Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
Results are in! I pulled the first butt after an hour and had me a sammie, it was excellent. I know where all you bark hounds are coming from now. This was the spicier of the two rubs and the bark was heaven. It was just a touch on the dry side but nothing a little finishing sauce couldn't make right. After my snack I caught a ride to town with a friend and let the other sit in the cooler till I got back. After 4 hours of rest it was holding at 161 and there was much more juice in the foil. It pulled apart great and seemed much jucier than the one that rested for an hour. Well here we go with the Q-view
Resting in the cooler
Butt #1
Time to eat
Back to pulling #1
Butt #2...notice the extra juice
Yep......
Bear view
And after a container set aside for supper, what I ate for lunch and giving a bag to my friend, I've still got a nice bit of PP to freeze. Sammies with slaw on top for supper tonight.
So I did learn some valuable info from this smoke. I will always let the cooler rest go 3 hours. Still don't know what the deal with my AMNPS was, but next time I'll do it during the day so I can keep an eye on it. I'm going to play with soflaquer's finishing sauce recipe a bit...I did 2/3 cider vinegar and 1/3 apple juice but still was missing something I was looking for. As always, thank all of you who have answered questions, offered suggestions, and posted step by steps and your own smokes that I could learn from. I ended up with some fantastic pulled pork that may have otherwise been less than stellar if not for everyone here. I'm off to have a sammie and think about what I want to attempt next!