I've been meaning to create a new post to describe my experience with this.
Short version: It's a 10 out of 10.
This was designed to be used with
Camp Chef's own line of outdoor cooktops, but either by chance or by design, it also perfectly fits my 1995-era Weber Genesis natural gas grill.
I did an initial break-in, without food, to test temperature as well as burn off anything left over from the manufacturing process. At that time I experimented with various settings. Long story short, I found that because this was designed for a grill that is more of a cooktop, with the burners much closer to the food, and because of the design of my Weber (it slopes inward as you go down towards the burners), this cannot sit any lower than the
grill grates, As a result, I initially couldn't get it much above 550 degrees.
I then decided to take a piece of heavy-duty aluminum foil and cover the opening, even though it is designed to be used with this open. Once I did that, the temperature gauge went up to 700 degrees, and my IR point-n-shoot thermometer showed the built-in stone at 650.
A few days later I did my first set of pizzas, and have made pizza 2-3 times since then. I used Trader Joe's dough, Safeway dough, my own dough, and pre-made crusts, like the Boboli crusts you can get anywhere. The Trader Joe's dough is very soft and very difficult to get on and off the peel, but once I figured out how to do that, the results were nothing short of spectacular: extremely tasty, very crisp crust. The toppings had a perfect char.
In my indoor oven, with the stone on the top shelf and the oven set to 525, it takes 10-11 minutes to cook a pizza. The results are good, and the crust has some crispiness, but it lacks both the crunch that this device gives you and completely lacks that hint of char on both the crust and the toppings. On this device, it takes 4-6 minutes to fully cook the pizza.
At some point I need to find some sort of sheet metal that I can use to replace aluminum foil. I have not yet figured out what material to use or how to attach it. Magnets seem like the right idea, but I don't know how to do that without introducing a gap between the door and the oven.
Even without this eventual modification, I could not be happier.
If you think you want to get this, you need to measure your grill very, very carefully, and then look at the dimensions at the
Camp Chef's site. Their dimensions are very accurate, so you can rely on them. On my grill it only has about 1/16" to spare on the two sides, and about 1.5" on the front and back.