First butt on the new MES with Q view

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

ws dave

Fire Starter
Original poster
Got my new MES a few weeks back and made some delicious chicken thighs for my first smoke so decided it was time to try a butt. I've done a bunch of these with my old red Brinkmann and times ranged from a high of 19 hours to a low of 8 hours. Results were always great but the times were all over the place. I have no idea how long it will take in the MES but I have nothing else to do today so it doesn't matter much. I always smoked them overnight with the old smoker but am trying a daytime smoke this time around. I don't usually like to foil but I certainly can if this gets to taking to long, we'll see what happens. Ok so the menu is PP with smoked beans for dinner and chicken thighs for lunch. I rubbed the butt down with two off the shelf rubs (I love the yellow "Rub some butt" rub from Lowe's) about 8am and let it sit for two hours before going on the smoker at 260*, once the temp recovers I want to lower it to 225 and let it ride. Chicken will go in soon so it will be done for lunch. I was advised to smoke to 140 IT and finish on a hot grill to crisp up the skin so that's the plan. Once the pork gets all melty and drippy the beans will go underneath to catch all that tasty goodness. I'll post some pics as I go.
 
Ok so apparently the chicken IT wasn't as high as I thought it was (no wonder it "cooked so fast") so it will finish on the grill. Not sure what went wrong because I checked with two thermometers and they both said it was done and now they both say it's not. The smallest one was actually done so I just had a pre lunch appetizer. Very juicy with that crispy skin that makes chicken so good. Not very smokey but still tasty.
 
Things seem to coming along pretty well, pork is stalled at 156 and melting out all it's juicy goodness into the beans. I'll give it a couple hours and if it doesn't come out of it I'll foil to get it up to temp. Beans are in and the chicken is out. Chicken tasted like very good BBQ chicken that you'd have at a picnic but didn't taste smoked at all. Tasted like what it essentially was, gas grill BBQ chicken. Very tasty but not as good as last time when they were almost 3 hours in the smoker. This time was under an hour and it tasted like it. Totally my fault for not probing more spots with the thermometers. Finishing on the grill is definitely the way to go though for that crispy skin, I will do that every time from now on. It's all a learning experience which is what makes it fun. More pics later as the butt finishes up.
 
Still smokin here! This was supposed to be dinner but it's 9:30 and it's still not there. Butt is at 189 and rising so I'm getting fairly close to pulling it but by the time it rests it will be too late to do anything with it tonight. Beans are looking good so I may get to have some of those tonight. I was chugging along earlier but got busy and didn't get to check the smoker for a couple hours and when I got back to it it was shut off and pit temp was at 160 with the meat at 170. Not sure how long it was off but I don't think it was all that long. I don't know how to run this without setting the timer (do you have to?)so when I started it this morning I set it for 10 hours and I think it timed out while I was busy. Frustrating. I cranked the heat to 275 and the butt has picked up 20* in the last hour and a half so I'm back on track now. That mistake will cost me dinner tonight I'm afraid.
 
Last edited:
I was shooting for 200 and it was rising quick so I let it ride. It's now off the smoker and resting comfortably but it looks too good to let it rest for long. I have got to get me some of this before I go to bed! I'll let it sit for a half hour to 45 mins and then I'll pull at least some of it. I made up some of SoFlaQuers finishing sauce earlier so I'll pull some, hit it with the sauce, and have a plate full of meat tonight and then pull the rest for sammies tomorrow. Took almost exactly 12 hours for about a 5lb butt which is about double what I thought it would. Still learning the new smoker. So tender it split in half when I took it off.Looks juicy!
 
Looking good. What I usually do with the timer is set it to the full 24:00. Then when the meat finishes I turn it off when I pull the meat out. That way I'm never guessing when it will finish.
 
Alright!
Finally, eh? I bet you're breathing a sigh of relief.
Every hunk of meat is different, and will be ready when it is ready and not before.
Give yourself 2-4 hrs leeway, I try to for myself.

From what I can see in that pic, it looks pretty good.
Nice bark, inside looks moist, falling apart tender, heck all I need now is a taste test. :drool

Point for pulling the pork through a challenging cook.

I pun therefore I am.
 
Hey thanks for all the comments guys. FINALLY got to have a taste and it was worth the wait. I do a lot of picnic shoulders because they're bigger and cheaper but there is no comparing the taste and texture to a well cooked butt. This is so tender and juicy and almost all the fat was rendered out so there wasn't much waste at all. I just pulled a little of it for now and will do the rest tomorrow. Beans came out great too this time.
Very juicy and perfect tenderness for a change.

It was a long cook but worth it. Would like to get a little more smoke on it next time but this was definitely a success. I'm thinking ribs will be next since I haven't made them in a while.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sportgd
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky