BBQ Hash and Rice...(Long read and lots of pics)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Gonna Smoke

Smoking Guru
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Sep 19, 2018
6,279
9,358
South Carolina
...or hog head hash as it was called when I was growing up, is a BBQ joint staple around here. It is served in over half the BBQ joints in South Carolina and everyone has their own recipe even though most are very similar. For many, many years, SC had hash houses all over the state which only sold their own hash and rice, but now they are gone due to DHEC regulations and hash & rice is only served in BBQ joints. Hash can be bought in many grocery stores, too. Many use potatoes as an extender, but I do not and it's always served over rice. Here is one good article, but there are many...

Anyway, when growing up and we would do a pig roast, the head, liver, kidneys, and heart always went into the hash. Some people used the lights(lungs), we did not and that's not allowed here anymore for commercially available hash. I can remember my uncle making hash in a big cast iron cauldron and stirring it with a big hickory stick. Making hash was the ONLY thing that pot and stick were used for and I often wonder whatever happened to them. The head went into the pot covered with water and was boiled over a fire for hours until everything could be removed from the bone and shredded. He then would add in the organs, a beef roast or two, and the seasonings and continue to boil until everything cooked apart. I got to watch, but not participate as this was his thing so not real sure what all the seasonings were with the exception of yellow mustard and white vinegar. These days, most places only use Boston butt and maybe a beef roast.

Fast forward quite a few years and I made my own recipe which I make following my memory of what it tasted and looked like along with other hash I've eaten at various BBQ joints. My recipe changes somewhat each time I make it depending on taste and consistency and I haven't made any it far too long, but it was time to change that, especially since Sheila loves it as does everyone in my zoo. So here we go...

List of ingredients I used this time...
  • 8 lb. Boston butt
  • 3 lb. top round roast because I had it
  • 1 lb. pack of beef liver
  • 1 quart unsalted chicken broth
  • 1 quart unsalted beef broth
  • 1 large yellow onion
  • 4 cups yellow mustard
  • 2 cups white vinegar
  • 3 palmfuls of coarse black pepper
  • No salt because this gets salty enough with the mustard
20250114_115835[1].jpg

20250114_121714[1].jpg

20250114_124303[1].jpg

20250115_073523[1].jpg

20250114_154850[1].jpg


I diced the onion and softened in a little EVOO...
20250114_132010[1].jpg


I ground all the meat and liver through the kidney plate. Before I had a grinder, I would coarsely chop it...
20250114_124246[1].jpg


The onion, ground meat, and broth went into a large pot and brought to a simmer...
20250114_125538[1].jpg

20250114_132207[1].jpg


After an hour or so, I added in the mustard and pepper. I started with 2 cups and as it cooked, I tasted and added more until I got the flavor I wanted. Ended up being 4 cups..
20250114_150451[1].jpg


This is simmered for a couple more hours and then I add in the vinegar. Adding the vinegar too early and the flavor will cook out. This is simmered another hour or so until I get the consistency and flavor I'm looking for. I call it "soupy thick".

Hash is always served over rice as a side dish for whatever BBQ is on the menu, pulled pork this time. Goes really well with fried chicken, too. Usually around here, green beans, mac & cheese are also on the plate. I served with my coleslaw and bread & butter pickles. Time to eat...
20250114_173926[1].jpg


We have been eating hash and rice our whole lives and it wasn't until very recently that I found out this style of hash is unique to SC. It is served at a few places in Georgia and NC, but it migrated there from here, from what I've read. I always assumed that it was a staple at all BBQ joints because it is so prevalent here. As with so many dishes, it was a way for people years ago to use every part of everything they raised and was considered poor man's food. Potatoes were added as an extender. If someone wants to read about hash and it's history, do an interweb search for BBQ hash.

What got me looking into this was at Christmas, my BIL brought a new BBQ book here he had just bought about the history of SC BBQ. Pretty good book with lots of stories and recipes, I've got my own copy on order...

Going Whole Hog​

1736946426099.png
 
GS, I remember having this a few times at joints off the base near Fort Bragg back in the late 70's . I had forgotten about this dish because as you said it was a local dish, great recipe and post!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gonna Smoke
Interesting! That's a lotta mustard!
It is a lot of mustard, but the hash is supposed to have a twang. I keep tasting until the flavor gets to what I'm looking for. It was not overpowering at all as one might think it would be. Also, I have 6 quarts left over so this made a lot of hash.

I appreciate your comments...
 
  • Like
Reactions: mr_whipple
GS, I remember having this a few times at joints off the base near Fort Bragg back in the late 70's . I had forgotten about this dish because as you said it was a local dish, great recipe and post!!
Thanks for your comments...
 
Heck of an informative write up there Charles. I don’t know anything about that style of hash but it sounds interesting and looks delicious. Nice work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gonna Smoke
I would definitely give that a taste, even though it has that beef liver in it🤢

It's probably not that prevalent buried under the mustard and vinegar


"I call it "soupy thick"".

I call stuff I make of that consistency "goop"!

"the hash is supposed to have a twang".

That's a Carolina word isn't it? It's on the Dukes mayo jar too!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gonna Smoke
Heck of an informative write up there Charles. I don’t know anything about that style of hash but it sounds interesting and looks delicious. Nice work.
Eric, it's always been around and I just took it for granted that everyone who knew BBQ, knew about hash and rice. Give it a try sometime, or better yet, come over here and try it one day, you may get hooked...😄
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinEdge
I would definitely give that a taste, even though it has that beef liver in it🤢

It's probably not that prevalent buried under the mustard and vinegar
Yeah, you can't taste the liver at all. I added it because the pork liver is traditional and since I had the beef liver, well...
"I call it "soupy thick"".

I call stuff I make of that consistency "goop"!
😄
"the hash is supposed to have a twang".

That's a Carolina word isn't it? It's on the Dukes mayo jar too!
Like hash, twang might just be a SC thing. But this hash isn't overly "mustardy", just a little twang...🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: 912smoker
Great thread Charles! Hash made around here isn't anything like that... imagine that, coming from a damn yankee! :emoji_blush:
But I'd gladly sit down and try some! Nice work!

Ryan
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gonna Smoke
I'll be by for a taste in 5 minutes!

Have you ever had hash from Midway outside of Union SC - I judge all hash by theirs. Back 15-20 years ago I had an ex brother in law lived in Union. Whenever we'd go camping or fishing or gold prospecting if we could we'd stop and get a at least a quart. Eat it straight out of the container with crackers for a quick snack. Sometimes we'd get a couple of quarts and not take any other food (other than the crackers)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gonna Smoke
Heck of an informative write up there Charles. I don’t know anything about that style of hash but it sounds interesting and looks delicious. Nice work.
It's unique to this area and not many places serve it anymore. When I moved to SC in the mid 90's every little Q joint had it on the menu. I don't think there is a single place in the county I live in (100k people or more) that still serves it.

It's the pepper that makes it. I would probably triple or even quadruple the onion Charles used. I've never gotten it just right, I've never used that much mustard. I think I'll give it a go with his proportions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinEdge
Great thread Charles! Hash made around here isn't anything like that... imagine that, coming from a damn yankee! :emoji_blush:
But I'd gladly sit down and try some! Nice work!

Ryan
Come on and get you some, Ryan! But I don't know if Iowa qualifies as "damn yankee" territory...🤣
 
I'll be by for a taste in 5 minutes!

Have you ever had hash from Midway outside of Union SC - I judge all hash by theirs. Back 15-20 years ago I had an ex brother in law lived in Union. Whenever we'd go camping or fishing or gold prospecting if we could we'd stop and get a at least a quart. Eat it straight out of the container with crackers for a quick snack. Sometimes we'd get a couple of quarts and not take any other food (other than the crackers)
Stop by and get some, would love to have you!!

I have not eaten at Midway. Most of my BBQ and hash experience is at places like Shealy's in Batesburg-Leesville or further south in the low country such as one of the many Duke's BBQ joints...

There are 319 BBQ joints in SC and 160 have hash on the menu. Here's a good read about SC hash...
 
With all the SC members here now and over the years, I was really surprised that a search on here didn't turn up any results...
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinEdge
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky