3 3lbs Chucks soaked in a beer brine then smoked over mesquite.

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

hemiii

Newbie
Original poster
Jul 26, 2012
16
10
Inwood, WV
Couldn't find a brisket in time to brine so I bought these 3 lbs chuck roasts to try instead.
I made a beer brine last night and have had them soaking for 14 hrs so far. I made sure I cut little slices into the meat and got garlic into them and swished the bag around halfway through, about 8 hrs into the soak.
So in about 2 more hrs I'm gonna start these bad boys. I'm gonna use a mixture of mesquite charcoal to keep the temp steady around 215-225 and wet mesquite wood chunks for my smoke. I'm also gonna pour the brine into a pan under the chucks just to keep things moist. Then near the end I'm gonna mop on my Jack Daniels sauce. This is making my mouth water as I type this.
Any pointers would be awesome. I'll be posting pictures as I go.

Wish I would of got a clearer pic here but that's one of the 3lbs chucks with the garlic in the slits:


This is all 3 chucks in the beer brine. I used a 2.5 gallon ziplock bag just so there is no air and they get completely covered:
 
Right on, thanx NivekD. Yeah I normally don't soak my wood for more than a half hour. I guess I'm just using the soak as a temp control I guess. That's good to know about the pan too. If it goes dry I usually add beer to the pan as it evaporates plus it just adds more flavor. Can't wait to get started. I've got a meat thermo handy this time, so I just want to make sure when the internal temp reaches 190 it's done or should I go a little longer? I haven't been able to read too much but I read I should smoke these just like a brisket. Probably gonna take around 6 hrs being 3+" thick or should I just stick to the thermo and pull them when they reach a certain temp?
 
Gonna' let the offset pros take it from here...I use a verticle gasser and have no experience with an offset...but my previous suggestions are still valid. I've only done one chuckie and it turnied out ok but not what I expected...I think I under cooked it. Your smoke looks good. Keep us posted with your progress.
 
If you're patient enough to let em get to 205° I think you'll be happier. I usually take my chuck to at least 195° for pulling but IMHO 200°-205° has been the magic temp window for me.
 
This is almost done:


This is about how it looked through my eyes (I was pretty sauced), words don't describe how amazing they turned out except for this picture of what was left:
 
Yeah I never tempt them, lol. Pretty much just started eating them when we couldn't take much more. Which was 5-6 hrs into the smoke soak. I remember having a hard time getting it above 209 for some reason. Weird huh? Maybe it was because of that big pan of brine I put under it. But yeah those chucks were freaking amazing!
 
Looks pretty good from here...JJ
 
Your smoker is the same as mine, I enjoy using it.  I have no problem getting mine up in temp, at one time it got over 350 when I was busy doing something else.  I use lump charcoua for cooking and usually hickory for flavor.  Have you tried lump?  I found it to be better than briquettes.  Keep on keeping on.  Steve
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky