• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

how to get the best bark?????? on a pork shoulder!!!!

bigharve

Newbie
4
10
Joined Jun 1, 2009
I need some advice on getting a really good bark on a shoulder. My butts turn out great but I am still new to this and cant get that deep black bark at the end. HELP!!!!
 

fire it up

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
5,169
14
Joined Feb 24, 2009
Well first off, welcome to the site bigharve.

Would help to know what kind of smoker you have and what you have tried in the way of smoking butts.
Slathering with mustard and a good rub, spritzing during the process.
Sugars, especially brown sugar, breakdown/burn quicker which creates a bark but with a butt you need to be careful.
I'm sure you'll be smoking some greatness in no time, any info you can add will help us help you achieve the smoke you are looking for.
 

erain

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
2,678
30
Joined Feb 2, 2008
rub ingredients and adhesion are the two biggest things i can think of, along with the adhesion if your spritzing are you washing off the carmelizing materials in the rub by over spritzing???
 

oldschoolbbq

Legendary Pitmaster
OTBS Member
9,361
200
Joined Jul 16, 2008
Well, adhesion is a good thing
in addition one should keep his lid SHUT


I do a lot of PP as the in-laws go through it like sauce through a Goose.
Once I have the smoker to 220*F, I place the Butt(s) on to smoke and don't open the lid till my estimated time to cook is about an hour from done(1.5hrs./lb.). I feel that opening the lid delays the coking and allows the bark to cool just a little and get soft.I could be wrong, but it does make for a really nice Bark, with a SNAP
!

The interior is always juicy and tender(falls apart as I am removing it from the smoker)and the bone just falls out.
My matra is STP-Smoke,Temperature and Patience. Get bored waiting?Drink more liquid

Hope this helps and SMOKE HAPPY:)-
 

tasunkawitko

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
2,397
26
Joined May 27, 2008
a couple of suggestions ~

if you are mopping/spritzing, wait at least two hours after putting the meat on the grate before doing so - this will give the rub a chance to set up (you DID slather the pork with mustard first, right?) - also, use a fine spray and be gentle.

don't foil during cooking. if the pork is wrapped in foil, it's not making bark - also, this traps a LOT of moisture in with the meat, and what bark you do have is going to be spongy and soft. foil when the meat's done, but not during cooking.

hope this helps.
 

thebodyman

Newbie
25
10
Joined May 21, 2009
do you have to put mustard on it i am not really a fan of mustard is there something else that is good
 

formerlyfatguy

Smoke Blower
SMF Premier Member
128
10
Joined May 14, 2008
You don't have to put mustard, but it helps the rub to "stick" better.
You will not taste the mustard at all when finished.
 

pignit

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
1,928
28
Joined Nov 3, 2008
I put my rub on when I'm getting ready to put the butt on. I don't use mustard... tried it and compared and saw no noticable difference so I don't take the time. I don't open my smoker up until the butt is done. No spritzing. No mopping. They turn out nice and juicy with a nice bark. I also don't use sugar in my rub.

The only time I spritz is when I'm doing ribs and have to open the smoker up anyway. I think that opening the smoker to mop or spritz does more harm than good. I always have a good bark in the electric or the gas. I just purchased my first stick burner so I don't have any experience with that.... yet.

Remember.... you get to keep doin it until you get it right.... then you get to try and do it that good again.
 

mikey

Smoking Fanatic
514
10
Joined Aug 10, 2008
Welcome to smf, bigharve. The first thing I do is whack all the fat cap off. No point in cookin' what you're not going to eat. There's enough fat internally to keep it from drying out. IMO, I feel it promotes an even bark all the way around the butt. I open my smoker lid twice, once to put the butt on and the 2nd time to take it off. No spritz or mop here either. Poppin' the lid every hour to spritz just adds time to the cook, imo.
 

pignit

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
1,928
28
Joined Nov 3, 2008
Yep... forgot to mention that. I always cut off any excess fat on butts or shoulders or brisket. I like to leave it on when I'm doing CB or Strami.
 

linescum

Smoking Fanatic
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
917
12
Joined Nov 12, 2006
rub with evoo then apply rub let set for a couple hours and apply more rub..then during the last hour, hour and a half brush with a honey butter or maple syrup and butter glaze and turn up the heat a little
 

tasunkawitko

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
2,397
26
Joined May 27, 2008
bodyman -

i've heard of people using olive oil with some success.

there is something about mustard that really makes a great bark, and i can guarantee that you will not taste any mustard when it's all over. the smoke, heat, cooking process or soemthing transforms the mustardy taste into something else entirely - absolutely guaranteed.

give it a try, or if you prefer, give olive oil a try - just a light rubbing down. i am sure there are other things that might work as long as they don't contain an excess of sugar.
 
1
10
Joined Jul 14, 2013
 The rich deep black bark your looking for can only be achieved from hours on the smoker.  Sure you could get it black by just setting over the fire until its.... well burnt,  but that totally not the same thing.  I just happened across this when I first started just because I love standing outside with the grill.  Another tip is to paint it with bbq sauce,  this will be quicker due to the sugars in the sauce.  So when your pork has that bark but its not done just wrap it in tin foil with juice or you can put it in the crock pot (sometimes I do this) all night and have it ready to go in the morning like on a camping trip or whatever.  Hope this helps
 

doomahx

Newbie
11
10
Joined Jun 17, 2012
do you have to put mustard on it i am not really a fan of mustard is there something else that is good
If you have eaten a fair share of BBQ from restaurants and other people then chances are you have eaten BBQ made with mustard :)
 
Last edited:

cliffcarter

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Group Lead
2,270
244
Joined Feb 28, 2010
 The rich deep black bark your looking for can only be achieved from hours on the smoker.  Sure you could get it black by just setting over the fire until its.... well burnt,  but that totally not the same thing.  I just happened across this when I first started just because I love standing outside with the grill.  Another tip is to paint it with bbq sauce,  this will be quicker due to the sugars in the sauce.  So when your pork has that bark but its not done just wrap it in tin foil with juice or you can put it in the crock pot (sometimes I do this) all night and have it ready to go in the morning like on a camping trip or whatever.  Hope this helps
If you have eaten a fair share of BBQ from restaurants and other people then chances are you have eaten BBQ made with mustard :)
How come no one asked sparkimus prime to head over to Roll Call? Was it the crockpot comment?
 On another note my favorite SMF pastime of reading threads resurrected from ancient times has been satisfied once again
 

smoking b

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
5,096
486
Joined Sep 20, 2012
I don't use mustard either - I tried it once & will NOT be using it again. I get great bark without it in my MES - Good coating of rub, no water in the pan, no spritzing & no foiling till it's done. 
 

flash

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
5,293
43
Joined Mar 30, 2007
My wife balked at me using mustard one time, but as stated, you will not taste the mustard when all is said and done. Only there to help the rub adhere. Does not help in the formation of bark.
 
Last edited:

bamaboysmoker

Newbie
9
10
Joined Sep 26, 2014
. Smoked with pecan wood temp 230 to 250 for 12 hrs no mopping or sauce dry rub 6hrs before I put on smoker but I do brine it in apple pine apple and orange juice for 6hrs then let sit 6hrs rubed with a lil brown sugar in the rub
 

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.