Boston Butt from the Twilight Zone......with Qview

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

freakynorm

Meat Mopper
Original poster
Aug 4, 2012
181
35
Mount Vernon, Washington
So the wife picked up a small bone-in 4lb lil nugget of meat. I figured I would cook it today and throw some ABT's on for lunch.

I got the UDS up to temp, tossed on the peppers and butt.


I used Anaheim peppers and some Caribe peppers filled with cream cheese, cheddar-jack, and mild Italian sausage wrapped in some bacon of course. I set it off at 225 for a few hours and pulled off the ABT's.


The butt was moving along nice and slow. The poppers were awesome!


So I initially had the butt on around 10:30am. At around 2pm it hit 145 and stayed there for 2 hours. Then it creeped up to 153 and wouldn't move. So I double checked the temp with my insta-read thermo. It showed around 165 in the middle, the edges of course were way hotter, like 190. The bone was pulled back about 1/4". So I let it run till almost 8pm and the bone still wasn't popping out, though the temp was showing at 173 on the insta-read. I think my Mavericks food probe has already fouled up after barely a month of use. Is this common? It was about 15 degrees off from the insta-read one.I double checked grate temps with my other thermos and all were within a few degrees of each other including the Mavericks grill probe.

So I didn't have any more time and so I pulled it off, now it sits wrapped in foil and a towel sitting in a cooler for a while.

It was weird that such a small cut refused to heat up. The only thing I can think of is maybe the heat diffuser caused an issue? I am baffled as to what the heck happened. Makes me less than excited to try again. I would think about 9 hours for a 4lb butt would be enough, no?

I'll post some pics and results once I pull it from the cooler later. Any suggestions are appreciated. Thanks!
 
Nice looking ABT's.....as far as the stall I always force mine; I have a propane fired smoker so I will just pour the heat to it to get it moving along. I know that it's not right, but I have to do what I have to do to keep it going......
 
Last edited:
I've had issues with my Maverick Et-732. Sent them an email but no reply so far. Looks like I have a defective food probe. My cheap ass digital probe I use for back up on my gas grill has never let me down. Same read as my thermapen. Maverick is just not impressing me. Less than two months and only casual home use. Too bad. I like the concept. Maybe just bad luck of the draw but I have no interest in ruining a good meal.


Still learning
 
I pulled the butt out of the cooler and it was basically a pork roast. Not too bad. I was really craving pulled pork, so it's not as good as I was hoping. It's like when you take a sip of your drink, thinking you're drinking soda and it's actually water. It still quenches your thirst but your craving for a cold sip of soda goes unfulfilled. Next time I will have to sweeten up the rub a bit with a lil more brown sugar to get a better tasting bark.

I can't think of why this happened. I noticed that it had string tied around it, I didn't even notice it when prepping it. Could that have anything to do with it?


I ended up slicing it and packaging up for my kid to bring to school for lunch.

 
Wow, 9 hours for a four pound butt?!?  I usually smoke butts about 1 to 1.5 hours per pound between 225 and 240 degrees F.  I don't use a probe in my meat while smoking, it just aggravates the heck out of me when it stalls, and it always does.  I do a check with two different thermometers at 8 hours on an 8 pound butt and if it reads 195 or slightly higher, I pull it off, if not it stays on for another few hours.  I have never overcooked a butt (of course, now that I say this I'll screw one up).

That four pounder should have taken you about 6 hours max if your temps were holding steady in your smoker.  How were your temps?

Also, that little bitty butt may not have had a really good marbelling of fat.  How did it look before you put it on?
 
Yeah the temps were solid at 225-240 the entire time. I double checked using a grate thermo and a 12" probe thermo. All were within 5-10 degrees of each other and the Mavericks remote BBQ temp probe.

That temp sure did stall. It sat at 145 for hours. The marbling looked good and had a decent fat cap on it. I think next time I will do it without the heat diffuser. That's about the only thing I can really think of, but the temps were where they should be. I was thinking too that the strings were on it and maybe since the string was basically squeezing it so tight, the heat was having a hard time penetrating and it was staying a bit colder way longer than if it was loose and allowed to breathe?

Maybe I will try again next weekend with a slightly larger butt like a 6 pounder.
 
I just did a 3.5 last week that took from 1:30 to 11. Dang thing stalled 3 times on me

On your probes - just call Maverick, everyone who has called them has posted good results  
 
I just did a 3.5 last week that took from 1:30 to 11. Dang thing stalled 3 times on me

On your probes - just call Maverick, everyone who has called them has posted good results  
Holy Smoke (pun slightly intended) Scarbelly!!!!  9 hours, whew.  This has me thinking...are the small butts taking up so little space in the smoker that the heat cannot concentrate on the meat?

I know that sounds crazy, but two small butts at 9 hours each?  Makes you wonder if bigger butts are better butts!  Relatively speaking, that is  
yahoo.gif
 
The last 8 pounder I did in my WSM stalled and it seemed to take forever.  I finally dialed the Guru up to 275 to get it over the hump towards the end.  It took about 23 hours and is the longest pork shoulder smoke I've ever had to do.   Odd thing is I have smoked them in batches of 4 (all 8 pounders too) for much less time than this single one took.
 
To follow up, I got a very nice reply from the Maverick folk. They happily offered to replace my food probe as it is within its warranty period. I appreciate their response. Good product. Would recommend it to my friends.


Ready to eat
 
Wow, 3 phone calls to them and 3 emails and not a single response back in the last few weeks. Guess I will have to try again next week. I left 3 voicemails and sent 3 emails and didn't hear a peep from them.
 
The Butcher string won't Hurt Your Cook time, Infact I have done Hams and shoulders  That were Wrapped  through whole cook.  Often Times with pork Butts despite SIZE Take Longer than Expected, The 1.5 Hours per lb theory is Just that.  Always Cook till Done, Not a set time ( meaning Plan ahead for a Longer cook ) I mean even if it gets done Early ( way early) a foil & towel wrapped butt or Brisket Placed In a cooler ( Ice chest ) will stay warm for several Hours ( yes even Over Night ) have Towels I Use Just for That ( I dont always Use foil as it makes the meat sweat )  Your meant  was simply Not Finished Thats why it wouldn't Pull.  Often I get tired of waiting and we slice and eat..  But If You are patient and wait That Bone will almost shoot itself out and the Meat Fall apart. For a delicious Bark Try a mustard Slather ( mustard paste butt then add Rub ) It holds better and  You can't taste the Mustard. Also  Get a Pump Spray Bottle  fill  With 1/4 Apple Cider Vinegar 1/2 Cup Pineapple Juice 1/2 cup Apple Juice (or orange) Can be refrigerated  and re-Used sprits the meat ( NOT Mop ) every few Hours Then at half way Mark  add a fine dusting Of Your Rub  This makes an amazing  Bark
 
I cooked my first one this past weekend- keep the smoker faithfully between 225 & 250degreesAfter 7 hours it finall hit 170- about a 5 or 6 pounderThought it was overdone-- stayed @ about 150-160 for half of the time
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky