NOT! My goodness, my two beagles are passed out, stoned, crosseyed and full bellies. They can't walk straight. I gave them one each a nice beef rib (no other bones, they splinter and can kill your dog!) from my Masterbuilt break-in and I've never heard their barking like this before. Charlotte's "wee-youuuu" went into a whole other hearing range that only dogs can hear. They came back upstairs with greasy chins, wagging tails, burping and useless. They'll be asleep for hours. These were VERY smokey ribs and they went into orbit!