Greetings from Lawn Guyland (Long Island, New York)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

littlemike

Newbie
Original poster
Jun 16, 2012
4
10
Long Island, New York
Hello all,

Total smoker noob. I live in Long Island, New York. I don't own a smoker yet, but I should be picking up a Brinkmann vertical this week. I love eating smoked meats so I figured it's about time I start making some myself. Maybe I've been watching too much Guy Fieri on Food Network, but with summer here, there's nothing better than a nice smoked brisket or some pulled pork, in my opinion.

I actually found this site while I was doing research on buying my first smoker. Home Depot has a cheap $40 one and when I found the reviews here about problems with vent control, ashes choking the coals, etc, I decided to go up one model to the Vertical. I read on here that I should immediately replace the fire bowl with something like a wok or any other kind of SS bowl with holes in it for ventilation and holes in the bottom for the ash to escape. Either that or I could break out the Ryobi. I think a cheap $10 grilling wok will do the job, though. I could always use the original fire bowl to catch the ashes right?

Anyway, I don't want to make this too long. I signed up for the free 5 day e-course to get the ol' juices flowing (har har har) and plan to do a lot more reading around here.

Pleased to meet you all! :D

-Mike
 
Hi Mike! 
welcome1.gif
 to SMF!!! We're happy to have you! Lot's of great stuff to read on here and you're going to learn a lot from the E-course!
 
Hello Mike and 
welcome1.gif
to SMF - glad to have you here - good luck with the new smoker
 
Hello, my name is Lance and I am an addict....

OK Mike, welcome to the site.  I'm new to the site myself but have been smoke curing, hot smoke cooking and playing around with traditional BBQ for some years.  I'm firmly convinced that if it can be cooked in a household kitchen it can be cooked with fire.

If by Brinkmann vertical you are referring to the ubiquitous Smoke 'N Grill or the Gourmet Smoker and Grill (AKA ECB, AKA El Cheapo Brinkmann) you have a tool that can produce great BBQ.  The fact that it needs a bit of tinkering and attention to produce good results consistently is a plus.  Think of it as training wheels for learning the basics.

The intake air vents are pretty restricted since assorted fools have used them over flammable surfaces and the corporate tort lawyers don't want the company to be sued any more than is normal.  There is no provision to get a stable and predictable airflow under the coals  since they were worried about small coals falling out.  Combine that with the need to sell at a low price point and so the fire sits on the bottom of the fire box and you really have little control over the draft or burning rate. 

Two easy fixes are to drill a ring of holes (maybe 3/8") between the slots on about an 8-10" circle pattern and then elevate the fire by plunking in an elevated grate.  Now you have an adequate air supply and a place for the ashes to fall without cutting off air flow and air coming up through the coals to promote clean burning and an absence of creosote and other things that can sometimes make for somewhat bitter tastes.  The grate can be as simple as one of the racks you would use in a roasting pan or a small grill rack with either one raised on a few wads of crumpled aluminum foil.  Remember that this smoker is your training wheels and tinkering and modifying it is easier than just about any other smoker.

So, with about ten minutes invested (four of them involved with finding the chuck key) you will have fixed the weaknesses of the design.

If you didn't get it right the first time and you have more air holes that you wanted = a few more wads of foil.  Not enough air holes?  Well, you know where the chuck key is now so get to work....

I use well ashed over briquettes to start and to heat things up and lump charcoal after that.  I toss in lumps of wood about half the size of a fist or a bit smaller to get the amount of smoke flavor I want.  Frankly, I usually switch to mostly wood chunks.  The two whole boned pork butts in my avatar were done in a Smoke 'N Grill about 4-5 weeks ago so you can see that they can produce darn good stuff.

If you don't have access to want some hunks of flavor woods shoot me a PM with an address and I'll mail you some.  We have a woodlot and heat a pretty large home with wood so i set aside a lot of the good stuff for friends and us for smoking and BBQ.  I've got apple, cherry, a couple of kinds each of oak and maple, beech, hickory, yadda, yadda, yadda.  Let me know.

Sorry for the long reply but, again, welcome.

Lance
 
Hi Lance,

Thanks for the informative response! I don't think the one I was looking at is the Smoke 'N Grill, but the next model up. It's this guy right here:

http://www.homedepot.com/Outdoors-G...splay?catalogId=10053&langId=-1&storeId=10051
 

Regardless I think your advice is the same from what I gathered on here. Stupid lawyers ruining perfectly good design. I read that I could either drill holes like you suggested or I could replace the fire bowl with this grilling wok here:


And that would solve the ventilation problems. I know these Brinkmann's are also notorious for having inaccurate thermometers too, so I'll keep an eye out for that. Is there a replacement thermometer that could easily be bolted in to this unit that I can swap the original out with? If not, I can always manage with a wireless one or some other means.

I'm glad you mention that you start with briquettes and toss in lumps of wood after that. I was actually trying to find some good info on what to use in this thing to actually do the cooking/smoking. My buddy wants to go in with me on this smoker and he was thinking we should go propane because he said it's cheaper than charcoal. I'm skeptical. I want this thing to be more portable because we're taking it camping with us. If it were propane, I would think it would be more of a hassle for the 8 hour drive from home to the campground and back again.

Again, I appreciate the response. Lots of helpful folks around here!

-Mike
 
Mike, your smoker is different from what I've used so you may find better advice over on the charcoal smoker forum.  I start with briquettes to get everything started heating up but unless you use a side fire to start more and let them ash over before adding them many brands of briquettes can leave a funky taste from the binders etc but your mileage may differ.  Let me kow if you want some hunks of wood.

Lance
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky