Pickled Tomatoes

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Coreymacc

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
Oct 7, 2020
429
406
Alberta,ca
Anybody pickle tomatos? I just did one jar of pickled cherry tomatoes. I just did them as fridge pickles. I have 2 weeks to find out how they are, if anyone has done them I would be curious to find out what they turned out like.

Corey
 
Nope never.
Curious if you added sugar.
I grew Red Pear for the first time this year and ended up pulling them out as wife and a friend didn't care for the flavor over the grape I normally grow. Too late now, but pickling may have salvaged the effort of growing an otherwise worthless tomato.
 
Nope never.
Curious if you added sugar.
I grew Red Pear for the first time this year and ended up pulling them out as wife and a friend didn't care for the flavor over the grape I normally grow. Too late now, but pickling may have salvaged the effort of growing an otherwise worthless tomato.
I did a 50/50 vinegar, water, a crushed garlic clove, ½ tsp of sugar,½ tbsp of salt , put in a good size sprig of fresh dill.. And a few cracked pepper corns. I poked each tomato once with a toothpick to just break the skin. Just a pint jar.

Corey
 
I did a 50/50 vinegar, water, a crushed garlic clove, ½ tsp of sugar,½ tbsp of salt , put in a good size sprig of fresh dill.. And a few cracked pepper corns. I poked each tomato once with a toothpick to just break the skin. Just a pint jar.

Corey
I've had pickled green tomatoes before. It never occured to me to do my own with cherry tomatoes.
We're going to a farmers market today. So I'll get some cherry tomatoes and give this a try. Here's the recipe I found and will try.
 
I've had pickled green tomatoes before. It never occured to me to do my own with cherry tomatoes.
We're going to a farmers market today. So I'll get some cherry tomatoes and give this a try. Here's the recipe I found and will try.
Seems the main difference is the apple cider vinegar, mine had that as an option, i went with just white, i am curious to see how this will be.

Corey
 
Seems the main difference is the apple cider vinegar, mine had that as an option, i went with just white, i am curious to see how this will be.

Corey
Sometimes I switch out between the two when pickling veggies. I'll use cider vinegar the first time for this.
 
And here we go...
20250823_131319.jpg

Vacuum sealed. I'll try them in a couple days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 02ebz06
Nice, i vaccum sealed mine also. Ill see if I can get a pic up also. The cider vinegar sure gave them a nice orange tinge. Im gonna give mine a taste tomorrow, that will be 3 days, should give a reasonable idea what they are like.
I used orange cherry tomatoes. Should have mentioned that!

20250823_125636.jpg
 
Green tomato relish is pretty common around Arkansas at Catfish restaurants. The version I see is little more than pickled green tomatoes with a bit of onion. Good stuff.
Never saw or tried any made from ripe tomatoes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Steve H
Green tomato relish is pretty common around Arkansas at Catfish restaurants. The version I see is little more than pickled green tomatoes with a bit of onion. Good stuff.
Never saw or tried any made from ripe tomatoes.
I wasn't thinking of it either but I picked up a cherry tomato plant in the spring, i didn't really want cherries but I waited too long and its all they had left. I prefer indeterminate but there wasn't any. Well, this plant must be nuclear grade or something, im gonna have hundreds of tomatoes so I figured i better figure something out soon or im gonna be over run. 😁

Corey
 
Green tomato relish is pretty common around Arkansas at Catfish restaurants. The version I see is little more than pickled green tomatoes with a bit of onion. Good stuff.
Never saw or tried any made from ripe tomatoes.
Yup! Love that stuff. I didn't know that ripe pickled tomatoes was even around before today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1MoreFord
Bit of an update. You may want to leave the tomatoes in the brine a while longer. I tried mine and they taste like a cherry tomato with a bit of vinegar on them. Almost zero brine in them. I just going to leave them for a couple weeks. This experiment may not work i fear.

Corey
 
  • Like
Reactions: Steve H
Been playing with my grandfathers pickled green tomato recipe off and on. It's fantastic but salty AF (and I like salty stuff). It's weird, whatever I change does not work well. Anyhow, for me small roma are best and 2nd would say medium size beefsteak type cut cup. No idea why but cherry do not work well and very bitter (still mad about that). Firm stuff only. Cold snap stunted is perfect (ran these in Nov)

This is a "jar recipe" where brine is simple and the stuff you put in jar gives it the flavor.

To one pint jar:
1 clove garlic
1 hot pepper (hot hungarian usually)
1 head dill
tomatoes.

My recipe says NOT to can/process and tested that and yeah, tomatoes get mushy.

20241103_181023_resized_1.jpg
 
Bit of an update. You may want to leave the tomatoes in the brine a while longer. I tried mine and they taste like a cherry tomato with a bit of vinegar on them. Almost zero brine in them. I just going to leave them for a couple weeks. This experiment may not work i fear.

Corey
If you try another batch you might poke extra holes in them or slice them in half.
Kinda labor intensive but you could always do this like Mom. She watched (well, at least listened to) TV and performed repetitive kitchen chores.
 
Bit of an update. You may want to leave the tomatoes in the brine a while longer. I tried mine and they taste like a cherry tomato with a bit of vinegar on them. Almost zero brine in them. I just going to leave them for a couple weeks. This experiment may not work i fear.

Corey
Maybe the cider vinegar makes a difference? A couple other recipe calls for making three or more holes.
 
If you try another batch you might poke extra holes in them or slice them in half.
Kinda labor intensive but you could always do this like Mom. She watched (well, at least listened to) TV and performed repetitive kitchen chores.
I was thinking about that, the most recipes said 1 hole, more make the tomato mushy so i played it safe. This is going to take a bit of testing

Corey
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Great deal on LEM Grinders!

Latest posts

Clicky