Toggle sidebar

Royal Oak Chef's Select?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
Remove the Ads for LIFE - 50% Off!
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
drum warrior

drum warrior

Newbie
Original poster
Aug 24, 2017
19
17
Bellevue, WA
I've been reading on the forum that Royal Oak wood charcoal gets high marks.  So I picked up this 20lb bag at Cash & Cary this morning and it's labeled "Chef's Select" 100% Hardwood Charcoal Briquets.  Has anyone used this particular kind of Royal Oak?  Curious if I got a good one or if this is one of the lesser desired varieties.  I am going to smoke a couple racks of pork spare ribs and some kielbasa sausages today on my UDS.  I have this Royal Oak on hand and also a bag of Kingsford Lump Briquets which I've been keen to try.  So I'm deciding between the two for today's smoke.  From what I've been reading the Kingsford gets terrible reviews but mostly because people say the wood burns off before the coals are hot.  In a UDS this may not be an issue as you are working a slow burn from the center on out so I hope to still get some of that Mesquite flavor from the Kingsford with my application. Anyhow, curious what you all think about this Royal Oak Chef's Select.  

royal oak.jpg

royal oak.jpg

 
Rings R Us said:
That's good stuff. Just not always available to everyone. And not on sale to much. Let us know how you like it.. if it's less ash than what your used to..
Click to expand...
Thanks for the insight!  I will try it today and report back.  It was only $9.99 per 20lb bag at Cash & Cary.  I hope I like it because for that price, it would be my new go-to charcoal. 
 
So far so good. I'm really enjoying the aroma from this royal oak charcoal in combination with the mesquite and some alder me and my son cut up from a fallen tree here in our neighborhood. This charcoal was easy to light with my chimney and easily got the UDS up to 250 before I turned down the air intake using the ball valves to about 2/3 on each. I have two ball valves and one fixed intake hole on my UDS. More to come. Will let everyone know how this charcoal works out.
 
I am using it tonight for an overnight brisket myself. I bought a couple of bags from DoItBest Center, they ship to a store free. A bit higher cost than you paid, $23 for 40 lbs. I have liked it better than Kingsford Blue so far after doing some baby back ribs last weekend with it, much cleaner smoke from my charcoal maze. Thought I had read that the only binder they use is tomato paste or something along those lines.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drum warrior
I6Quer said:
I am using it tonight for an overnight brisket myself. I bought a couple of bags from DoItBest Center, they ship to a store free. A bit higher cost than you paid, $23 for 40 lbs. I have liked it better than Kingsford Blue so far after doing some baby back ribs last weekend with it, much cleaner smoke from my charcoal maze. Thought I had read that the only binder they use is tomato paste or something along those lines.
Click to expand...

How's your brisket going? I am now a fan of the Royal Oak chef select. These ribs taste nice and smoky without a hint of that petroleum taste. I highly recommend this charcoal if you can get your hands on it. It worked well in the UDS. I wrapped the rips in foil after 4 hours and gave em another hour in the foil. That said, with 1/3 bag of this charcoal, I could have gone 8 hours in my UDS. For a Brisket I would go with 1/2 bag in the UDS and should have no problems with a 10-12 hour smoke. Collard Greens and Blackberry Cornbread also turned out nice to compliment the meat tonight. My only regret is that I didn't smoke a larger rack of ribs! Hope everyone's Sat smokes turned out fab.

plate.jpg

plate.jpg

 
Last edited:
It was very good, unfortunately I didn't get pics because it was eaten as fast as I could slice it! I'm planning to stick with this charcoal, very happy with how it burns.
 
We grilled salmon on the chef select tonight and it came out with a nice woody flavor.  Went by Cash n Cary today and they're out.  Hope they can get more soon.  Is the chef select much different than the red bag?
 
Drum Warrior said:
We grilled salmon on the chef select tonight and it came out with a nice woody flavor.  Went by Cash n Cary today and they're out.  Hope they can get more soon.  Is the chef select much different than the red bag?
Click to expand...

I am a new major fan of Royal Oak Ridge briquettes (the red bag). Chef's Select is the same briquette, but 30% larger per briquette. Lowes will have Ridge on sale later this week for $4 per 15.4 lb bag, or just under 26 cents a lb. Ridge burns 140% longer than KBB, Chef Select even longer.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: drum warrior
Noboundaries said:
I am a new major fan of Royal Oak Ridge briquettes (the red bag). Chef's Select is the same briquette, but 30% larger per briquette. Lowes will have Ridge on sale later this week for $4 per 15.4 lb bag, or just under 26 cents a lb. Ridge burns 140% longer than KBB, Chef Select even longer.
Click to expand...
That's very helpful.  At $4 per bag, that's even cheaper than the Chef Select I found at Cash & Carry.  I will need to make a trek to Lowes and pick some up.  Unfortunately Lowes recently closed their shop in Bellevue.  I'll need to drive to their Renton store.  I went to Home Despot today and they don't have the ridge.  Heard Walmart also carries the ridge but not in my town unfortunately.  It's one of their smaller "grocery oriented" shops.  
 
