I really like the spoonbill, but I'm with ya in the fact that it isn't the favorite of the fish I chase either.
Seems everyone has a favorite fish and it's different from person to person. I'm in the minority down here. My favorite to fish for and eat are them whites and hybrids. There ain't nothin' like chasin' a school of shad, waitin' and hopin' for the surface to boil, then bustin' them bass one after another.
I lived in Iowa for a big portion of my life and gained a likin' for carp too. Most folks won't eat carp in the south. Same as NO ONE in the north would eat a sucker. But down here, the favorite is sucker. Nixa, MO, where I work, even has a weekend in the spring when they celebrate the hognose sucker. It's called Sucker Days, and everyone turns out to eat them and join in the festivities.
Since being here, I've eaten and very much enjoy Gar. When eaten hot, right out the oil, there's nothin' better.
I lived in Traverse City, MI for a while, and up there if you get caught eating carp or even catfish, they'll run ya out of town. It's fresh King or Cohoe Salmon, or get the hell out.
I've smoked every fish I've listed here with the exception of gar, and I can't think of a better way to prepare them fish. Except maybe picklin' that carp. Oh yeah, now that's good stuff.
Hey ultramag, next spring when I go to Warsaw to snag, maybe we can hook up and do some snaggin' together. Maybe share some cookin' wisdom. I also do a lot of bow fishing up there. And if you are ever down this way, maybe visiting Bass Pro or somethin' holler at me, I'll smoke up some fresh killed home raised chickens or turkeys for us. Anyone else for that matter. If you're ever anywhere near Springfield, give me a holler.