Oven Brisket...Don't Judge Me

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

mneeley490

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jun 23, 2011
4,291
2,988
Everett, WA
Okay, due to circumstances beyond my control, I no longer have a smoker available. Not going to get into "why" just now, I'll have to explain later.
But I just couldn't pass up that Kroger brisket coupon, and got a 12 pounder a few days ago. So, about 10 lbs after trimming, I rubbed with "Eat Barbecue: The Most Powerful Stuff Purposeful Rub" and some coarse ground black pepper. Then injected with a mixture of
1 cup beef broth
1/4 c. Worcestershire, and
1 T. liquid smoke,
and hoped for the best. Got it in the oven at 230° (fat side up) about 11pm last night, with my last 2 beers in the pan for humidity.

20240703_231836.jpg


At 5 hours, it was at 152° IT. This pic is at 9 hours in. Mopped with reserved smokey liquid. It was still in the stall at that time, so I wrapped in foil, fat side down.
20240704_084251.jpg


At 200° IT around hour 15, I probed, and while most of it was butter tender, there was still some resistance in the middle of the flat. So against my better judgement, I repositioned my probe and let it go a little longer. Pulled it at 4:40 pm. Turned out to be slightly overdone, and was tricky to slice, but still tasty. Not as good as on a real smoker, but certainly serviceable.
This is fat side down. Most of the fat rendered well.
20240704_132455.jpg

I miss the smoke ring. Pic makes it look a little dry, but it was fine. First time using liquid smoke like this, and I was afraid it might overpower the beef, but it played as a decent background flavor.
20240704_173704.jpg

20240704_174050.jpg


Plated with some corn and Dutch's Wicked Beans.
20240704_175052.jpg


So not my preferred way of making brisket for the 4th, but much better than nothing.
 
Last edited:
I would eat that plate up! If you are happy with the results that's all that matters.
 
Absolutely nothing wrong with that. Your right, the liquid smoke can get very strong if not distributed properly. Ask me how I know that (chuck roast) 😝
 
That plate is perfect ! Nice work .
I'm a fan of liquid smoke , but also have some mesquite powder that has a smokeyness to it .
 
Brought some leftovers to work today to make a smokey ramen for lunch. 🍜
 
Okay, due to circumstances beyond my control, I no longer have a smoker available. Not going to get into "why" just now, I'll have to explain later.
But I just couldn't pass up that Kroger brisket coupon, and got a 12 pounder a few days ago. So, about 10 lbs after trimming, I rubbed with "Eat Barbecue: The Most Powerful Stuff Purposeful Rub" and some coarse ground black pepper. Then injected with a mixture of
1 cup beef broth
1/4 c. Worcestershire, and
1 T. liquid smoke,
and hoped for the best. Got it in the oven at 230° (fat side up) about 11pm last night, with my last 2 beers in the pan for humidity.

View attachment 699913

At 5 hours, it was at 152° IT. This pic is at 9 hours in. Mopped with reserved smokey liquid. It was still in the stall at that time, so I wrapped in foil, fat side down.
View attachment 699914

At 200° IT around hour 15, I probed, and while most of it was butter tender, there was still some resistance in the middle of the flat. So against my better judgement, I repositioned my probe and let it go a little longer. Pulled it at 4:40 pm. Turned out to be slightly overdone, and was tricky to slice, but still tasty. Not as good as on a real smoker, but certainly serviceable.
This is fat side down. Most of the fat rendered well.
View attachment 699915
I miss the smoke ring. Pic makes it look a little dry, but it was fine. First time using liquid smoke like this, and I was afraid it might overpower the beef, but it played as a decent background flavor.
View attachment 699916
View attachment 699917

Plated with some corn and Dutch's Wicked Beans.
View attachment 699918

So not my preferred way of making brisket for the 4th, but much better than nothing.


No judgement here Brother - from here, that looks good enough to eat!

And as a Marine might say (at least it's what Clint Eastwood said as Gunny Highway) - sometimes ya gotta adapt and improvise!

Red
 
  • Like
Reactions: Redicans
Looks good and way to roll with the punches. Liquid smoke and powdered smoke both have a place in my kitchen
 
Meat and Heat=Eat. any way to cook as I don't do raw lol. never be afraid to grind a brisket for burger meat, some of the best you will every fry or grill. I came close to causing a major fire in the oven 1 time, Deer hunting won out over baby sitting a smoker, into the oven at 200ish , dark thirty when I rolled in, fat was almost over the sides, didn't think there was that much fat in it.
 
I would eat an oven brisket any time but you don't sacrifice your last 2 beers for moisture :emoji_astonished::emoji_laughing:

Over the years it was interesting to see different folks using different "secrets" in the water pan of the old smoking "bullet" when smoking a brisket.
Pepsi, liquid smoke, Coke, Alegro, Onion water...... All I can remember is eating a lot of good briskets.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BigW.
Oh, I did. Went on a Costco run last weekend and picked up a few different kinds.
 
1720652396545.png


I had heard that some states don't allow smokers in prison Mike :emoji_laughing::emoji_laughing:. Seriously that is some good looking brisket. Nicely done, and I hope you get access to your smoker soon.

Point for sure
Chris
 
  • Haha
Reactions: JLinza
Judgment? Here? Really? Sir that looks like a delicious brisket I'd eat half of any day. That plate looks amazing.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Great deal on LEM Grinders!

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky