Opinions on Fish and Meat in the same box

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

maineac

Smoke Blower
Original poster
Mar 13, 2010
85
39
Central Maine
I could use some opinions here.  I've been smoking for 8-9 years now but have never smoked sausage and I am ready to jump in.  I have an Original Bradley which was my first smoker and I still use it for salmon and mussels because it fills that low temp niche nicely but it hasn't had anything but fish in it for maybe 5-6 years.  I have read in a number of places that you should have separate boxes for fish and meat and I'm wondering how important that is.  Before I had other smokers I did both fish and meat in it and I don't remember a cross effect.  I know some of you guys have super taste buds but I'm thinking I might not know the difference if I smoked some sausage in that OBS.  I realize that I could try it and see what I think but if you guys think it would be a mistake I will do something different from the get-go.  I don't want my first sausage smoke to be a bust. 

Thanks for looking, and maybe some insight.
 
I have an MES 40 and do both meat and fish,never had a problem.No one that has eaten any of it had any complaints

Richie 
 
Maineac, morning...   I had and still have and use my original smoker...  All I ever smoked was fish...  salmon, trout, oysters etc.... for years....   Then I smoked a turkey in it...   Turkey tasted like fish... had to throw it out it was sooooooo bad....  

I've read where folks say "there's no problem"...     I always smoked Pacific Salmon..  wild caught...   very fatty fish with a powerful flavor...    

Anywho, I bought a second smoker for meats... beef, pork and poultry and never looked back....

If you have the room and a few extra bucks, my advice is buy a second smoker and save the fish smoker for fish...  Probably makes the best smoked fish anyway...   that's what I find with mine..   had it over 30 years.....

 
Thanks, Dave.  I think I'm going to watch Craigslist for another Bradley since I'm set up for it.  There is one avail now but 5 hr away.  I do get some wicked nice salmon out of that box so I hate to mess with the inside.  My wife has smoked salmon 4-5 times a week for breakfast so I go through a bunch.  I'll work on fresh sausage until I get another box.

 
I like your mod. I may have to do something similar so I can get true cold smoking and still use the Bradley biscuit burner if I ever get it to feed correctly...
 
Thanks, Doug.  I did it mostly so I could smoke out of the elements.  It's in our detached garage and it works great for the salmon and mussels.

I have had problems with the biscuit feeder also and right now it works correctly but I stopped using it last year.  Now I use 2 of the foot long A-Maze-N tubes with apple pellets.  They last about 4 hours and give me the heavy smoke we like.  I added the cold smoker microwave to do cheese and ended up not liking the cheese, but it works great so I just left it that way.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky