Pulled Pork, Second Attempt Qview

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

disco

Epic Pitmaster
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Oct 31, 2012
11,135
5,265
Canadian Rockies
The first time I tried pulled pork, I pulled it too soon as I hadn't allowed enough time.

The snow is finally leaving Passing Wind Estates here in the rockies so I decided it was time to try again.


I was able to get a 4 pound pork butt roast unfortunaly boned but it was on sale for less than the national debt. I slathered it with mustard (first time I am trying this for a rub).


I used my own rub that I use for grilling. I vary it a bit from time to time but this is the basic recipe:

Passing Wind Estate Rub

15 ml Kosher salt
15 ml Sugar
15 ml Brown sugar
5 ml Onion powder
15 ml Chili powder
1.25 ml Black pepper
65 ml Paprika
5 ml Garlic powder


I rubbed it on the roast yesterday at lunch and let it rest in the fridge.


My old guy plumbing woke me up at 3 am so I figured what the heck and through it in the Bradley at 230 F over hickory.


Shortly after I got up, it reached an internal temperature of 140 F and I pulled it and wrapped it foil and threw it into a 230 F oven.


Now I am waiting. I will take it to 208 F and then let it rest for 2 hours. I will add SoFlaQuer'd finishing sauce and cross my fingers! More pictures will be posted as I go.


 
Oh boy that is gonna be good. Did you use the oven for convenience? PP is one of my absolute favorite things. You can do so much with it including using it to add to ground beef for burgers etc.. Pork Rules!
36.gif
 
Oh boy that is gonna be good. Did you use the oven for convenience? PP is one of my absolute favorite things. You can do so much with it including using it to add to ground beef for burgers etc.. Pork Rules!
36.gif
I used the oven because I'm cheap. It is still cold in the mornings here and I figured I'd pay for calories that would stay inside instead of heating up the outdoors. When it gets hot, I will do it all the way in the Bradley. I also love pork. Any creature that is that well marbled was meant to eat!
 
Oh that makes sense didn't even look at your location. When is the thaw gonna come for you? 
It is getting up to about 55 F during the day but it is still freezing at night. Our last day of frost is usually around the end of May. Were you part of the bad weather in the US this spring?
 
Luckily we are a bit further south and west than where the storm hit. Its fairly temperate here. A bit chilly in the winter and a bit hot in the summer but overall not too bad. Typically the worst we get are some really bad thunderstorms. 
 
Luckily we are a bit further south and west than where the storm hit. Its fairly temperate here. A bit chilly in the winter and a bit hot in the summer but overall not too bad. Typically the worst we get are some really bad thunderstorms. 
Sounds nice! Not enough for me to leave the mountains, but nice.
 
Meat has it's own schedule, so far timing is about right....sounds like your weather about like ours here on the other end of the Rockies right now...and yup   I wouldn't give up the mountains.
 
Meat has it's own schedule, so far timing is about right....sounds like your weather about like ours here on the other end of the Rockies right now...and yup   I wouldn't give up the mountains.
I have traveled in the mountains from New Mexico north. I really love the area you are in. Still beautiful mountains but quite different from here. Now 11 1/2 hours on the butt. This is a real eye opener for a newbie!
 
The last butts I did took just over 16 hours!! Glad I had a therm with alarms! Was able to sleep, finally pulled out of the smoker at 2am! I foiled them and let them rest until I got up at 6. Pulled the meat and made some pulled pork hash and eggs!
 
MMMM....I always get better results from the WSM than the MES!  Don't know why...the flavors are all the same no matter which pit I use but the times are always better coming off of the WSM!!!!

Can't wait to see the finished product DISCO!!!

Bill
 
The last butts I did took just over 16 hours!! Glad I had a therm with alarms! Was able to sleep, finally pulled out of the smoker at 2am! I foiled them and let them rest until I got up at 6. Pulled the meat and made some pulled pork hash and eggs!
Now I know what is meant by low and SLOW! Har  Coming up on 14 1/2 hours and the internal temperature is 197. Hanging in there but really wanting to taste the end product!
 
MMMM....I always get better results from the WSM than the MES!  Don't know why...the flavors are all the same no matter which pit I use but the times are always better coming off of the WSM!!!!

Can't wait to see the finished product DISCO!!!

Bill
Perhaps you can help a poor ignorant newbie out. I am assuming that WSM and MES are brand names of smokers? Sorry if it is a stupid question but I am stupid.
 
Am I missin somethin?  14.5 hrs for a 4 lb butt?!?!  That's over 3 hrs per lb!!!  The last butt cook I did was an overnighter for two butts (no wrap); one 9.5 lb and one 8 lb, and they were done in 11.5 hrs (~ 1.2 hrs per lb).  Granted I cooked them slightly higher temp (250*) but something's not right here fellas.  I say poke the butt with a skewer or temp probe and if it slides in like a hot knife through butter it's done.  Temp is only a hint at the finish line... tenderness tells you when it's done.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky