Please critique this conversation

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

mossymo

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
May 30, 2007
4,988
1,814
Glenburn, North Dakota
On a hunting and fishing site, this is the current conversation. I am speechless, with a loss of words of what to say without sounding rude so my intentions are not to reply anymore. I think you all can guess which one I am. I would value anyoneâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]s opinion on this though.

Member 1 - I just did some venny jerky last weekend and it came out awesome! We used my brother-in-law's smoker. He's got a propane smoker with a chip tray and a liquid tray and 4 racks. I cut up 3 large venison roasts into good sized pieces (some were almost steak size). I bought the Cabela's Sweet and Hot jerky seasoning. I soaked it in the mix for about 24 hours and we smoked it at about 350 for 45 mins. to an hour. Best jerky I've ever had. We used a bag of hickory wood chips and put apple juice in the liquid bowl. I would recommend thicker chunks of meat as they turn out almost like roast beef.

Member 2 - Shadsky
This is meant as helpful advise and not to knock your jerky smoke at all. Glad to hear you made jerky that turned out great !!! Just hoping any experience I have had can help with your next jerky smoke.

When you say cut into thicker chunks because they turned out like roast beef. I would instead recommend thinner chunks and a much lower smoker temp than 350º. Smoking it at a lower temp make sure you have cure added or it was included in your seasonings. This will protect the meat during low smoking temps and help preserve it for safe eating later on.

Try a 1/2" to 3/8" cut and keep smoker temps around 150º. Smoke the jerky and every 1/2 hour to 45 min give it a spray of apple juice for moisture and taste. Rather than a water pan filled with apple juice, fill it with water and save the apple juice to spray on the jerky. Then when the jerky is getting close to what you feel is done, more frequently start checking the texture of the jerky for when you feel you want to pull it out from the smoker. Remember, when you pull it from a warm moist area, it will dry more rapidly until it is at room temp. Cover the jerky with a damp towel to cool and it and retain moisture.

This will take much longer than 45 min. but I think if you do try this, you will be even more happy with your end product.


Member 3 - I been smoking since a kid at my uncles cabin, and we did everything from fish to beef and I have say a good slab of smoked sucker is da bomb!

I currently have an Big Chief elect. and a Brinkman wood/charcoal fired, I prefer the set it and leave it with the electric although nothing is better than a slow smoked turkey basted in a Miracle Whip and mustard combo.


One of my favorite meats to smoke other than turkey is a pork roast, rub it with cavendars and garlic pepper place on top rack and smoke 3 pans of chips over about 2 hrs then move down to the middle and let it go for another 12 hrs. it will look like a big hunk of jerky although when you cut it you have a very tender ham like treat.

My favorite smoking woods include green poplar, Box Alder, and maple. I rarely buy chips except for a little Mesquite.
Soaking dry chips does not give the true smoke flavor like a slow burning piece of moist fresh wood. If you use green wood I would suggest to use small poplar branches that have recently died off and lost their leaves, or fresh Box Alder. DO NOT USE ANY OF THE ELMS! They can give a real terrible taste.
 
I wouldn't go there. The other member has a mind set in stone.
 
I would say if you are already thinking of not replying anymore than go with your gut feeling and save the hassle.

Personally I take everything on forums with a grain of salt, not everyone will agree, and opinions on just about everything vary wildly. I am also one of those that doing take differing opinions as a personal attack.

If you are worried about sounding rude, then leave it alone, sort of sounds like your opinion would not be welcomed anyhow from what I got out of it.

Good luck with either route you take.
 
I think that replying will just start a flame war. I would not continue that "conversation".

Take care, have fun, and do good!

Regards,

Meowey
 
Forgive me for sounding ignorant, but what is the problem Mossy, 3 different styles, all work very well if the finished product is what you like, and for #3, i know a few folks that use nothing but wet, green, apple wood at comp's and WIN consistently........different folk's, different strokes
icon_mrgreen.gif
It's all good!!
 
To all - Thanks for your replies and i am going with my gut on this and not replying.

bbq bubba
Thank you for pointing out my closed mind thinking on this. You are 100% right, everyone has their own ways. I feel embarrassed for thinking as I was and happy I hadn't replied as I was thinking. Again, sincerely; thank you.

Gypsy
Only time mayo goes on my bird is if it is a chicken patty or breat on a bun. But that is just my personal preference !!!
 
No one pointed out the fact that it was a hunting and fishing forum, not a smoking meat forum. I feel sorry for anyone that would go to a site like that for cooking info. Most of the deer hunters I know don't even know how to care for a carcass, let alone cook the meat.

Probably the best thing to do in the future is to post a link to the SMF and let them sort it out.

Oink snort snort EAT MORE DEER MEAT
 
Sounds like some of these folks don't want to know anything they just want to brag about their awsome jerky - even if it's not smoked.


You are Shadsky?
 
Debi
Shadsky was the user id of the original post, I was the replying with my thoughts to him and the 3rd post was from another member of the site.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Great deal on LEM Grinders!

Hot Threads

Clicky