First Attempt at Pulled Pork this weekend

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jcam222

Epic Pitmaster
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jun 13, 2017
11,254
13,093
Northeast Ohio
So after several smaller projects in my new smoker I am going all in this weekend for Fathers Day gathering and doing pulled pork. I have read extensively on here regarding brine / no brine, mustard coating, rubs, finishing sauces etc. Will go pretty basic on this one using the step by step from the index and likely will use SocalQ finishing sauce on half the batch. Have settled in on applewood for the smoke. 

My first few smokes have been 2 to 4 hour deals with chicken, pork loin , burgers and meatloafs. With this being a much longer longer smoke I bought an AMPS for my MES40.

So questions with  this behemoth piece of pig at 18.67 lbs. 

1) What is this cut? Is it the butt and shoulder joined?

2) As a whole piece what would my expected smoking time be?

3) Should I have it cut in two to reduce smoking time to what I hope to be 14 hours or less?

Any advice appreciated! Thanks


 
Last edited:
 
So after several smaller projects in my new smoker I am going all in this weekend for Fathers Day gathering and doing pulled pork. I have read extensively on here regarding brine / no brine, mustard coating, rubs, finishing sauces etc. Will go pretty basic on this one using the step by step from the index and likely will use SocalQ finishing sauce on half the batch. Have settled in on applewood for the smoke. 

My first few smokes have been 2 to 4 hour deals with chicken, pork loin , burgers and meatloafs. With this being a much longer longer smoke I bought an AMPS for my MES40.

So questions with  this behemoth piece of pig at 18.67 lbs. 

1) What is this cut? Is it the butt and shoulder joined?  Looks like two butts.  It is common to put two together. 

2) As a whole piece what would my expected smoking time be?  I'd be shocked if you only found one piece of meat. 

3) Should I have it cut in two to reduce smoking time to what I hope to be 14 hours or less?  Been done for you. 

Any advice appreciated! Thanks


 
Looks like you have two there, now for time it depends on what temp you will be doing them and IT you are taking them to, I did 2 in foil pans and spritzed them with rum and apple juice on the rub I put on during the smoke. Had it at 250 to start and were cooking faster than I thought and went down to 225, Took just around the 5 hr mark for them. It was also a very nice warm day out as well. 

  Yours could be different depending on the above questions / conditions. Keep us posted, I will be watching for your results. 
 
Thanks both of you! So assuming its two pieces I plan on cooking to around 200 degrees for the final pull. I believe Ill set the smoker for 240ish. I'll pull and wrap around 160. Would this result in something around  12 hour total?

Also are those butts? I know butts are part of the shoulder piece but it just references blade? LOL sorry just  confused and learning. 

While I am asking questions.................I am planning on using the SoCalQ finishing sauce on half the pulled pork. Is there any merit in putting the finishing sauce in the water pan and ultimately using a mix of the SoCalQ and meat drippings as a finisher?
 
Last edited:
 
Thanks both of you! So assuming its two pieces I plan on cooking to around 200 degrees for the final pull. I believe Ill set the smoker for 240ish. I'll pull and wrap around 160. Would this result in something around  12 hour total?  Since you've got two 9.3 lb roasts there, 12 hours at 240-ish might be a little ambitious unless you crank the temp up once you wrap it. 

Also are those butts? I know butts are part of the shoulder piece but it just references blade? LOL sorry just  confused and learning. They look like butts to me.  Picnics usually have the skin on them and are not called "Boston," at least where I shop.   

While I am asking questions.................I am planning on using the SoCalQ finishing sauce on half the pulled pork. Is there any merit in putting the finishing sauce in the water pan and ultimately using a mix of the SoCalQ and meat drippings as a finisher?  Personally I separate the fat from the drippings, add the drippings back to the meat and save the fat for other uses.  I put finishing sauce in squeeze bottles and let people add the finishing sauce to their sandwich or plate.  I think vinegar loses its zing the longer it sits on the meat.  It makes the meat "pop" when it is added fresh.   I get the squeeze bottles for something like a buck fifty at my existing grocer.  I've seen them for $4 at other grocers.   I always keep a bottle of Chef JJ's finishing sauce in my refrigerator.   I keep a supply of the bottles on hand because when I take pulled pork to family and friends, there's always enough for leftovers, and it just isn't pulled pork to me without finishing sauce.       

View media item 536270
 
Last edited:
Those are indeed butts.  The butt has the blade bone, picnic has the leg bone.
 
Well time to get this party started. Patted them dry, scored fat, coated them with some glue , rubbed them up and tucked them in until tomorrow morning. Had hoped my AMPS would have come in today but didn't. Need to get these going early tomorrow so will just have to hand feed applewood chips to the MES40.

Thanks for all the advice and here are some pics along the way.............

 
Looks tasty,are you planning on resting or serving right away? The best bet is to get them done early and hold foil wrapped,after a short 5-10 min rest in my opinion. Then wrap in a towel and into a dry cooler. Looking forward to more pics!
 
If you want to do them without foiling, then you should expect at least 16 hours at 250. However, I've never had the patience for that. I usually start at 6:30 in the morning and at about 4:30 in the afternoon, while still in the middle of "the stall" (usually at about 158 degrees), I put the foil on. I usually reach the 200-205 final temp within about two hours of foiling. You then need to plan for an hour or so after that to let the meat sit in a pan, usually inside of an insulated cooler, to let it cool down very slowly and reabsorb some juice prior to pulling.
 
Pulled to wrap about a few hours ago at 165. I'll get pics up again later. I know it smells delicious. I also cheated and sliced off a little bark and OMG was it tasty lol.
 
Pulled at 203 and siting in the cooler for an hour. Can't wait to pull it. I will say the biggest concern of th day was the AMPS. I used it for first time today. Followed all the tips on microwaving, filtering out dust. Lit for 10 minutes etc. No dice went out within 15 minutes. Repacked it some, relit and let it burn like a bon fire for 15 minutes. Put back in and maybe got another 15 minutes. Overall only made it a third through the first row. I don't think water was the issue as I had very little in pan. It was placed in the bottom thin pan on the bottom left right next to the burner. Not sure what else I could have done. Any advice appreciated. Seems people either do really well with it or really bad. Wood was their apple pellets.
 
All done, falling apart tender and delicious. A lot of nice drippings in the frig to skim and put back in tomorrow. I also learned that also finishing sauce is very vinegary plain it's the BOMB on the pork lol. A newb learns more :) I'll post up pics tomorrow.
 
Sounds good!  
drool.gif


Mike
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky