or Connect
SmokingMeatForums.com › Articles › Needle Valves For Gassers

Needle Valves For Gassers

If you are like me, you may be having a hard time keeping the temperatures down on your propane smoker/cooker, hopefully you will find this article helpful

.

This article describes what a needle valves does, why you might need one, and some sources for obtaining one.

 

This is your basic LP Needle Valve:

 

needlevalve.jpg

 

The importance of proper installation of Needle Valves...

All well designed needle valves include an arrow shape, either machined, or cast into the main body of the needle valve. It is common to see needle valves, with the same or different threads on both the inlet and the outlet. So let us examine this arrow and it's importance. As with any pressurized gas or liquid, safety is paramount. Therefore we have discovered the reason for the arrow. As you can see in the illustration above, even though a needle valve may look similar from either end, the inside is very different.

In the above image, you see that if the gas is entering the valve from the RIGHT, and the valve is shut, there is no pressure on the seals around the valve stem and knob assembly. On the other hand, if the inlet was connected in error, with the gas supply coming in from the LEFT, in the illustration, then with the valve closed, the seals around the valve stem and knob would be under stress... NOT GOOD!!!!

Proper installation of a needle valve will ensure years of safe operation.

 

 

There are many sources for needle valves, and I can't really say one is better than any other, personally I've only ever installed one, but I know there are alot of fine folks on this site that have installed them on many different types of cookers and smokers

 

Here are some pictures of my installation:

 

P1060866 - Copy.JPG

 

And a close up:

 

P1060867 - Copy.JPG

 

 

Previous to installing the needle valve in my smoker, the temperatures, even at the lowest setting, would creep up to around the 270F range.  Not that most anything can't be done nicely at that temp, but for those of us wanting the the preverbial "low & slow", that is a little too high.

 

The manufacturer of my smoker actually indicates to only turn on the propane bottle valve 1/4 turn so as to not fully open the propane bottle.  With the needle valve, I am able to open it as much or as little as I want without having to worry about it.  The valve on the bottle is more of an open/close anyway, and not for flow control.

 

 

Here is the before picture of my burner at night with the gas control knob set on LOW:

 

before.jpg

 

 

And after the needle valve installation:

 

after.jpg

 

Even with the poor shots from my camera, you can clearly see an obvious difference in the flame output.

 

 

Here are a collection of sites that carry different needle valves, I got mine from Adventures in Homebrewing as it was the cheapest with shipping ($12 and change), and what arrived was the Bayou Classic valve.  HA!

 

Adventures in Homebrewing:

http://www.homebrewing.org/Needle-Valve-For-Propane_p_1726.html

 

Bayou Classic:

http://bayouclassicdepot.com/nv108p_propane_burner_part.htm

 

Homebrew Heaven:

http://store.homebrewheaven.com/propane-needle-valve-p1225.aspx

 

 

For those who don't want to mess with taking apart your existing propane lines, Bayou Classic offers several Propane Regulator Kits that have the Regulator AND Needle Valve already in place.

http://bayouclassicdepot.com/propane_regulator_kit.htm

 

From what I found during my research, shop around, Amazon has the same product even cheaper.

http://www.amazon.com/Bayou-Classic-5HPR-30-Pressure-Regulator/dp/B0043DHJKY/ref=pd_sbs_ol_5

 

** UPDATE 2/28/2013 **

It seems the vendor is no longer shipping the product shown in the above link.

After a quick search, this seems to be the correct assembly.  (at least as of today, if someone orders it, please post a comment that it is indeed the correct one)

http://www.amazon.com/Classic-Thermoplastic-Preset-Regulator-Control/dp/B005FOF2XQ/ref=sr_1_15?ie=UTF8&qid=1362090916&sr=8-15&keywords=5HPR-30

 

 

 

** UPDATE 3/18/2013 **

It seems the vendors on Amazon need to change their descriptions as they are shipping the adjustable regulator assembly versus the one with the needle valve.  If you find a correct one, please post below for others to order, I'll update if I find another one.

 

 

If anyone has anything further to add, please feel free, this is just my attempt to help out where I can.

 

Happy Smoking!

Robert

aka "Bluto"

 

 

UPDATE 2/23/12:

In hindsight, after buying the needle valve and additional fittings at my local Lowes to make it work, I would have spent just about as much by purchasing the entire regulator assembly from Amazon, and wouldn't have had to mess with the splicing.

 

** Also, before firing it up after making the mod, make sure to check all of your connections with soapy water to ensure that you don't have any leaks.

 

 

 

 

 

Comments (17)

Thanks Robert. Needle valve has been ordered.
personaly I would buy the complete unit from Bayou. I find hose regs all go weak after some time, Robert your installation looks good, check you clamps every so often. I bought a complete set up for a clam baker reg,valve,hoses tank fitting and burner con for around $40 at my local L/P dealer
I use the kit from Bayou for my pig cookers. They work like a charm and give a good temp range. Normally from 180 degrees to about 550 degrees.

Would an adjustable regulator work the same?
Just ordered the complete Bayou set up as well. Thanks for the heads up.
Hey Mike, sorry for the late reply. I've never had any exposure to the adjustable regulators, but from what I've read when I was researching what to do for mine, they may have presets for their pressure, the needle valves offerr much greater refinement for flow control.
Hope this helps.
I was thinking most smokers are low pressure. But the one from Amazon is high pressure will this work? I would not think it would be a good idea. But really have no idea. If some one that knows propane please post an let me know.
I just bought an ajustable reg from bass pro works great.
Hey Dave, I don't know off the top of my head what exactly the pressures are, and I could be wrong, but I believe propane is under fairly high pressure, natural gas is low, propane is high.
TomHood, I've heard the adjustable regulators work but aren't as finite with their adjustments, but each case is different, so as long as it works great or you, that is all that matters!
I ordered the one Bluto listed as being available from Amazon. The pic showed it had a needle valve. When it came today, it had an adjustable regulator. I do not want an adjustable regulator as I have heard that they do not work well and you should not screw with adjusting the pressure. Will be sending it back to Amazon. Does anyone have a source for one with a needle valve installed?
Thanks.
Dan
It looks like they are indeed shipping a different product, even the reviews show the same comments, after a quick search for the part #, I found another one on Amazon that does state it ships with the needle/control valve, and for just a couple dollars more with shipping, I've replaced the link in the article to it.
I ordered the one from Amazon that Bluto found and it is the same one as the previous one with the adjustable regulator. If it is a Bayou Classic part number M5HPR-30 it has an adjustable regulator and not a needle valve. This one is getting returned like the last one.
Hey Duke, that sux, it would be nice if they would correct their descriptions then. What a hassle, I'll update the article to reflect what you found.
I found this 10 PSI Bayou Classic regulator with needle valve on Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Bayou-Classic-M5HPR-1-Regulator-Assembly/dp/B0009JXYSM
Is 10 PSI appropriate for a propane smoker? (I have a Landmann 3405BGW)
good day
I wish to make the same mod.
Can you supply the various part sizes required
thanks
Acidpacket, did you purchase the 10 PSI Bayou Classic from Amazon? If so, did it have a needle valve or an adjustable regulator? The Bayou Classic M5HPR-30 has an adjustable regulator. Been looking for a needle valve assembly for my Masterbuilt XL.
Hey Dude Smoker. I ordered the 10 PSI regulator from that link, and it did indeed have a needle valve as shown in the picture. Seems to be working well for me so far.
SmokingMeatForums.com › Articles › Needle Valves For Gassers