I have zero zero zero regrets on getting the
RecTeq Bull with a bunch of accessories.
If I had that budget(I was close but wanted lower), I would look at
RecTeq, Yoder, Mak and Pitts and Smith. I always hear great things about Mak and Pitts and Smith and they seem to be like the best of the best materials wise and production wise.
Yoder is more than
RecTeq and I just couldn't wrap my head around the grill rusting which will happen. If I did have a covered area though, I might of considered Yoder more.
I personally think
RecTeq is just the best bang for your buck that not only will last, they guarantee it on the Bull for 6 years bumper to bumper. I've already had a few interactions with their support and they are the best support I've ever dealt with in ANY industry.
I did want to mention the alerting issue with the app mentioned above. I too have had issues with the app alerting. I can't exactly remember but they did re-vamp the app and the alerting has been a ton better. I can't say it works all the time b/c I have had issues but I believe it has worked everytime since they re-vamped it. But I do believe the poster above about just this past Easter. Maybe other pellet grill companies have done better? I don't know b/c no experience but before I had my pellet, I had an aftermarket maverick RF thermometer for alerting and I haven't used once since I got my RecTeq over 2 years ago. A few times I got lucky I was up already and sometime I've just been watching and didn't work. But I have had it wake me up before also. Can I count on it, I won't say 100% but like I said, I haven't been so concerned that I used my old maverick which still works. So that says something. If you have no backup from a previous smoker, then maybe this tilts the scale to another company that has done a better job with the alerting working.
I would research these 4 companies but remember, a pellet grill is a pellet grill and they all give the same lighter smoker flavor than any other smoker using real wood/charcoal. Part of that is the pellets but also part of it is the fan that keeps the smoke moving. So any company that pretends to give more smoke flavor than the other is lying in my opinion.
Good luck with your research!