A steak by any other name.....

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Hill Country

Fire Starter
Original poster
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Feb 5, 2018
57
3
New Braunfels, Texas
I’m a huge proponent of the Paleo diet plan. Translation- I eat red meat. Lots of it. Unabashed. No apologies or concerns. I’m going to die of something at some point. It won’t be from lack of protein. I’m a frequent guest of Brazilian steakhouses and decided to try some of my favorite cuts grilled and no rotessirie. (Side note: Rotessirie is the same in English and Portuguese.). I wanted my first trial run to be Picanha. Or Rump Cover, Sirloin Cap, Coullote, Tri Tip, or whatever name you’d like to pin on it. I started asking around at the local grocery store meat departments and no one had what I was looking for or were not willing to custom cut one for me. Next went to one of the few local butchers and he said no problem they’d cut me one. Paid 6.39/PD for it and much to my dismay when I opened it up it was just a chunk of sirloin. You can see the Picanha in the right hand piece below. It’s the piece that’s on the upper right with the grain running in a different direction. Chalk one up to experience. BTW, it still tasted really good! (It’s red meat, enough said.).

7E528006-BFED-44FB-8464-B0654CEAA4D6.jpeg


Ended up going to a Mexican meat market in San Antonio. They knew what I wanted and simply asked how many pounds. The untrimmed piece is pictured below. It was 4.99/PD.

55A23324-633A-4757-9EB3-E88048878492.jpeg


This is after I trimmed it a litttle, very little needed and seasoned it for searing.

E793D9DF-B5FF-4D64-A767-CED9AF0B3C05.jpeg


Thought I’d share a picture of the “cap” since it was showing.

F7AC7F8F-0D54-4B57-BB83-310EED7E9EC0.jpeg


Post searing and a few minutes on a really hot grill. (500 degrees)

D1B07368-1332-4F27-80BC-F1BEA62AE5CD.jpeg


Sliced and ready to be seasoned for final cooking.

95525498-7E85-4788-9294-1DBB03354440.jpeg


Right off the grill. For this run I got the grill steady at 400 then cooked each side for 6 minutes and finished with just enough time over the coals to produce a nice char.
The two that look more charred are for a friend who doesn’t know any better and likes his medium to medium well. Haha
C4742B72-968F-4251-B846-50FCB1FB21D8.jpeg


For some reason this picture doesn’t show how juicy it really was. I was happy with the overall outcome. Great flavor, not as tender as I would have liked. Compared to a regular sirloin it was very tender. Guess it’s all relative like everything else. lol. But I didn’t cut it as thin as they do at Galpoa Gaucho either. Next time I will cook the whole piece to an IT of around 100 at a lower grill temperature, slice it and finish to medium rare.
B3A55105-52D5-4871-8CFA-B855A4FE5225.jpeg


I would also like to try what they call bottom sirloin. It is extremely moist and has a different flavor. I think it might be well marbled throughout and the high temperature they cook with renders the fat until its oozing everywhere. I’ll post when I do. Tommy
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
johnl..... I cooked more this evening. Only downside is that unless you have numerous rotisserie’s it’s really like long term snacking. Haha... you slice off a few thin pieces, season, put it back on the grill. And repeat over and over. But wow is it delicious..
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky