Which propane smoker should I get?

Discussion in 'Propane Smokers' started by nimrod1, Mar 16, 2011.

  1. nimrod1

    nimrod1 Newbie

    This is my second post.  I posted in the electric smoker section and the replies led me here.   I have a Little Chief smoker that does a decent job for fish and jerky but other items I usually have to finish in the oven.  Thus, I'm looking for sustained temp of 225 to 275.

    1) How expensive are propane smokers to use? (ie: how fast do do they burn through the propane)

    2) Which propane smoker should I get?  (Those I've noticed are The Smokey Mountain series, the Master Forge and the GOSM?)

    3) Why should I go with propane?  Why should I not go with propane?  (PS:  I think I prefer convenience over tending/perfection)
  2. pineywoods

    pineywoods Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead SMF Premier Member

    I generally get 35-50 hours per 20 lb cylinder of propane

    The smokey mountain series is the GOSM they were bought out but basically the same smoker

    Propane smokers are great for the higher temps and give a better smoke ring than an electric if that matters to you.

    The propane smokers aren't usually insulated like the MES is so in cold climates that may be a consideration.

    Personally I own 2 GOSM's
  3. nimrod1

    nimrod1 Newbie

    So 35 to 50 hours.  How long would you cook say....two racks of ribs?  Thus how many meals of ribs can I get out of one tank?  My ignorance is due to the fact that I have an electric and usually cook partly in the oven. 
  4. pineywoods

    pineywoods Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead SMF Premier Member

    Ribs are one of the few things most of us cook by time and looks instead of temp. If you followed the 3-2-1 method that would be 6 hours per rib smoke.
  5. smokinal

    smokinal Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator OTBS Member ★ Lifetime Premier ★

    You have gotten some good advice nimrod. I don't own a propane smoker, but the advice Piney gives you is golden. If you decide you would like to try a charcoal smoker the Weber Smokey Mountain is a very good choice. It's very well built, economical, easy to maintain steady temps & will produce a good smoke ring. I have to also say that the smoke ring will not change the flavor it just looks cool.If you are looking for convenience then I would look at the Masterbuilt Electric Smokers, they are a favorite of many of the members here.

Share This Page