Check the Lowes website between Tuesday and Thursday. That's usually when it goes on sale. If you have a Winco near you, their store brand is actually Royal Oak Ridge. Non-Sale price is usually $5.48 for a 16.6 lb bag, or 33 cents a lb.
 
I picked up a couple bags of the Chefs Select from Cash and Carry. The jury is still out for me on if I like them or not...not because of the typical reasons you would think. Since I use them primarily in my WSM mini and these briquettes are larger, I can't load as many coals in the basket as I would with the smaller briquettes. Therefore I cant go as long with them before I need to reload. This is probably not an issue in your UDS because you have a lot larger basket.
 
Rings R Us said:
Been using these Kroger brand ones up. They seem a bit small but don't produce huge amounts of ash. They do have a natural hardwood briquette and all hardwood lump. I get their stuff when other brands are not on sale.
IMG_20170828_181703.jpg

IMG_20170828_181703.jpg

Click to expand...
Royal Oak Ridge supplies a large number of store brands, obviously including Kroger because those are RO Ridge briquettes. 
 
  • Like
Reactions: drum warrior
Noboundaries said:
 
Royal Oak Ridge supplies a large number of store brands, obviously including Kroger because those are RO Ridge briquettes. 
Click to expand...
This is really helpful and explains why I've been a fan of the Kroger brand briquettes for years.  In fact, it validates that I need to go with my experience and not pay too much attention to brand.  I buy them at both Fred Meyer and QFC especially when they are on sale.  They have never disappointed in my UDS.  I will say though that the Chef Select provided a woodier flavor to my smoke than I associate with the Kroger brands (even though I like them).  I wonder if the composition of Chef Select is just a little different than the stuff they put out for Kroger.  Or maybe the ridge is slightly different than Chef Select and the Kroger briquettes are the same as ridge.  It certainly appears so from your picture.  I will definitely need to get a bag of ridge at Lowes or Winco now to do a comparison with my Kroger.  Thanks for sharing that visual comparison.  Can't believe how much we're geeking out on Charcoal.  Awesome forum!  Funny and true story from the weekend.  Me and my wife went to Fred Meyer.  I was there to geek out on the charcoal selection.  Meanwhile, my wife was pulling my leg to check out the diamonds.  I told her diamonds and charcoal are essentially the same thing as I tried to interest her in a large piece of charcoal to go in one of their settings but she would have nothing of it!  
 
Last edited:
Drum Warrior said:
This is really helpful and explains why I've been a fan of the Kroger brand briquettes for years.  In fact, it validates that I need to go with my experience and not pay too much attention to brand.  I buy them at both Fred Meyer and QFC especially when they are on sale.  They have never disappointed in my UDS.  I will say though that the Chef Select provided a woodier flavor to my smoke than I associate with the Kroger brands (even though I like them).  I wonder if the composition of Chef Select is just a little different than the stuff they put out for Kroger.  Or maybe the ridge is slightly different than Chef Select and the Kroger briquettes are the same as ridge.  It certainly appears so from your picture.  I will definitely need to get a bag of ridge at Lowes or Winco now to do a comparison with my Kroger.  Thanks for sharing that visual comparison.  Can't believe how much we're geeking out on Charcoal.  Awesome forum!  Funny and true story from the weekend.  Me and my wife went to Fred Meyer.  I was there to geek out on the charcoal selection.  Meanwhile, my wife was pulling my leg to check out the diamonds.  I told her diamonds and charcoal are essentially the same thing as I tried to interest her in a large piece of charcoal to go in one of their settings but she would have nothing of it!  
Click to expand...
it's ok for usual price of $6.99 a bag. When everything else is $10~$12 a bag
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Similar threads

Y
Oak Wood? I’m guessing.
Replies
6
Views
460
Woods for Smoking
Smokin Okie
Smokin Okie
PapaRed
Fine powder ash
Replies
2
Views
240
Charcoal Smokers
PapaRed
PapaRed
Brokenhandle
Royal Oak charcoal sale & a little self enabing!
Replies
15
Views
838
Blowing Smoke Around the Smoker.
Brokenhandle
Brokenhandle
ron50
Another charcoal question
Replies
10
Views
1K
General Discussion
ron50
ron50
larryfoster
Masterbuilt 560 ashes in cook chamber
Replies
15
Views
654
Charcoal Smokers
larryfoster
larryfoster
mr mac
Lump Charcoal v. Briquettes - One Man's Opinion
Replies
7
Views
3K
Charcoal Smokers
Gadgetman
Gadgetman
Count Porcula
Dark Ribs with Smokin-It 2
Replies
14
Views
733
Electric Smokers
JLinza
JLinza
Redicans
Lump Charcoal
Replies
14
Views
3K
General Discussion
Chris_in_SoCal
Chris_in_SoCal

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
Back
Clicky