or Connect
SmokingMeatForums.com › Forums › Smoking Supplies & Equipment › Pellet Smokers  › Pellet Smoker as a grill to?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Pellet Smoker as a grill to? - Page 3

post #41 of 47
My Yoder YS640 grills wonderfully, with temps over 600.

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
post #42 of 47
Originally Posted by MRudi View Post

Ok, here is a very minor small point but I'm thinking an exposed grease bucket could be an issue.  I have dogs and although I'm sure I can keep them out of the bucket while I'm present, I know them enough that as soon as I go inside they will be all over it making a mess of themselves.  Was wondering if anyone else has had to deal with that.  Feels kind a stupid to exclude a grill for that (and a lot of them at that) but it is something I'm concerned about.

I have found this to be no issue with my dogs who love grease. 😀

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
post #43 of 47
Originally Posted by muralboy View Post

Look a few posts up


"Twenty-five degree swings don't matter much at 225°F+ or searing a Steak...BUT...Low and Slow smoke cured Sausage or Fish at 150 to 170° with a 25° swing and you got garbage. So there is a benefit to 5° control. Just up to the individual to decide their needs and budget...JJ"


Yes, but we were talking about pellet grill owners.  I greatly respect JJ’s opinions, but as far as I know, he has never owned a pellet grill. As far as slow smoked sausage is concerned, I use a cabinet smoker and would not use a pellet grill. Most do not operate reliably at 150F. As far as temp swings, the most extreme swings are at the higher operating ranges. I’ve low smoked plenty of salmon on my CampChef with great results that are indistinguishable from salmon smoked on my Memphis.


Remember too that grills are not at the extreme end of the swings for long. Home ovens operate similarly. My home oven has 25 degrees of swing, but an oven thermometer, which responds slowly, registers a constant temp.


We also need to clarify some things. First of all, there’s a huge difference between wide swings, and wild or erratic swings. With the former, your grill will operate with consistent, repeatable results. There are some grills (PID or otherwise) that have wider temp swings than others. But the swings are consistent and the temp averages out fine. Other grills have erratic swings. On one cycle, it may overshoot 15 and undershoot 5, the next pass over 25 and under 20, etc. This makes the average temp drift over time and produces inconsistent results. The former is fine, the latter is not.


I had great results with my CampChef which had 20-25 degree swings. So if +/- 25 is good, then people naturally assume that +/- 5 must be better, right?  Again I have to ask, what evidence is there that it will produce better results? And in fact, many folks believe it will produce worse results in regards to lower smoke output.


So is any amount of swing too much? I’m sure there’s a practical limit, but in my experience, 20-25F is fine. To me, a more important concern about temperature is variances from left to right, up and down. Many owners report variances of 60 degrees or more. Even though you can learn your grills hot spots, and “use that to your advantage”, I’d rather not bother. If I want multiple cooking zones, I'll buy an FE. 


Again, I agree with most of your original recommendations. I’m only arguing the statement “You want something that will maintain temp within a 5 deg swing”. As far as I know, only one manufacturer claims to have temperatures swings of +/- 5 F.  My current grill – a Memphis Elite – usually maintains temp within +/- 8F.   You’d have a hard time convincing me that another grill is better, just because it can maintain +/- 5 degrees. 

post #44 of 47

I would agree - at higher temps precision is not as important.  But if you are trying to maintain a lower temp, it becomes very important.


My grill operates very reliably at a low temp, as do other pellet grills based on what people have shared.  I would say there are a few grills out there that claim a 5 deg swing. PelletPro and RecTec are two that come to mind. I know there are more. 

Edited by muralboy - 2/24/16 at 7:49pm
post #45 of 47

I have a Green Mountain Daniel Boon Pellet Smoker.. I have used it for both smoking low and slow as well as grilling Steaks.. At first I was saving my old propane grill to use for burgers and steaks and found out quickly there was no need..The Daniel Boon gets plenty hot enough to grill burgers and steaks as well as leave grill marks..

post #46 of 47

I along with Westby and Red have a Rec Tec.

Owned it for about a year.

I do everything on it:

Low and slow for bbq, steaks, burgers, chicken, appetizers, and set it to 425 for great frozen pizzas!

Their customer service is outstanding.

I had one issue with it where it was my mistake. I dumped the end of a bag of pellets in to the hopper (which is 40lbs).

There was a bunch of sawdust in the bottom of the bag that ended up clogging the auger and smoldering out the fire.

The customer service rep diagnosed the problem and had me up and running in no time.

I really enjoy cooking on it.

My $.02

post #47 of 47
I just wanted to chime in about temp swings and temp variance from left to right. Attached is a screenshot of a Tappecue graph from my cook yesterday. Probe 1 was on the right side, probe 2 on the left, and 3&4 were in the roast. Temp swings weren't bad - a couple small swings later in the cook caused by nosey family members. I ran the temp at 230 until about noon and then bumped to 250. Variance from right to left was negligible until later in the cook when the right side got a bit warmer. I think that coincided with the meat getting closer to temp. Right side always runs just a bit hotter, but not until whatever I'm cooking gets to temp. This chart is pretty representative of my cooks and I assume most other Rec Tecs.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Pellet Smokers
SmokingMeatForums.com › Forums › Smoking Supplies & Equipment › Pellet Smokers  › Pellet Smoker as a grill to?