How does one accurately determine when a stuffed Fatty is done......

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.


Original poster
Jun 2, 2007
Obviously you can place the probe into an unstuffed Fatty and get an accurate internal temperature, but what about when it is stuffed with onions, jalapenos and cheese. Any thoughts would be appreciated?

Doing a monster Fatty half with bacon half without and two butts -- all smoked with lump charcoal and hickory chunks on a large grill using indrect method.

Thanks, MH
@ 225-250 2-3 hours should "git-r-done".i put mine on the pit farthest from the fire & go 3-4 hrs but thenmy fattiesare quite large most times. here'sa shot of my "centipede"-a super fatty using 2 rolls of jimmy dean. notice it's as large as the rack of beef ribs.
You can probably still take it's internal temp. If the middle where the stuffing is done then the exterior probably is too. There is so much fat content I think it's probably pretty tolerant if you keep it on a bit too long. Worse comes to worse you might actually have to taste a piece; if you need a volunteer, I am available
just took it off after 2.25 hours and it was amazing on toast with eggs (Fatty Sandwich). Two butts to go and corn souffle, collards and Dutch's baked beans for dinner with homemade chocolate mousse cake.

Collard Green Recipe (Created during tailgating)

2 bags of pre chopped and cleaned Collards
smoked ham hocks, tails or turkey necks or bacon
4-8 oz coke (the acid helps break down the greens and the sugar neutralizes any bitterness)
large onion - diced
bourbon - one shot (for the pot, but you can always make another for yourself. If you only have one shot left....well then you have a tough call to make)
4 oz beer - drink the rest
Heaping teaspoon of sugar
salt and pepper to taste
vinegar pepper sauce and/or hot sauce to taste

1. Cook down meat (you can use as much or as little as you like) and diced onion in a large stock pot (the taller the better) until onions are tender. Fat from meat should be sufficient, but if not you can add a little EVOO to cook down the onions. You can leave the meat whole or chop it up and eat it with the greens, it is up to you.

2. Add a little water (see Note below) and then beer, bourbon and coke to the bottom of the large stock pot. Scrape off all the juices from the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon.

Note: At this point add just a little water as well. You want the liquid to barely cover your greens so add a little at a time. Also, the greens, like any other leafy green will cook down considerably, so don't add too much water, you can always add more later. It takes time, but you will get the feel of this.

3. Add half a bag of the collards and cover for a couple minutes until the greens cook down to half the size they were. Then add the other half of the bag. Do this until all the collards are in the pot. Remember to get the liquid level just up to the top of the greens, but also remember that the greens will cook down. It won't take as much liquid as you think doe to the fact the collards will cook down and release most of their stored water as well

4. Cook on low until they reach the tendernees you desire. I recommend at least two hours, probably more depending on the level you cook them at. The longer you cook them the more they will cook down and the more tender they will be.

5. Add salt and pepper to taste. Finally, add pepper sauce and/or hot sauce to the greens in the pot or at the table.

Go great by themselves or on some cornbread.

Obviously, these amounts are not exact, but feel free to add/subtract amounts and ingredients. I never measure anything, but did so here only for convenience. As long as you have some meat, onions,salt and pepper and water you will be good, but the coke is the secret ingredient.

Thanks and good luck.
As long as you reach an internal temperature of 160°, youâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]re good to go, why overcook and compromise the quality of your dish. Get one of those instant read clip-on spike thermometers ($9.00) I wear mine like a ball point pen when I smoke.
i found that at 160 in 3 hrs the raw vegies werent quite done in the middle, very much werth eating tho id probly let it go to 170 to finish the veggy's.
How does one accurately determine when a stuffed Fatty is done......

When they get up from the table...
I've got an age old secret... eat it! You'll know right away if it's done or not.. if not make another one and try again
icon_biggrin.gif is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.