Definitely a noticeable difference in flavor and consistency from the oven. The smoke flavor added just the right compliment and wasn't overpowering at all. It was especially awesome on the one with the bbq sauce, which I am not a huge fan of normally as I prefer gravy on my meatloaf. I can't wait to make my next batch of bbq sauce and finish it in the smoker so I get that smokey flavor in the sauce. (Different discussion though) I put slits in my pan so the grease could drain, a luxury you don't have in the oven. Made it actually slicable instead of just hacking off chunks o meatloaf. I would like to try the fatty meatloaf method next time to see if I can keep the cheese more inside the meatloaf. All in all it was a roaring success! New father in law finished his wifes portion and had seconds, and my wife had 2 helpings. I usually barely eat meatloaf warm, preferring to have it cold and in sandwiches for the next few days, and I even had 3 slices. I will never make meatloaf in the oven again, and it was at temp after 2 1/2 hours at 225. Hope this helps and please ask if you have any more questions!