First Major Screw-Up

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

cjclemens

Fire Starter
Original poster
May 20, 2016
35
12
Illinois
Well, Friday evening was my first taste of failure (figuratively speaking). I had a request for a smoked pork loin for a family get-together.  Dinner was supposed to be at 7, but my cook went about an hour over.  I've done a couple of pork loins before, and they both went right at 2 hours at 250 degrees.  The loin I cooked on Friday may have been slightly bigger than the previous two, but I didn't bother looking at the actual weight on the tag, since I was in a big hurry to get the smoker set up and get it cooking.  So, I guess you could call that mistake #1.  My next mistake was probably the one that hurt the most - I decided to take a quick shower and get ready for the event, which means for the first 20 minutes, I wasn't watching the temp on my smoker.  By the time I got out to check on it, the temp had drifted down around 230.  I ramped it back up to 250, but it was too little, too late.  I went ahead and put the glaze on, when the IT hit 125 on my probe.  I was thinking I was still right on time, but to my dismay, the temp stalled at 125 for a while, before continuing to rise.  When the probe said 145, I pulled the loin, thinking everything was OK.  I was only 15 minutes behind at this point - or so I thought.  I put the loins on the counter and went to double check the IT with a pen type probe.  As soon as I pushed the probe in, I could tell something was wrong - just from the way it felt when I stuck the probe in.  Sure enough, IT was only 135.  Somehow my cooking probe was almost a full 10 degrees off.  Frustrated, I tossed the loins in the oven to finish them, but they ended up being about an hour too late.  Fortunately, there was already brisket and plenty of sides to feed everyone, but I'm still pretty disappointed with the whole deal - especially since I didn't realize there was a problem until the very end.

I guess the moral of the story is that smoking meats is not something you can put together last minute.  If you don't have time to do it, don't let family members talk you into trying to pull it off.  On the bright side, I did learn some valuable lessons.  Not to mention, I do have a whole smoked pork loin in the fridge that I don't have to share - which slightly offsets the shot my ego took when I had to admit failure.  I apologize for the long rant, but I really needed to let off some steam about this.  Besides, I feel like you guys might understand the feeling better than anyone else!
 
Lessons learned are valuable.  Especially when you share them and others learn from your situation :)

Sounds like it's time to check your cooking probe for accuracy.  I finished building and assembling my HeaterMeter controller PID box over the weekend and tested all 4 probes that go into the controller (1 smoker probe thermocouple, and 3 maverick probes).

The maverick probes were all 5 degrees low and the thermocouple was 4 degrees high.

I'm fortunate because the HeaterMeter controller allows me to assign offsets for the probes. I assigned the offsets and tested twice and BAM everything was right on the money 212F for boiling water! :)

I did learn that maverick probe 1 reports temperature very quickly while maverick probes 2 and 3 report much more slowly.  This shouldn't be an issue in meat but I learned that probe 1 would be my preference to work as the back up smoker probe or an additional smoker probe while 2 & 3 would be meat probes.  Probe 0 is the thermocouple and has an alligator clip. 

I LOVE the idea of having a have a whole combo of measurements I can take with 3 meat/hybrid probes and 1 thermocouple smoker probe!

Anyhow, enough rambling from me and enjoy the pork loin!!!
 
Last edited:
Thanks for sharing, I always feel better when I share my screw ups too.

Mountains out of molehills... An hour ain't anything serious.

Converting expensive prime meat into an inedible lump is... BTDT
The dog stealing the main course is...
A grease fire not only immolating the food, but the grill too, is...

Not that I've had all those happen to me, but one is bad enough.

I try to give my cooks at least 2-4hrs of leeway over the longest reasonable cooking period for reasons just like yours.
Meat will almost always benefit from a nice long rest in a cambro.
Better to be done early, than be done after the guests have dined on delivery pizza... BTDT

I have two instant read probe thermometers, both currently test accurately.
 
Aw man, feel your pain and frustration.  And when one thing gets out of kilter, usually another one closely follows.

Thanks for sharing, reminds me I have a new temp sensor I have not done the boil test on yet, need to do that.

When I am smoking for a crowd I try to adjust my plan to finish way early if I can or even the day before.  A couple extra hours in the cooler resting or just having to reheat up some slices for that meal has always worked out better for me than being late with hungry people with forks and knives in their hands looking at me. Ha Ha

Glad you were able to recover.
 
Thanks, fellas.  It sure is good to have a support group here to lean on.  I've always believed that its all good - as long as you're learning.  I think that applies here.  Let me tell ya - that pork loin sure turned out good, though.  Still nice and tender, even after being reheated in the microwave.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky