Need help, first brisket!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

agonolin

Newbie
Original poster
Jul 19, 2017
25
15
New York
Hello all and good morning! I've been up since about one o'clock tending the smoker and drinking and relaxing with some good buddies of mine. I'm cooking my very first brisket and I've read and read and read and I thought I had the theory down solid. I got the offset smoker up to 210-235 range then threw the trimmed brisket fat side up onto the smoker. After 4 hours I opened the cc for an apple cider spritz and a turn and the first thing I noticed is it looked dry. Like really dry, so I started to get nervous. I spritzed extra thinking it would soaked up some more but when I just opened after two more hours it's looking even worse. Is that the start to the bark forming or is that signs that I'm going to have an expensive piece of leather after 15 hours of tending to this thing like it was my baby? I've been looking on the forum for about 30 minutes and I have found anything about being able to tell if it's drying out as your cooking it. Thanks alot guys I've learned a ton on this forum and hope to learn something new yet again
 
So you left fat on top? 1/8 inch or so? You put a rub or seasonings on before you put it on? You put a temp probe into the meat and it's reading what now?
 
So I did it "Texas style" just salt and pepper. I do have a temp probe in and at 10 minutes shy of 8 hours I'm at 176 in the thickest part of the flat. It was a 11.5# packer before trimming. I'm about to spritz again I'll try and put a picture up. Fat cap is still on the top, it was thin when I got it so I didn't take much off the fat cap
 
I feel like after 8 hours there should be more bark and it still looks dry to me. Am I just worrying to much?
 
It doesn't look bad at all.  Keep the lid closed, maintaining consistent heat is what you're after. Start probing around IT of 200 and when no resistance, pull & rest.
 
Yeah it's a full packer. Not a good selection where I live, I only had two to pick from so I picked what I thought was the nicer one
 
Use the toothpick test on it around 190 degrees. It's done when the toothpick slides in smoothly.

Good luck.
 
So I just hit 190 where my probe is, should I start probe testing now? It's only been in just over 10 hours. Does that seem to short a time?
 
I use one of these to check and see if it goes through like butter.

My digital instant read probe. Some places might feed very soft.. some might have more resistance.. it's got to all be like room temp butter. You could check every half hour now I reckon. It might slow down now that it's closer to the cooking temp.
 
Last edited:
Yeah people do use probes to. I don't like making the hole any bigger than it needs to be. Like to keep the moisture in the meat. Toothpicks for me.
 
Been checking every half an hour or so with a toothpick. A couple spots are starting to get pretty tender but a few are still tough. Temp is 200 even after 13 hours. More pics next time I probe
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky