10 lbs of Choice Sirloin Tip!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

s2k9k

AMNPS Test Group
Original poster
Sep 8, 2011
11,324
182
SEUSA
Well my Step-Daughter decided she wanted to come back home after being in Montana for three years, I guess she just missed me that much! So my Sister suggested we have a family dinner to welcome her back (I think she just wants some more of my smokey goodness) The local grocer had sirloin tips on sale this week (not a great price but not bad) so I picked up a 10.66 pounder. This morning I trimmed it a bit, got some fat off so the seasonings would stick to the meat and not fall off with the fat. Took off less than half a pound so it still weighs in at over 10 lbs. I had thought about cutting it in half but couldn’t find a place I really wanted to cut and keep two equal and uniform looking roasts so I decided to just do it whole. I rubbed it down with some Thick Lea & Perrins then a little Montreal Steak Seasoning mixed with a lot of SPOG. One side of it was kind of open with thinner edges so I tied it up nice and tight with some butchers string. I wrapped it in plastic wrap and stuck it in the fridge for a 24 hour soak. I’m going to smoke it tomorrow with Chef JimmyJ’s Au Jus and some corn on the cob and make some mashed potatoes. I want to take it to 130*, nice and med rare and let it rest for an hour or so. Planning on dinner around 5 or 6 so I have a little window there but am still not sure how long it will take. I have read 30 – 45 mins/lb and that would put it 5 – 7 hours. JJ told me on another thread he thought under 4 hours. If anyone else has done a sirloin tip this big Please let me know how long it took or I am planning on 5 hours, I’m taking JJ’s advice and adding a little cushion to it. If it gets done early no problem but I don’t want it to be late.

Thanks!

Here’s a few pics of the big boy:





Tune in tomorrow............
 
Looks great!  Best way to cut a sirloin tip in half is lengthwise (in the seasoned pic, from the Lea and Perrins bottle to the bottom of the pic) then tie up both roasts, or from the face to the heel is another way of putting it, dividing it in half, vs. cutting it across, separating the back from the front all the way across.  The best cut is in the front face of the roast and the worst cut is in the back end of the roast, so you divide it vertically, not horizontally.

Looking forward to the results, and leftovers!
 
Thanks Pops! I guess I was looking for a seam or something to follow, kind of like cutting a point off a packer. I think leaving it whole will still work out good.

Leftovers will meet the slicer and make some good sammies for lunches at work!
 
Well it's been on for an hour now and looking good. I am making Chef JimmyJ's Au Jus with it and after roasting the veggies for an hour I just added the beef broth mix.


I loaded up my AMNPS for a 1 1/2 hour double burn for some heavy smoke at the start then it will change to a single burn for another 2 hours. I'm using the Pitmaster's Choice pellets! I think my smoke penetration should be done at that time when the dry skin forms locking in all the succulent juices! 

 
Looking good Dave - We are going to do some of your wings today here at the campground 
 
So I waited 3 hours before I probed to to ensure I had a safe surface temp. Deep in the heart of this it is at 92*, looks like I have a couple of hours to go.

I got that nice dry skin I was looking for to seal in all the succulent juices.


 
popcorn.gif
 
Well after 6 hours it was at 125* in the very center but 130*-135* everywhere else and everybody was getting very hungry so I had to pull it. I stuck it in a cooler for 45 mins while I got everything else ready. Here it is out of the cooler:



All the leftovers will get sliced real thin for sammies!
 
I forgot to mention the Au Jus, it was Awesome! I thickened some of it up (with a little help from JJ) to make a gravy, it wasn't your traditional beef gravy but it had a very good different flavor. I don't normally like gravy but this was really good on the mashed potatoes! The beef was so good I didn't want to put anything on it. I'm saving the Au Jus and looking forward to some good French Dip sammies after I slice up the leftovers.
 
That looks incredible.  I might have to try this next.... Would love to do that with a nice standing rib roast.  Perfect color on the inside.  I'm assuming you sliced it thin, but how was the texture? Was it tough at all? 
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky