First Butt run with a Pellett

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

comer4tide

Fire Starter
Original poster
Nov 3, 2016
52
19
Middle Tennessee
This all started because of the love a beautiful woman and she doesnt understand what she has created and enabled here but here goes:

The wife wanted to get me something to cook poolside that wouldnt be an "all day operation" for me and something a little "easier" on me to cook with just for us by the pool this summer. Ive got 2 trailered stick burning Reverse Flows (Big Bertha and Great Big Bertha) but just to put 1 or 2 butts on or chickens wings or bologna its not feasible to run em for that. Thus, the pool side pellet pit boss.

So here is my question and my problem: I couldnt get the typical bark I usually get with my butts. They also took almost 4 hours longer than they typically do on my stick burners.

Prep: Rub was my tried and true rub with brown sugar, salt, poprika, garlic and onion powder, cayenne pepper, and black pepper. Injected with apple juice and water and spritzed with apple juice/water along the way. Again, nothing new or different in the prep of these butts.

Onto the cook: They were 8 pound butts, cooked at 250 until I wrapped them at 160IT, like always, and then cranked it up to 300 until IT was 200. At that point I pulled them out of the foil and the bone wouldnt budge. No biggie been here before. Back on for another hour and crank it up to 350 IT is at 210 now and still wont pull clean. 12 hours into this cook these butts are 215IT and the bone still wont pull clean and no meteorite bark. I pulled them off and let them sit for 30 minutes (the kids couldnt wait any longer to eat) and pulled them. Still, bone wouldnt pull clean without alot of help. Flavor was great, nice smoke ring, and super juicy, but my favorite park is the bark and I didnt get it. Wife and kids had zero complaints with the meat and you know what they say...happy wife, happy kids...but in the never ending quest for BBQ its the little things that keep us up at night.

So...pellet heads, how do you get your bark on these pellet cookers? Did I miss the boat somewhere? It was my first cook with a pellet but By no means my first rodeo on butts but it was the first time I couldnt get bark on any cook. Tips, tricks, or ideas.

Below are the Q pics...Pitt, first put butts on, butts at 140, and butts at what would normally be pull off temp (notice no bark)
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3280.JPG
    IMG_3280.JPG
    100.9 KB · Views: 78
  • IMG_3301.JPG
    IMG_3301.JPG
    187.7 KB · Views: 81
  • IMG_3300.JPG
    IMG_3300.JPG
    167.7 KB · Views: 81
  • IMG_3302.JPG
    IMG_3302.JPG
    189.1 KB · Views: 78
First thing I would do is double check the temp inside the cooker with another thermometer. In my experience, pellet cookers cook faster than other smokers because of the great amount of convection. A 9lb butt typically takes me 12-14 hours running at 225F, without wrapping. And I get great bark, but again, I don't wrap.
 
I have a Pitt Boss 440 pellet pooper and get, IMO, nice bark on my pork butts, see pics below. For increasing bark 3 things come to mind: time, temp, and airflow. I imagine your big smokers have ALOT of flow which is going to dry the meat surface faster for more bark combined with the rub and mop/spritz if using. On you new smoker I doubt you can adjust airflow so temp is going to be the main adjustable. Also not wrapping (more time in dry air) will help formation. As bregent said I'd also have a probe on the grate to see what the temp really is.



 
  • Like
Reactions: comer4tide
Did you have water in the water pan? If so I wouldn't do it. It doesn't need it and the added moisture in the cooker may have prevented some bark. I too have a Copperhead and don't use water.
I just did a 9 pounder yesterday in the Davy Crockett at 225* till IT of 170* then into a aluminum pan with foil and into a 275* oven till 205*. Never have an issue with bark, I defat the juices and add them back after pulling.
 
Did you have water in the water pan? If so I wouldn't do it. It doesn't need it and the added moisture in the cooker may have prevented some bark. I too have a Copperhead and don't use water.
I just did a 9 pounder yesterday in the Davy Crockett at 225* till IT of 170* then into a aluminum pan with foil and into a 275* oven till 205*. Never have an issue with bark, I defat the juices and add them back after pulling.

I did have water in the pan and it didnt cross my mind until you mentioned that. Also, did run a thermo on the grate which stayed within 10 of what the cooker was set at so temps inside were not the issue. Thank you guys for all the suggestions.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Great deal on LEM Grinders!

Latest posts

Clicky