My first smoke, the Boston Butt

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

tcald429

Newbie
Original poster
Oct 23, 2012
18
10
Burnside, LA
I am going to attempt my first smoke this weekend for the super bowl on my new Master Forge vertical smoker. I have been searching around the forums for the last couple days and believe I have the gist of it, but looking for a little feedback on my plans.

I bought a 2-pack of Boston Butts, 18 lbs total.

Friday night or saturday morning I will rinse the meat, apply a rub, and wrap.

Assuming they are approximately 9 lbs a piece, and judging by the 1.5-2 hours per pound rule, this will be a 14 - 18 hour smoke.  Does this sound about right?  I'm looking to have these ready around kick-off (5:30 PM Sunday my time), which would put me starting at around 11:30 PM the night before.  This is where it gets a little sketchy for me, i'm not sure if attempting an overnight smoke is the best idea for my first try at this, but I'd rather these be ready early and rest in a cooler than have me cooking during the game and hungry guests.  Please comment on this, I need all the pointers/advice I can get!!

I will cook at a smoker temp of 225-240 degrees, until the internal meat temperature reaches 205 degrees.  I then will wrap in foil/towels and allow to rest in a cooler for minimum of an hour.  Then, I will pull the meat and apply a finishing sauce before serving.

Does this all sound pretty accurate?  My main concern is trying to smoke over night, being my first official smoke ever (besides seasoning the smoker).
 
I would say it really depends on how much you plan on sleeping that night and how good a feel for your smoker you got during your test run. I'm also new to this smoking thing and just did my third smoke (first butt) yesterday.  For me there has been a learning curve for getting good consistent smoke generation such that yesterday I was relighting my AMNPS every hour or so for a while.  If you feel comfortable with your equipment and/or don't mind losing a little sleep then I say go for it. Only one way to learn rite?

-Barret
 
 
I am going to attempt my first smoke this weekend for the super bowl on my new Master Forge vertical smoker. I have been searching around the forums for the last couple days and believe I have the gist of it, but looking for a little feedback on my plans.

I bought a 2-pack of Boston Butts, 18 lbs total.

Friday night or saturday morning I will rinse the meat, apply a rub, and wrap.

Assuming they are approximately 9 lbs a piece, and judging by the 1.5-2 hours per pound rule, this will be a 14 - 18 hour smoke.  Does this sound about right?  I'm looking to have these ready around kick-off (5:30 PM Sunday my time), which would put me starting at around 11:30 PM the night before.  This is where it gets a little sketchy for me, i'm not sure if attempting an overnight smoke is the best idea for my first try at this, but I'd rather these be ready early and rest in a cooler than have me cooking during the game and hungry guests.  Please comment on this, I need all the pointers/advice I can get!!

I will cook at a smoker temp of 225-240 degrees, until the internal meat temperature reaches 205 degrees.  I then will wrap in foil/towels and allow to rest in a cooler for minimum of an hour.  Then, I will pull the meat and apply a finishing sauce before serving.

Does this all sound pretty accurate?  My main concern is trying to smoke over night, being my first official smoke ever (besides seasoning the smoker).
Sounds about right but if you don't start them till 11:30 & they take 2 hrs/lb they won't be done till kick-off time not counting the time needed for the rest & to pull it. If it were me I would start them earlier just to be safe - I have kept butts in the cooler for 5 hrs before pulling & they were still piping hot when I took them out. Do you have a remote thermometer with alarm by chance?
 
Sounds about right but if you don't start them till 11:30 & they take 2 hrs/lb they won't be done till kick-off time not counting the time needed for the rest & to pull it. If it were me I would start them earlier just to be safe - I have kept butts in the cooler for 5 hrs before pulling & they were still piping hot when I took them out. Do you have a remote thermometer with alarm by chance?
I like the idea of starting them earlier, gives me time to get comfortable with the temperatures before I'm ready to sleep some.  I did pick up a Maverick Redi Chek remote themometer/alarm a couple nights ago at Cabelas.
 
Agree that you need to give yourself more time. I have done several briskets and pork butts, and the one thing I've learned is it's hard to predict just how long they will take. Even 5 degrees of variance can drastically alter the cooking time. I've also had difficulty doing 2 at once (but that's just cause I don't have much experience doing that). Better to start way early and put in a cooler for several hours (makes the meat better anyway). Lack of sleep is small price to pay for great BBQ :)

Good luck! You'll have to let us know how it turns out...pork butss (IMHO) are a great way to start with smoking...very forgiving piece of meat.
 
How much time do you think I should add to be safe. 8:30-9:30ish?
I usually give myself 24 hours, but I'll defer to some of the other folks, as I still consider myself a bit of a rookie at smoking. Not sure if you've used the smoker before, but take into account they take longer than yoou expect to get to the right temp.
 
Also, is there anything special people use in their water pan?  Or should I just use plain old water?
 
How much time do you think I should add to be safe. 8:30-9:30ish?
If it were me I would have my smoker all warmed up & ready to go & put the butts in by 9 pm the night before. This way if you hit a long stall & go the full 2hrs/lb or even a little longer you will still have time to get a good hour of rest time before you pull the pork. The reason I asked about the remote therm is so that you can set the alarm to go off if your temp drops off - you probably won't get much sleep on your first overnight smoke but if you do fall asleep & something happens the alarm will let you know.
thumb1.gif
 
If it were me I would have my smoker all warmed up & ready to go & put the butts in by 9 pm the night before. This way if you hit a long stall & go the full 2hrs/lb or even a little longer you will still have time to get a good hour of rest time before you pull the pork. The reason I asked about the remote therm is so that you can set the alarm to go off if your temp drops off - you probably won't get much sleep on your first overnight smoke but if you do fall asleep & something happens the alarm will let you know.
thumb1.gif
Thanks, I'll be so nervous about screwing them up that i'll probably end up staring at the thermometer all night long haha
 
First smoke + overnighter + deadline = setting yourself up for a very tired and crabby superbowl Sunday!

If I were you I'd run the smoker the day before and keep an eye on the process. Pulled pork reheats wonderfully and you will preserve your sanity for the big day. You have a lot of learning to do about your particular smoker and putting that kind of pressure on yourself to get it right the first time will not make it fun.

If I were you I would try to find a wireless remote thermometer. This greatly simplifies the smoking process so you don't need to open the smoker to track your temps.....Good luck!
 
Looks like B's gotcha covered and I would take the advice given by Damon too!  I never rely on the smoker thermometer.  For good que investing in a good quality digital thermometer is a must.  My favorite is my Maverick ET732.  I have had two other remote thermos before (one a different Mav) but nothing really compares.

Being your first overnighter I also suggest doing this a night earlier, that way you get to sleep on Saturday night and enjoy the game with your guests.

Good Luck and Get Smokin'

Bill
 
Thanks for all of the advice, unfortunately as much as I'd like to take Damon's advice, I will be out of town all of Saturday, so overnight is my only option (plus mom always told me I was hard headed).

I purchased the Maverick ET-73 a couple nights ago, is that a decent thermometer?  It looked like it pretty good reviews.
 
Thanks for all of the advice, unfortunately as much as I'd like to take Damon's advice, I will be out of town all of Saturday, so overnight is my only option (plus mom always told me I was hard headed).

I purchased the Maverick ET-73 a couple nights ago, is that a decent thermometer?  It looked like it pretty good reviews.
Ah well.

The ET-73 is pretty good but people are having problems with the probes and cords, as did I.  I just upgraded to the ET-732 and love it!  Plus, I saw on this site just a few minutes ago that Amazon has them on sale for $45 with a coupon!  I'm buying another for a spare.

Bill
 
Ah well.

The ET-73 is pretty good but people are having problems with the probes and cords, as did I.  I just upgraded to the ET-732 and love it!  Plus, I saw on this site just a few minutes ago that Amazon has them on sale for $45 with a coupon!  I'm buying another for a spare.

Bill
Figures, and I just bought the ET-73 for $50 at Cabelas haha, but I needed it for this weekend so I didn't have the option of online ordering.  I guess I will use it until it gives out, the replace with the 73
 
Ok, great. I have the same and made those mods last weekend and wanted to warn you in case you hadn't. Sounds like you are good to go!
A couple pics I have of the mods, forgot to snap one of the bottom vents, but all parts are Weber replacements ordered off of Amazon.

Weber 72501 Replacement Charcoal Grate


Weber Charcoal Grill Smoker Kettle Damper Kit 77901


Not pictured are Weber Smoker 18 1/2" Smokey Mountain & Kettle 3 Pack Damper Kit 63105 which were installed on the bottom of the smoker, and I capped off the open hole in the middle with aluminum sheetmetal and some 3/6" rivets.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky