much pepper on it, I mean it was still good but little powerful.

Before cutting:
20190122_142557.jpg

The smoke flavor was there more than my first smoke on my Austin XL, can't wait to see what's next... thanks for stopping by!
 
Looks great I’d eat that in a heartbeat! Try pulling it 10 degrees earlier next time and giving it a nice reverse sear on the grill I think you will like the results!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky