First time smoking fish - whitefish w/ Q View

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

msaunders

Newbie
Original poster
Feb 29, 2012
19
11
Fargo, ND
Well guys, it's time to fire up the smoker.  After a great trip up to the Ontario side of Lake of the Woods, I came back with a lot of nice fish, including some whitefish.  I decided to give the whitefish a shot in the smoker.  The lady that does the cooking at Flag Island Resort gave me a recipe for a brine, so I tried that.  I'm hoping it's not going to be too salty, but we'll see when it's done.  If it turns out, I'll post the recipe.

So, here goes.  Hopefully I can get some photos uploaded.  I'm using flickr, not photobucket, and not sure if they're going to allow the direct link to the image.  We'll see...

Caught this dandy whitefish up on Shoal Lake.

9c466aac_6823675508_1096778745.jpg


Whitefish fillets in brine.

47a14c67_6823688682_a8a092c76a.jpg


Rinsed and ready to dry.

5c441a64_6823689842_236f7046b4.jpg


Got some pellicle.

7ab38327_6969813703_f59c4593b5.jpg


Ready to add fire!

89d1fd92_6969814795_f943604d3f_z.jpg


Got some TBS.

d5b8b6a7_6969815779_0896565322_z.jpg


Temp is holding steady at 190F.  I'll be back in a few hours with pictures and hopefully a good report!

-Mike
 
Here's the finished product.  It turned out delicious!  Brine recipe to follow.

Finished in the smoker:

628d3905_6831479230_90333c79b1_z.jpg


First batch done.

3fca6d2c_6831478188_dab6b32887_z.jpg


I also did some Tullibee (aka Cisco) fillets.  Those turned out pretty good, too.  Just gotta be sure to scrape off the red fat meat on the skin side of the fillet.

Tullies ready to smoke:

ee8adc5c_6977609635_45916ac165_z.jpg


Ding!  Fries are done!

0d6d4b87_6977608333_36f763dd0f_z.jpg


The whitefish were brined for about 20 hours, I believe.  The tullibee fillets were brined for about 16 hours.  The second batch of whitefish I did the next day were brined about 12 hours or so, probably could have been done a few hours longer.

The brine I used was:

1 gallon water

1 cup brown sugar

1 cup pickling salt

1/8 cup coarse ground black pepper

1/4 cup granulated garlic

7 bay leaves

2 tbsp. onion powder

The tullibee probably don't need as much salt since they're a much thinner fillet.  I think a 1/2 cup salt would have been fine on those.  The fillets were smoked about 4.5 - 5 hours at 190.  I used hickory and apple chips.  I had to reload the chips about once every 75-90 minutes.  Still figuring out how to use my smoker.  I could probably get the smoke time down if I use more chips and have to open the smoker fewer times (mine doesn't have a separate chip drawer).

The fish turned out amazing, especially considering I've never smoked fish before, and never used this smoker before.  I'm impressed with my Masterbuilt extra wide propane smoker and how well it kept the temperature stable.

-Mike
 
Those are some big Whities! Especially thru the ice!! Nice work! They're super boney, but you probably know that by now but some of the tastiest. I know some spots here in CO you can fly fish for them. 

Looks tasty! 
 
Last edited:
Wow really pretty! The color is great....JJ
 
@thoseguys26 - Where about in CO?  I have some uncles living in Denver and get down there from time to time to visit them.  Would love to catch some in the summer time on some light tackle!

@Chef JimmyJ - Yeah, I was amazed at the color when they came out.  Really nice deep golden brown color.

Thanks, everybody! 
 
They're more common than most people think. Rivers and lakes. Colorado river, cache la poudre, yampa, frying pan. They spawn in the fall, have small soft mouths, but are tasty! I'm driving all the way up to fly fish the Yampa tomorrow, can't wait!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky