Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
look for advice on doing a eye of round have about a 3 1/2# one i like to smoke but have just got my smoker and trying toget some good advice on time and time for it on my propain smoker
Welcome to SMF for that cut personally I would just rub with some EVOO then apply some salt, pepper, garlic and put into the smoker running at about 225. I would smoke it to an internal temp of 140 degrees then pull it off and wrap it in aluminum foil and then wrap that with an old towel then I would put that all in a warm dry cooler to rest for about an hour. When the hour was up I'd take it out and slice it fairly thin and serve with some mashed taters and gravy. I'd take the leftover and put it in the fridge till it got cold then I'd put it on my slicer and slice it nice and thin for sandwiches. Yikes what size did you say that thing was you may need to get another one
I'm with Jerry (pineywoods) on this one cause he knows what he's talking about and it sounds like a really good dinner to me and then you will have some really good sandwich meat to boot. I do it all the time. Now for time you are probally looking at about 45 mins to a 1 hr a pound to smoke it but that is only a guess cause we smoke by temp not time here.