Mystery Briskets?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

sniltz

Meat Mopper
Original poster
May 21, 2008
228
11
China Grove, NC
I have a mystery that has happened the past several times now.  I will cook several briskets and one or two will come out perfect while the other ones are still bloody or way under cooked.  It also will do it on my pork shoulders.   This is how I prepare them.

I will trim the fat off the flat and some off the point them flip it and shave down the fat cap some.

Then I use Coke and beef broth to inject into it, then put a heavy rub on it.

I put in on the smoker (which is a Texas style offset smoker) fat cap down.

I leave it there for 4 to 5 hours and then wrap it for the remainder of the time.  I cook hot temps around 300 degrees for about 10-12 hours. Depending on the size of the brisket.

The size I use is between 12-14 pounds brisket.

I have used this method for years and years.  But, until recently they have always turned out nice, really nice.  Good smoke ring.  It will have a little pull to it but, be tender and really good.

But, this new thing is puzzling me!   I prepare every brisket the same way and 1 or 2 will be great the rest will seem done but, when you cut into them the meat is stringy and a little bloody.  (Medium Rare ish).  And Now my Pork shoulder are starting to do the same. I don't know what I'm doing wrong.  If you have any advice or question that might help please let me know.  
help.gif
 
Are you just cooking by time? Do you check the internal temp of the meat?

Every piece of meat can cook differently even if they look identical.
 
No have always gone by look and touch to see if briskets are done.  The only thing I have every probed is my chickens.  But I will try probing the brisket and see how that turns out.  I learned from my father and that was the way he always did it.  Yes I monitor the temp very well.  Thanks for the advice and if anyone else has an idea please fill free to let me know.  Thanks.
 
I don't have much with cooking briskets.

But I do find these couple things effect my cooks in a smoker and the oven.

Hot spots? Are your temps running even in your cook chamber? I find that I need to move my pork butts around during the cooks.
When we do a lot of roasts in our ovens we find that some do cook faster then others. No good reason why. Just some guesses like beef density, marbling and quality of the meat.
Aliens have messed with the beef and they are testing you for patience....... :biggrin:
 
Just wanted to thank everyone for their input.  It was very helpful.  I cooked 2 briskets today and they turned out beautiful!!!  I still did it the way I have always did it but I used 3 digital thermometer.  2 for the brisket and one to check out grate temp.  Found out that the grate temp was a little off and it takes anywhere from 14 to16 hours to cook the briskets.  I wrapped the briskets when they got 160 on the thermometer and then it hit its plateau. It took about an hour for the temp to start to rise and then I  took them off at 195. I let them rest for 30 minutes before cutting into them and they turned out wonderful!  Good smoke ring, and nice bark!  It tasted so good.  Again thank you for the advice it was put to use.

Sniltz
 
Snitz, glad your results were good.  I have learned that keeping a close eye on both IT of the Meat being smoked as well as the temp at cooking level helps you get the best results.  Keep on keeping on.  Steve
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky