The Beginner's Foolproof Guide to Perfect Brisket EVERY TIME!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
I've learned a few things since I wrote this write up.

1.) Ditch the beef broth injection method.
2.) When you trim the fat off your brisket, take the fat trimmings and put them in a large pot on the stove and cover. Set the stove to setting 2 or 3. Let it render liquid beef tallow.
3.) Filter the liquid through a mesh ladle or mesh scoop into a container.
4.) Inject liquid beef tallow into your brisket (after you apply your rub).
5.) put an aluminum tray under your rack to catch the juices.
6.)Ditch the wrap method (no foil or butcher paper). Why? It isn't necessary. It's personal preference. I have done both. The turkey bag method retains moisture in the brisket the best.

Now you can go one of two ways here.

Method 1.) For the BBQ Purists
  • continue the smoke till the brisket is probe tender or about 197° I.T. (It should be jiggly like jello).
  • Pull the brisket.
  • Put it in a turkey bag.
  • Filter the juices from the aluminum tray through the mesh ladle into a container.
  • Pour juices over the brisket in the turkey bag.
  • Force all air out!of the bag, tie it off with a zip tie.
  • Wrap in a towel.
  • Wrap in a second towel.
  • Toss in a cooler for 3-5 hrs. The brisket will continue to cook and render.
  • Remove from cooler, towels and turkey bag
  • Brush with beef tallow.
  • Slice and serve.

OR


Method 2.) For those who have limited time
  • continue the smoke till the brisket has established a firm bark that doesn't wipe away when you touch it.
  • Preheat oven to 275° F
  • Pull the brisket.
  • Put it in a turkey bag.
  • Filter the juices from the aluminum tray through the mesh ladle into a container.
  • Pour juices over the brisket in the turkey bag.
  • Force all air out of the bag, tie it off with a zip tie.
  • Put the brisket in a pan or on a large cookie sheet and put it in the oven.
  • Set a timer and CHECK IT EVERY 15-20 mins OR SO! Until it's probe tender or I.T. IS 197° F (should be jiggly like jello). Do NOT run off and forget about it. You will have a dry brisket if you do. (Ask me how I know...)
  • Wrap in a towel.
  • Wrap in a second towel.
  • Toss in a cooler for 3-5 hrs. The brisket will continue to cook and render.
  • Remove from cooler, towels and turkey bag
  • Brush with beef tallow.
  • Slice and serve.

Method 1 or Method 2 really comes down to personal preference. There is no right or wrong answer or preference here.

I personally go with Method 2. Why? It saves me from having to reload the smoker with charcoal and wood. It saves wood and charcoal for another smoke. It saves me on time that I can use to shutdown the smoker, clean up and work on other food prep for side dishes and desserts and kitchen clean up.

Also, once you establish a firm bark on the brisket, smoke has already penetrated the meat completely.

There is nothing to be gained by leaving it on the smoker for the entire duration. The oven will finish the job and you don't have to worry about temperature spikes or the fire dying out and running late and not having the food ready on time for family or guests.

Enjoy and Smoke On!
 
Lighter fluid ? NOPE!
Not only does it affect the meat, It also clings to the Grill/ Smoker walls to affect later cooks?
7 hour thaw in a sink ?, Think not !
Make sure the meat is still sealed :
Thaw with a pot/bowl fill with water and rotate water every 30M, up to 2 hrs to head start the thawing process. It will pull the coldness out ! Then into the fridge for a few days. Rotating it every few hours to help the thaw. Not a fan of Turkey bags, they Stink !
Maybe use a Dutch Oven with a lid ?
Lower the Temp? IDK?
The Dutch Oven will maintain a constant Temp.
It be easier to add liquid ?

Other then that? seems to be a good write up !
Enjoy ! ELF
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: MileHighSmokerGirl
Very good write up. Haven't thought of using a turkey bag before, makes sense to me. I've used them for other things in the past and always had good luck with them. To each his own
 
  • Love
Reactions: MileHighSmokerGirl
Very good write up, Hannah. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. I know for sure that it will help others get good results from their next, or first, brisket. I may not agree with everything but I certainly realize the value in what you have written. Again, thank you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MileHighSmokerGirl
Thanks for the writeup. One of many ways to cook a brisket. Glad it works for you. The turkey bag is an interesting idea. My last brisket I separated the point from the flat but left a couple of inches still attached. It worked out well and the flat and point finished at same time which is something I have had issues with in the past. It also makes it easier to make burnt ends since dont have to take the whole packer out to finish separating.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky