My First ever Smoker Experience - Brisket - Need some Advice

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

beedsboys

Newbie
Original poster
Jan 8, 2013
12
10
London, Canada
My wife bought me an 18.5" Weber Smoky Mountain for Christmas .. yeah ..

My ambitious 1st ever smoke was this past weekend .. I tried doing a 7lb brisket ..

Here is what happened and my questions if some one can chime in with help that would be great ..

Smoker: 18.5" WSM
Charcoal: Green Egg natural
Weather Conditions: I am in Ontario, Canada - woke up with about 4" of snow on the Smoker and temperature was about 26 Farenheit (was probably closer to 32 most of the day)

7:30 am

Tried the Minion method as this was my 1st time and it seemed like correct method for LONG smoking.

Got quickly to desired temperature however it was fluctuating a bit high and a bit low for better part of 1st 3 hours as I was adjusting to 1st ever cooking with charcoal.

As well I noticed that it was really burning through charcoal - I assume this was because it was cold out and it had work that much harder. Was a bit windy and it was snowing on and off for early am.

10:30 am

Fire was more or less out - caught me off guard as I expected it to burn for much, much longer - REFIRED it up

For remainder of morning/afternoon was pretty good with temperature - around 225

2:30 pm

Temperature dropped but was able to get it back up to 225 ish shortly after and it stayed there consistently for remainder of afternoon

Family coming over for 7 pm for dinner so I finally checked temperature of meat at around 4:30 - was about 150 degrees

Kept monitoring it (staring at digital reader) for next hour and there was no change!

6:30 pm

Still in the mid 150's - getting worried!

At this point I cancel Brisket dinner (wife told me to put in oven) and we order pizza!

I didn't put brisket in oven as I wanted to see this through

8:00 pm

Covered Brisket in foil and added some "juice"
Let it cook for about 60 minutes longer
Temp actually back down to 150

Total time now is 13 hours!

Following Day:

Put Brisket in oven at about 300 for about 90 minutes

Did not check Temperature at this point (wife was in charge while I was working)

I sliced a piece when I got home (see pics) and it was delicious - not dry but not dripping in juice like I wanted ..

Looking for any advice about getting through STALL and being able to better plan for Next Time?

Should I wrap at 150/160 and then finish in oven?

Thinking the cold weather played a big role in slowness ..

What else can help me? I know that I opened and closed Smoker too many times as I tried to get this right.

Thanks!

BB



 
I think your because your temp kept dropping and you kept opening the smoker it slowed you down a bit but briskets can take a long time, up to or even over 2 hours/lb. The stall is just something you have to get used to and plan for it. You can wrap in foil to help push through it. I have seen the same thing, temp drops after foiling. I don't know what causes that because I have foiled in the summer when it was 90* outside and did it as fast I could and the temp still drops, so it's not from the meat being out of the smoker cooling off.

I think you were right on track and were just expecting it to get done sooner. Next time plan for 2 hours/lb and add a couple hours to that as a cushion, if it gets done early you can hold it wrapped in towels in a cooler for hours and it will stay hot. And No More Peeking! Open it only when absolutely necessary!
 
 For a first time smoke, heck that aint bad at all!!

 First off you didnt set anything on fire, you didnt burn the brisket, and to top it off it was edible!!! You're over half way there. In all seriousness though, likes been said, a brisket just reaches a certain point and as you put it "stalls" for a while. I did one a couple weeks ago and it was 18 out most all day. You may use a little more fuel to keep the temp up, but 225 is the same inside the smoker regardless what it is outside. It was your first time and you peeked in on it a little to often, and......most likely you will next time or two as well. Seems to be human nature. 

 Nice job!! Next one'll probably go a little smoother as you gain even more confidence.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky