First shot at a brisket

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

sirvesa

Newbie
Original poster
Jan 18, 2017
12
10
So I have never even tried brisket. it's not very popular here, but everyone I have talked to about it either loved it or hated it. I'm assuming that has a lot to do with how it was cooked. So after consulting the oracle, (this site) it was finally time to see what was missing in my life.
Got a 7 lb brisket flat from Costco. It was literally the only brisket in store. Marinated in a bottle of l&p and some (maybe 1/8 cup) sauce from South of the border over night in the fridge.
Pat dried it this morning with a paper towel then rubbed it with a mix of salt, pepper, garlic, chipotle powder, parsley, and cumin.
Set the temp to 220F (104C because I bought the cheap PID that only displays Celsius). At 220, put the brisket in and probed it up.
Kind of hard to see but TBS is flowing nicely. The dog definitely noticed.
Once the it hit 160 (around 5 hours) the brisket went into a baking dish with 2 cups of Costco apple juice and was covered with foil. Cranked the temp up to 270.
The total cook time was around 12 hours. After an hour rest I cut into it. Thicker side of the flat was tender and juicy. The thinner side was too dry. It on the thin side was 203 and the thick side was 198. Used the toothpick test to determine when it was done but this was a first using that method. May have cooked it a little too long. Still, I'm not complaining by any means and will definitely take another shot at brisket. Thanks for reading and any advice is always appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Looks like a great first time...congrats!! Way better than mine...my first time didn't turn out so well. It's unlike any other cut of meat in my opinion as far as certain IT etc. Trust the toothpick. If mine are thicker in the middle I find for me when I pull them the thinner part probes so easily I don't feel the probe go in but the thicker portion I can feel a slight resistance, not having to force it through but just enough I can feel it consistently smooth like butter. Something I guess you kind of acquire a feel for. If a slice pulled apart with little to no resistance try removing with just barely noticeable more resistance to the toothpick next time and see if moisture improves. Your rub sounds pretty similar to what I normally use...just keep tweaking to your taste until you find something you like. Best part about smoking is trying new things and experimenting as you go...just have fun along the way and if ya have any questions there are some very knowledgeable people around here to help out. Great job!!
 
 Looks good, that is always the joy of doing this lol It is edible and you learn from the previous try. Always keep going and browse the forums ask questions and pick up tips. Way to go.
 
Thanks guys. It sounds like Jon nailed it, I need to get a better feel for the toothpick test. I'll go for round 2 in a couple weeks and hope for better results.
 
Nice work on your maiden voyage. Out of curiosity, where's "here" that brisket isn't popular? Also, why did you bump the temp up to 270 and go to a braising process with apple juice? My recommendation next go-round is to trust the tried and true brisket method: 225ish throughout the cook, don't braise it, pull and wrap it tightly (not in a pan) to complete. You said that the IT got to 260: IMHO, it shouldn't get that high, and combined with the higher pit temp, those helped dry it out. My $0.02.
 
Last edited:
I meant to say 160. I've read in some other threads about people using juice around that temp but to be honest it was a shot in the dark. I'll try keeping it at 225 next time. Thanks for the input. I'm in Orcutt Ca. Pretty sure brisket is not on the menu at any of our steakhouses.
 
Doing just a flat will cook more quickly than a packer cut, so keep that in mind also. Next time in Costco, see if they have whole briskets and give that a whirl: check also in the prime section, as the last one I got there was cheaper than the choice cut. Good luck.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky