Smoking a turkey big enough to feed 18 guys!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

eldelay

Newbie
Original poster
Oct 7, 2015
6
11
Hello everyone! I would like to jump into a pretty hefty project and would love to have a helping hand to guide me along. Here is my project I'd like to do.

Every Friday night, I am part of a guys Bible study/game night.  We are broken up into teams and take turns making the meals. This week is my turn and would love to smoke a big turkey to feed all 18 of us.  I have a massive smoker that a buddy of mine welded and could definitely hold a bird big enough for the task.  I am in a bit of a competition with another guy who has a reputation for being quite an elaborate cook. So far I haven't let his group beat ours, but in each case we have to one up each other.

From the research I have done, I have seen that I should brine the turkey for a day before smoking it. I was also aware of smoking a large turkey could run into a problem of keeping it in the danger zone too long.

So here are my questions. Im sorry if some of them seem trivial. I would like to keep them all in one place so I can refer back to this post so I can repeat this if it works.

If I plan to smoke this big boy,

what size of turkey would best suit this task?

what temperature should I keep the smoker at to best care for the meat?
Is there a preferred wood that would flavor the meat the best?
Should I brine the turkey? If so, how, and for how long?

Are there any other tips/tricks I could add to make this adventure more exciting? I am open to putting alot of work in this meal. I don't have much to do for the next two days.  (Gotta love your last semester of college!)

Thanks for everyone's input!
 
 
Hello everyone! I would like to jump into a pretty hefty project and would love to have a helping hand to guide me along. Here is my project I'd like to do.

Every Friday night, I am part of a guys Bible study/game night.  We are broken up into teams and take turns making the meals. This week is my turn and would love to smoke a big turkey to feed all 18 of us.  I have a massive smoker that a buddy of mine welded and could definitely hold a bird big enough for the task.  I am in a bit of a competition with another guy who has a reputation for being quite an elaborate cook. So far I haven't let his group beat ours, but in each case we have to one up each other.

From the research I have done, I have seen that I should brine the turkey for a day before smoking it. I was also aware of smoking a large turkey could run into a problem of keeping it in the danger zone too long.

So here are my questions. Im sorry if some of them seem trivial. I would like to keep them all in one place so I can refer back to this post so I can repeat this if it works.

If I plan to smoke this big boy,

what size of turkey would best suit this task? two 15 pound birds. One bird to feed 18 guys would have to be 30+ pounds

what temperature should I keep the smoker at to best care for the meat? I like turkey at 225
Is there a preferred wood that would flavor the meat the best? Whatever you prefer. Pecan or fruit wood works well
Should I brine the turkey? If so, how, and for how long? YES! It makes all the difference. I would brine for 24 hours

Are there any other tips/tricks I could add to make this adventure more exciting? I am open to putting alot of work in this meal. I don't have much to do for the next two days.  (Gotta love your last semester of college!)

Thanks for everyone's input!
See my answers above and good luck. 
 
The USDA recommends turkeys of no more than 12 lbs for smoking. Of course that's at a pit temp of 225 personally I smoke poultry at 325-350 so that rule really isn't the same with the higher temps. The higher temps also crisp up the skin while 225 results in rubbery un edible skin around my house
 
So. As an update I was unable to find a fresh turkey in town, so I will wait for my next rotation. However we made smoked pork tenderloin, it was awesome. Thanks everyone!
 
You mentioned you want a handy place your Smoking info . ( good , bad or indifferent ) . My suggestion is to start a BBQ logbook containing all aspects in your procedure ,your recipe , the Weather , fuel used , tricks learned and anything else you want to track .

You will have the greatest learning tool for BBQ as you can get . Hands on and advised , can't lose , win , win situation ! :biggrin:

Have fun and . . .
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky