New Electric Smoker Recommendations

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
God morning. I personally do not own an electric. Stick burners for me however The MES seems to be the most talked about and member owned on this forum. I have been looking to add to my arsenal and will be purchasing an MES 140 B soon as well as a Weber Smokey Mountain 22.5. Currently if you go to the Academy Sports site you can buy a MES 140 B for $199.00.
 
Hi everyone!
I'm here for the same question, I need a new smoker. I don't want to create new thread too, because it's so trivial question, especially here :D
I moved to a new house and now I have some free place in my backyard, and I can afford a smoker to myself and my family. Insofar as I'm a newbie, and I don't have enough experience and skills I decided that an electric smoker is the best choice for me. I've been searching info about smokers for a week and I've found one comparative review. I like 3 models and I'll be very grateful if you help me to choose out.
1. Char-Broil Vertical Electric Smoker - there it's said, that this one is the best vertical electric smoker
2. Char-Broil Standard Digital Electric Smoker - in the same review it said, that this one is the best choice for beginners
3. Masterbuilt 20071117 - this one is the easiest
What do you think about Char-Broil? Is it a good brand?
I also heard about Weber Smokey Mmountain. Everybody praises it, so is it a good idea to buy a charcoal smoker with no experience? Waiting for your replies!

dj, morning... I'm not sure I got this correct... Are you wanting to cold smoke fish and cheeses ?? If so, you can get by with a cardboard box and wire racks.. Poke holes in the box and shove wooden dowels through to support the racks...
For smoke, I recommend the AMNPS using dust made from pellets... The dust creates VERY LITTLE heat so it can be used with ambient temps up to ~65F... The box will need several holes in the side walls top and bottom for good air flow.. make them about 3/4"....
A full load of dust will last about 4 1/2 hours... Use a fruit wood for mild flavor... For salmon use Alder...
Todd, a member here, invented these things... He's part of Admin now... A real good guy...



Pellet Dust 3.JPG

I smoke everything with dust now... I prefer the flavor from dust.. it's a lighter flavor..
Some stuff I have smoked recently...
.....Cold smoked bacon...
Bacon3 11-7.JPG

..Warm smoked ham....
HAM 005.JPG
 
  • Like
Reactions: djdienummeat
Hi everyone!
I'm here for the same question, I need a new smoker. I don't want to create new thread too, because it's so trivial question, especially here :D
I moved to a new house and now I have some free place in my backyard, and I can afford a smoker to myself and my family. Insofar as I'm a newbie, and I don't have enough experience and skills I decided that an electric smoker is the best choice for me. I've been searching info about smokers for a week and I've found one comparative review. I like 3 models and I'll be very grateful if you help me to choose out.
1. Char-Broil Vertical Electric Smoker - there it's said, that this one is the best vertical electric smoker
2. Char-Broil Standard Digital Electric Smoker - in the same review it said, that this one is the best choice for beginners
3. Masterbuilt 20071117 - this one is the easiest
What do you think about Char-Broil? Is it a good brand?
I also heard about Weber Smokey Mmountain. Everybody praises it, so is it a good idea to buy a charcoal smoker with no experience? Waiting for your replies!
If you go with an Mes, I'd look at the one's that are stainless steel inside and out except for the plastic bordering on the top and bottom of the door and the window. The black paint around other cabinets where the door seals looses paint and corrodes because it's insulated, using less energy/airflow to keep the same temp compared to noninsulated smokers which is a more humid envirionment which is why most of us here on SMF don't put water in the water pan. If you get an all SS Mes 40 you should never have to buy it again compared to the painted Mes. Get a PID controller when the Mes stock controller fails and then unplug it from the smoker and bring it in out of the elements inbetween smokes and just replace heating elements over the decades. There's all kinds of threads on making an Mes better than your kitchen oven in ten minutes. The element connectors will fail and need to be replaced with high heat connectors. Electronics that don't have a conformal coating, protecting the circuit board like the Mes will corrode and arc with moisture, humidity etc and fail. So if you have a good box/door from the start, then replace failed connectors, and controller with one not from MB. It sounds overwhelming but as you get to know your stock smoker you should keep up with SMF R&D threads so you don't have to buy the smoker again. Just make it better than MB makes it.
 
dj, morning... I'm not sure I got this correct... Are you wanting to cold smoke fish and cheeses ?? If so, you can get by with a cardboard box and wire racks.. Poke holes in the box and shove wooden dowels through to support the racks...
For smoke, I recommend the AMNPS using dust made from pellets... The dust creates VERY LITTLE heat so it can be used with ambient temps up to ~65F... The box will need several holes in the side walls top and bottom for good air flow.. make them about 3/4"....
A full load of dust will last about 4 1/2 hours... Use a fruit wood for mild flavor... For salmon use Alder...
Todd, a member here, invented these things... He's part of Admin now... A real good guy...



View attachment 411336

I smoke everything with dust now... I prefer the flavor from dust.. it's a lighter flavor..
Some stuff I have smoked recently...
.....Cold smoked bacon...
View attachment 411337
..Warm smoked ham....
View attachment 411338
Thank you for the detailed answer, i appreciate this. Pictures look so tasty, you've made me hungry :D
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky