2 in 1... first cook on the wsm, first chuck

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Workaholic

Smoke Blower
Original poster
May 12, 2019
139
59
KANSAS
So there I was, digging through the freezer. Found a chuck roast in there. Wife had me get it out, and I managed to talk her into letting me smoke it.
So, I fill the wsm with RO lump. Find half a dozen or so big chunks and set them aside for lighting. Mixed in several pieces of apple chunks, since I had it on hand. Lots of smaller pieces in that bag, including several that definitely looked like they had started out life as dimensional lumber. Hopefully it was untreated oak or something similar. Pulled my little coffee can and tossed in the half lit coals. Came up to 200 fairly quickly, I adjusted down the intakes until 2 were closed and one only maybe a bit over 1/8 inch open, with it settling in at about 250.
While it was settling in, I went in and prepped. The chuck got slathered with mustard,and then a heavy dusting of rub. The rub was equal parts (1 Tbs) salt and pepper, and then a tough more of the onion, garlic, and some creole seasoning (1.5 Tbs each). Also cut up a few taters, stalks of celery, an onion, and some carrots, which went in a disposable half pan along with 2 cups beef broth. Onto the smoker they went, with the half pan centered on the bottom rack, and the roast right above it.
As seen in another thread here, it stalled. And stalled. About 4 hours worth, maybe 5, all the while I was thinking it would come out of it. Boy was i wrong. Thanks to some help here, I managed to get it out of the stall, by wrapping it and boosting the temp up to 285ish. But i didn't wait until 208. Once it had been at 199 for a couple minutes, I decided to pull it early.
Below, hopefully the pics will be in order. I have to admit, it was quite a bit better marbled than I expected, since it was gotten at Aldi's.

20191005_135734.jpg
20191005_140227.jpg 20191005_140356.jpg 20191005_140828.jpg 20191005_212038.jpg 20191005_212043.jpg 20191005_212507.jpg 20191005_212747.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: yankee2bbq
Lessons learned:
1. I will not be using lump again, once this is all gone. For the first few hours, which includes into the first hour or so of the stall, I had a heck of a time with temps going up and down, and I had to go shake things up and adjust the intake. And I was very disappointed with the bag of RO lump. Next time, briquettes, and probably stacked, at that.
2. If it stalls, it stalls. But don't wait 4 hours to ask for help.
3. Have more flavors of wood on hand. Apple is good. But a bit light for beef. Best used on poultry and pork.
4. If doing veggies again, more liquid is needed. There wasnt enough left for gravy. Although the roast would have made an amazing hot beef sandwich.
5. Put the smoker on the end of the patio, not out in the yard. Easier to get to, and if it goes past dark, the outside lights will help. They didn't do anything for me with where the wsm was.
 
Last year I got a lot of scrap in Royal Oak lump. I’ve switched to B&B lump and it’s awesome. Ace Hardware carries it in my neck of the woods in Ohio. I agree on the wood. I like at least some hickory for beef. I mix hickory and cherry a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Workaholic
Congratulations on the your first smoke on the WSM! Your chuck roast loooksss good! Great job!
I’ve strictly use royal oak briquettes for my low and slow smokes. Save your lump charcoal for temps 300-350. Like you stated above, lump charcoal burns hot!!!
Anyway, you did good!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Workaholic
Thanks for the kind words. It was an experience. One of these days I'll have to repeat it, just without the long stall.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky