3 Questions - Ribs, Thermometer, Wood Question

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

relic1882

Newbie
Original poster
Jun 13, 2017
9
14
Northeast Pennsylvania
I have three questions and I wasn't sure of where to ask them. 

I have an Oklahoma Joe modified with baffle plates, and gaskets and clamps. It's sealed off nice and holds heat pretty well.

My first question is, which kind of wood am I best off using in the firebox? I mean chunks or chips. I've been using chunks because I can't find and bigger pieces of wood conveniently. The cherry chunks at Walmart (unfortunately cause I hate that store) are all pretty nice sized in the bag without all the little broken off pieces towards the bottom. I've never used chips, but wasn't even sure how if I wanted to. 

Second question, is if anybody has used these thermometers from BBQSmokermods.com --> http://www.bbqsmokermods.com/product-p/adj-therm-3.htm   How do they rate?

I bought two of them to replace the stock ones because my probe thermometer has been reading way different than the stock thermometer on the smoker. I didn't lower the chimney stack down to grate level yet so I'm thinking that could be partly why.

Third question...

I made baby back ribs the first time I smoked and they turned out awesome. Tender, meat fall off the bone with zero effort awesome. I did those on my OK Joe 3-in-1 combo grill/smoker, that's not modded at all. I used the stock thermometer and cooked them for about 2.5 hours at about 220, then I slathered on BBQ sauce and wrapped them in foil for the last 45 minutes. They could not have turned out better. (for me!) 

The second AND third attempts were on the Highland, and both times I cooked them the same way but they came out dryer and they would not come off the bone without pulling on them quite a bit. Could this just be a severe difference in temperature readings between the two grills or something? I'm not sure but that's my biggest hunch.

I did order the Maverick ET-732 from Amazon that should be here soon so I can use that to compare I guess. 

P.S. This forum is awesome. I've learned a lot and I thank everyone involved!
 
I'll answer what I can. 

Use wood chunks or splits, not chips.  Chips burn up WAY too fast in a hot fire. 

Can't help you with those thermometers.  I used a River Country thermometer to replace my OEM piece of junk and love the RC therm.

The BBs done the second and third times on the Highland were not cooked long enough if they tasted dry and would not pull from the bone.  Different smokers, grills, whatever have different air flow patterns and temperature zones.  You most likely needed more like the 2-2-1 method in the Highland, or just to let them go longer.   

I could finish BB's in 3 hours on my gas grill.  Takes about 60-90 minutes longer on my WSM.
 
wow I would've thought that leaving them on longer would make them even dryer but I guess I'm wrong. Smoking's a whole different ball game huh? thanks for all the info
 
wow I would've thought that leaving them on longer would make them even dryer but I guess I'm wrong. Smoking's a whole different ball game huh? thanks for all the info

Yeah, it's counterintuitive. Muscle with a lot of connective tissue will be dry and tough if undercooked. Ribs, pork butt, brisket all have that structure.
 
Try checking the IT of the ribs. 195 is very tender & juicy , but not quite FOTB.

200-205 is definitely FOTB ribs.

It doesn't matter if you foil them or not. The final IT is what determines the tenderness of the ribs.

Al
 
Try checking the IT of the ribs. 195 is very tender & juicy , but not quite FOTB.
200-205 is definitely FOTB ribs.
It doesn't matter if you foil them or not. The final IT is what determines the tenderness of the ribs.

Al
Good to know. I was pulling them a little sooner than that.

I'm gonna play dumb here but what does FOTB stand for?
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky