Raw and tuff ribs. What went wrong?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jblud1986

Newbie
Original poster
Jun 29, 2017
12
40
PLEASE HELP!

Hello everyone, I need some help and hoping to get feedback from anyone willing to help. Any help would be greatly appreciated!! Last night I put a slab of St. Louis cut spare ribs on my Landmann charcoal grill with a offset smoker box that I picked up from BJ's wholesale club.

Last night my ribs were in the smoker for about 4 1/2 hours. I placed my ribs in the cooking camber directly on the grate for 3 hours, next I pulled my ribs off, wrapped them in foil with the usual butter, brown sugar and honey and placed back in the smoker for another 2 hours. Next I put BBQ sauce on both sides and placed them directly back on the grate for another 30 mins to caramelize the sauce.

What I noticed when I took the foil off, the rib bones wasn't showing. The entire time I had my temps up to around 235-250 as I kept adding hickory wood and charcoal to the pit/firebox to keep the temps up.

The only temp gauge I was using was the one that came with the smoker that is placed on top of the lid to the cooking chamber. Im assuming that I need to get a temp gauge that attach to your grilling gate to get more accurate temp reading where your meat sits.

My ribs where tough as nails and even raw in some spots as the meat didn't get hot enough to cook, even though it was in the smoker for 4 1/2 hrs. Am I answering my own question as to why my ribs where tough and raw....because they wasn't as hot as the themo temp said it was cooking at? Are those type of temp gauges really off by that much? It seems to me that I did ever thing right by the book to get falling off the bone ribs but clearly Im doing something wrong.

Someone suggested to me that I place the coils inside the cooking chamber, next to the ribs. Someone also told me that I didnt use enough charcoal for as the small amount I used to get 235 wasn't even enough to cook a hamburger. This is smoking, not grilling so Im assuming that 235-250 are the right temps, but my raw ribs say otherwise, please help!

Thanks! Jared.
 
Jared, it's good to have you here on this great site.

The stock gauges are notoriously off. Especially in the lid. They can register 20-30* hotter than at the grate. I would replace that gauge with a River Country therm, available at Amazon. Also a really good digital gauge for the cooker is a Maverick et-732. One probe is to display the grate temp and the other is to put into the meat to show the IT (internal temp).

So, it would definitely appear to me that your ribs were undercooked. If you are going to cook ribs by time, be sure that the cook chamber (CC) is around 10* above your target temp before you put the cold meat in. This will keep your CC temp from dipping too low at first. Also, always pre-heat the wood splits. This will give you a quicker ignition to also keep the temp from dipping too low. By igniting quicker, it will also keep the smoke cleaner.

Good luck and good smoking, Joe. :grilling_smilie:
 
Joe, thank you for your reply and taking the time to answering my questions. The more I think about it, it makes perfect sense why my ribs were undercooked when my lid thermo was reading the desired temp. I never would of guessed that those factory thermos are off by that much from the lid position! I looked into the maverick 730's on Amazon but I also came across a Ivation wireless thermo for half the price but I'm sure you get what you pay for. Anyways, again I really appreciate everything. Until next time!

Jared
 
Jared, The price makes a difference in some cases. However, with the door or lid gauges, I really like the River Country. There are others that are higher priced, but IMO they are no better. Just be sure to check any gauge that you are getting ready to use in boiling water. Be sure to adjust your results to compensate for elevation.

Joe
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky