Chuck roast first attempt (QView)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

bangster

Fire Starter
Original poster
Mar 23, 2017
33
28
2.77 a pound on sale (briskets are much cheaper for choice), so got a few chuck roasts. my wife does them in a crock pot, so a 4 pounder got done that way yesterday, beef birria (a semi spicy stew). Left overs for awhile, freezes and reheats well.

I got a 5 pounder to do slices as we have company coming today and a concert to attend this evening. Plan on sandwiches, I think I can slice it thin if I let it cool down before slicing.

Salt, pepper, garlic, and paprika for that color, 6 hours before putting on the smoker. Pellet grill with Hickory, Cherry, and Maple pellets. 6 hours at 225 to get to 180 degrees. Wrapped in foil (as it needed to go in there to rest in the cooler anyways) to 190 degrees. It got a little darker in the last hour wrapped, will try to get pictures of it pre and post cutting, but will be eating in shifts.

seasoned and rested


getting to 225


ready for the smoker (I did a bad job seasoning it, and I didn’t tie it up, note for next time)
remote temperature probe in and ready to go


3 hours in, checking pellet level, 145 degrees IT


6 hours in, 180 degrees, time for foil (well, too late for foil, but still did it)
need to learn how to seal up these better, and do a better job estimating how much foil, always too little (cheap skate)
not even an hour later, 190 degrees (probably too high for slicing, we’ll see):

 
Last edited:
Looking good,a old pillow will take up lots of air space in your cooler.
 
What is this newspaper that you speak of? 
roflmao.gif


Let it sit for an hour and a half, and first wave of eaters digging in. First thoughts are next time I will do a low temp smoke and spray with apple juice for an hour, then 225. Also might go to 195/200 degrees, and foil wrap it at a lower temperature, and let it rest longer before eating. I put this on the smoker between meetings this morning, I should have postponed one of them to get it on a little earlier, but was nearly spot on for how long it would take, around 6 hours.

Still 168 degrees, easy enough to carve up, but not real thin:



not enough to make gravy with:


Fairly flavorful beyond just the seasoning, but not as "smokey" as the brisket was


Eventually got some sort of light cheese like provolone and Au Jus, I will maybe try cheese whiz and another with BBQ sauce.

 
Last edited:
Looks darn tasty! I like to smoke till I like how they look and pan it with French onion soup or similar liquid wrapped in a pan till around 200+ for nice shredded/pulled beef sammiches.
 
I think I will try that next time, beef broth or similar in a pan. I have one roast to do faux burnt ends, and one to try something else.

I want to get down these cuts of meat you go to 195-200 degrees then next try a roast you go to medium with, like a prime rib. Also 8 dollar chunk of meat versus 40 or 50, but never made a bad prime rib; roasting, rotisserie, and searing on the grill then roasting.

In the background you can see my natural gas grill, it has pretty much gone unused since getting this smoker, I thought I wouldn't use it as a grill but do, only when I have a limited amount of time to cook do I use it, and burgers.
 
Tri tip is a good option to work with if you can find them at a good price. There best kept under medium and you have to cut them properly against the grain I spin them on the rotisserie a lot but can get them for around $2.99# most of the time. Eye of round can be good smoked med or less as well usally fairly cheap. Here's a shot of a Tri tip.

 
For some reason the first thing I tried was a tri-tip.

Look at that pristine stainless drip catcher whatever you call it. I didn't cover it with foil, and scrape it with a putty knife, and every 6 or so smokes I degrease it.


But I did it to 175 degrees, not 140 medium or 200 nearly pull temps, it was okay and first of many practice attempts. It was all edible and enjoyable.


First of many bad foil jobs


I will certainly try to get to medium next time with one.
 
Good job on the chuckie! After doing a couple, this is a cut I like to take to 200-205 and use for shredding. Foil and a little liquid helps keep it from drying out.

I take tri-tip to 132 and then give it a reverse sear. Rest for 10-15 minutes and slice it up.
 
I wouldn't recommend trying to pull a Tri tip,but I have been wrong before. if you have a food service supply store you could buy a larger and easier to use roll of foil the size works much better.
 
 
What is this newspaper that you speak of? 
roflmao.gif


Let it sit for an hour and a half, and first wave of eaters digging in. First thoughts are next time I will do a low temp smoke and spray with apple juice for an hour, then 225. Also might go to 195/200 degrees, and foil wrap it at a lower temperature, and let it rest longer before eating. I put this on the smoker between meetings this morning, I should have postponed one of them to get it on a little earlier, but was nearly spot on for how long it would take, around 6 hours.

Still 168 degrees, easy enough to carve up, but not real thin:



not enough to make gravy with:


Fairly flavorful beyond just the seasoning, but not as "smokey" as the brisket was


Eventually got some sort of light cheese like provolone and Au Jus, I will maybe try cheese whiz and another with BBQ sauce.

Looks mighty fine from here--well done.  No need for pillows or newspapers when the buzzards are circling around the groceries!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky