Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
Based on my experience with smoking butts in a smoker I'd say that a 4.5lb butt cooked at 225 or so that goes through its normal stall should take longer than 6.5 hours. Most of mine take 12 or so. I had an experience very similar to what you are describing when I tried to smoke a butt on a...
What was the total cook time on your Boston Butt?
I've done an improvised smoke in a gas grill while on vacation with my family and I wasn't able to run at 225 to 250 like I do in my smoker. The butt got up to temp (190+) but a lot faster than it should have (~6 hours). What happens if the heat...
cforand,
I know how frustrating it can be once a pork butt stalls and you have no idea when it's going to be done. I tend to use the bone in shoulders and they regularly take about 18 hours, sometimes more. I usually do no less than 4 at a time since they're not very expensive and it's the a...
I love that you do it all from 'hoof to table'! Raising, slaughtering, butchering, prepping, cooking, and (eventually) eating a hog is on my list for the next 2-3 years. Been doing chickens here and there, but nothing bigger yet. Thanks for the ongoing inspiration...
Bill
I don't sterilize the temp probe myself... I am just not that worried about these kinds of things. I do what you do, wash it with soap and water after I use it. I guess washing it with soap and water before using it for a low temperature roast / smoke would be a good idea as well.
Having said...
I have this issue in my smoker all the time. I arrange the brisket like an upside down hard taco... point side up of course. It doesn't take too much if a 'bend' to get it to shorten enough to fit. I hope that shape suggestion is clear... if not I can see if I have a pic. As the brisket cooks it...
Bear,
You clearly have a very experienced eye for this... your comment on the 1/2" around the edge being an indicator of what the ends would have looked like makes sense. I guess I just have to do this another hundred times or so and I'll be right there with you ;-)
Bill
My mother in law uses this technique and it works well. She picked it up at a cooking class that she took. One thing to keep in mind is that you need to have a a well insulated oven since you are relying on the stored heat to work on that roast for a good 2 hours. Lower quality ovens may not...
I can only speak from experience in smoking packer cut briskets (flat and point still together with a fair amount of fat left on) since I've never smoked a flat alone. Having said that, if I recall correctly the fattier side of the brisket is on the point. For this reason the packer cut brisket...
Bear,
You are right. In my post I said the ends were medium-well but now that I think about it they were not that well done. I would've been disappointed if they were. I don't have any pics of end pieces, but my memory suggests that you are right on... most of the roast was medium rare and the...
Fred,
Looks great! I paid $9.50 / lb for a Choice bone-in rib roast from Costco. Not a steal by any means, but I agree with you that Choice is where it's at.
Looks like we were doing the same thing yesterday...
That is a very fast temperature rise... I've attached a plot from a 8-9 lb whole brisket that I did a while back. Smoker temp was ~250. It stops at 180, but I cooked it to 190+.
I'd shoot for a higher target temp than 170. 190 to 200 is common for brisket if you like it to be very tender. If...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.