1. Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Pork butt or shoulder?

Discussion in 'Pork' started by okie from muskogee, Dec 12, 2005.

  1. I have not smoked a pork shoulder or a butt yet. So which is the better value, shoulder is around $1.29 lb and butt is around $1.99 lb.
  2. TulsaJeff

    TulsaJeff Smoke Whisperer Staff Member Administrator OTBS Member


    Basically, a whole pork shoulder is broken up into 2 sections.. the boston butt and the picnic. Usually when you eat pulled pork in a restaurant or you hear folks talking online about pulled pork they are referring to the boston butt which is the upper part of the pork shoulder.

    It is extremely easy to smoke and very forgiving to new smokers becuause of the nice marbling of fat throughout the meat that helps keep the meat moist during long smokes.

    I personally feel that the butt has a better overall flavor than the picnic but that again is a matter of preference and will vary depending on who you talk to.

    I rarely see a whole pork shoulder around here so I have not done any price checking of butts vs the whole shoulder but it does seem odd that it would be that wide of a margin between the two.

    Maybe others in here have noticed that as well and can shed some light on the reason for the difference in price.

    For the most part.. if you have the opportunity to buy the whole shoulder then it would be an excellent smoking experience as well as a good way to feed the neighbourhood.
  3. Hi Jeff
    Albertson's sells what they call a shoulder, it must be the picnic. So if this is the case which is a better buy.
  4. Dutch

    Dutch Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead OTBS Member OTBS Admin SMF Premier Member

    okie, go with the butt as there is just the top portion of the shoulder blade in it. the picnic has the lower portion of the shoulder blade as will as part of the shank (leg) bone.
  5. bob-bqn

    bob-bqn Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    I prefer the Boston Butt cut as well (shoulder blade bone-in).
  6. Thanks Guys [​IMG]